From what I recall, that googlebomb is widely believed to have been "defused" algorithmically, by devaluing anchor text which didn't match the target page at all (e.g, "miserable failure" didn't appear on GWB's page). Those measures only really defused googlebombs to unsuspecting sites; they wouldn't help for sites which are intentionally trying to rank for a term that they are relevant for!
So Google should start manually tweaking sites supporting public figures in order to garner favors from them in case they get in a position of power?
Talk about setting a bad precedent.
"This isn't a plea to treat all potential presidents with kid gloves, it's a plea to make sure that pranks against public figures of all kinds are squashed once they become known."
You're still missing the point. It should not be up to the search engine to do that: just let the search engine reflect what the web thinks.
killing it would probably look even worse, as google would be attacked for censorship.
also, the site in question comes up first on bing, yahoo, and duckduckgo.
Screencapped: https://img.skitch.com/20120105-x7fb17is53yx99pw61bfur6g57.j...
edit: Ah ha, it only shows up if you have safe search off.
Organising information is one thing - allowing pranksters to prank public figures is something else.
We might all laugh because we don't share the targets politics - but one day it will happen to someone we do support or care about.
No thanks.
My argument is that search engines of all stripes shouldn't allow themselves to host public pranks. That itself is a bad precedent.
If I were Google's team I would kill this just because it looks very bad for Google. Let's assume Santorum goes on to win the Republican Primaries and then the Presidency. Is President Santorum going to be receptive or agressive if someone from Google (or the search industry in general) turns up on their doorstep?
It's the sort of thing that stays with people for a long time, rightly or wrongly.
This isn't a plea to treat all potential presidents with kid gloves, it's a plea to make sure that pranks against public figures of all kinds are squashed once they become known.