Re:Detangle: tl;dr your legal docs with AI
by kemitchell on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @01:41PM
(#34235851)
* * *
Re:Detangle: tl;dr your legal docs with AI
by freejazz on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @01:53PM
(#34236069)
Lawyers don't have a monopoloy over business knowledge, they have a monopoly over providing legal services.
Re:Detangle: tl;dr your legal docs with AI
by okennedy on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @02:59PM
(#34237128)
Lawyers also have a _legally binding obligation_ to provide accurate, context-aware, complete advice.
Re:Detangle: tl;dr your legal docs with AI
by freejazz on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @03:25PM
(#34237472)
Which, when they don't deliver, gives you a cause of action for malpractice.
Re:Detangle: tl;dr your legal docs with AI
by jackbrookes on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @02:47PM
(#34236960)
Why do you think AI cannot be as good as a lawyer for all these things? Take the technology to its logical end and it can be better than a lawyer
Re:Detangle: tl;dr your legal docs with AI
by notahacker on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @05:15PM
(#34238904)
> Why do you think AI cannot be as good as a lawyer for all these things? Take the technology to its logical end and it can be better than a lawyer
Because the "logical end" of an LLM that can match words with other words isn't even close to AGI that actually understands the current version of the relevant law and its specific implications for a specific entity in a specific jurisdiction. But it can spout convincing looking bullshit based on having parsed a load of text with a certain amount of semantic similarity which is completely irrelevant in legal terms.
A random teenager on Reddit who prefaces his posts with "IANAL, but I think..." is closer to the relevant level of understanding of legal documents and jurisdictions than GPT-3, but nobody ever wonders why people don't think teenagers on Reddit are better at offering legal advice than lawyers...
Anybody who has been in business-roles that involve reviewing legal documents will tell you that.
TL;DR three things:
Really, I'd run away from something like this as fast as you can.