News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Go 1.20 Cryptography by tptacek on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @02:26PM (#34250162)
I think Filippo has the right side of this debate, but "SHA3 means likely memory corruption flaws" is not a great argument.
Re:Go 1.20 Cryptography by some_furry on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @03:32PM (#34251069)
Yeah that's not my argument at all.

My argument is specifically: "SHA3 implementations are necessary for Ed448, which increases code size and therefore also increases attack surface". The memory corruption bug was just a specific recent data point about the attack surface increase.

The more meta point is "just add one more algorithm" isn't a free decision. It involves non-obvious trade-offs.

I hope that makes it clearer.

Re:Go 1.20 Cryptography by tptacek on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @03:34PM (#34251098)
Oh, I follow the argument, I just don't think it's persuasive. You wouldn't look at a system that deliberately built on SHA3 and say it was worse than a Blake2 scheme because of SHA3 code quality concerns, so I don't think it's a particularly compelling reason to pick a curve.
Re:Go 1.20 Cryptography by some_furry on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @03:36PM (#34251121)
It's difficult to determine whether you follow an argument when you summarize it in a way that sounds incorrect.

If that's an attempt at highlighting that what you summarized is not persuasive, your tactic also isn't very persuasive. Instead it comes across as snarky, dismissive, or that you misunderstood. It might be worth reconsidering this tactic.

The main reason I wouldn't pick Ed448 is simpler: Nothing else really uses it.

Re:Go 1.20 Cryptography by tptacek on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @03:38PM (#34251154)
For what it's worth, I'm responding to this:

    There was a recent flurry of buffer overflows in SHA3
    implementations. I'm aware of at least PHP being affected.
     
    Wanting Ed448 for political reasons, or purely for psychological
    comfort reasons, is a perfectly understandable stance to take as a
    non-expert.
     
    Unfortunately, the details that experts are privy to matter a ton, and
    severely outweigh any notions of having eggs in multiple
    baskets. We're open to having our risk calculus checked, but we're
    nearly unanimous on this one.
Who's "we" here? I think Filippo has a mainstream take on the 448 curves, but I don't know that your take on SHA3 is widely shared.
Re:Go 1.20 Cryptography by some_furry on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @03:39PM (#34251167)
We here is people who don't advise using Ed448. It's tautology.

You don't have to agree with the specific reason I cited. That isn't encapsulated by "we". I was providing an additional argument in case the mainstream take isn't sufficient.

You cut the "To add to what Filippo said" part out of the excerpt you quoted, which was the necessary context to understand I was making an additional argument.

Re:Go 1.20 Cryptography by tptacek on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @03:41PM (#34251191)
I don't agree with the specific reason you cited, which is what I wrote about.