News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Skeptical Take on ChatGPT: Ezra Klein Interviews Gary M... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @02:36AM (#34286056)
"For many decades, part of the premise behind AI was that artificial intelligence should take inspiration from natural intelligence. John McCarthy, one of the co-founders of AI, wrote groundbreaking papers on why AI needed common sense; Marvin Minsky, another of the field's co-founders of AI wrote a book scouring the human mind for inspiration, and clues for how to build a better AI. Herb Simon won a Nobel Prize for behavioral economics. One of his key books was called Models of Thought, which aimed to explain how "Newly developed computer languages express theories of mental processes, so that computers can then simulate the predicted human behavior."

A large fraction of current AI researchers, or at least those currently in power, don't (so far as I can tell) give a damn about any of this. Instead, the current focus is on what I will call (with thanks to Naveen Rao for the term) Alt Intelligence.

Alt Intelligence isn't about building machines that solve problems in ways that have to do with human intelligence. It's about using massive amounts of data - often derived from human behavior - as a substitute for intelligence. Right now, the predominant strand of work within Alt Intelligence is the idea of scaling. The notion that the bigger the system, the closer we come to true intelligence, maybe even consciousness.

There is nothing new, per se, about studying Alt Intelligence, but the hubris associated with it is." - Gary Marcus

https://garymarcus.substack.com/p/the-new-science-of-alt-int...

Re:A Skeptical Take on ChatGPT: Ezra Klein Interviews Gary M... by seydor on Saturday January 07, 2023 @02:48AM (#34286094)
Also, those people had little idea what human intelligence is like. Human introspection can only get you so far, and we still don't have the tools to probe the brain in large enough scale to be able to figure it out with anything but remote speculation.

Hubris goes both ways, but it's the use of the word "hubris" here that is eye popping. Do these guys consider themselves some High Priests of intelligence?

It's perfectly fine to dismiss linguists etc after decades of no progress. As the saying goes , every time you remove a linguist the performance goes up

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Jelinek

Re:A Skeptical Take on ChatGPT: Ezra Klein Interviews Gary M... by mellosouls on Saturday January 07, 2023 @03:26AM (#34286248)
"Alt Intelligence isn't about building machines that solve problems in ways that have to do with human intelligence. It's about using massive amounts of data - often derived from human behavior - as a substitute for intelligence...There is nothing new, per se, about studying Alt Intelligence, but the hubris associated with it is."

I can see how Marcus is tiresome at times (with perhaps his own hubris issues), but I agree with his premise, and that's beautifully put. I love "Alt Intelligence".