News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by spodek on Monday January 02, 2012 @04:48PM (#3417522)
"I, too, disregarded Stallman as way too extreme... Only a short while ago I would've declared this as pure paranoia - but with all that's been going on recently, it's no longer paranoia."

I considered him extreme until I thought more about it, then came to agree with him on most major points...

... that was in 1993.

Glad to see others here.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by sadfasdf on Monday January 02, 2012 @06:16PM (#3417826)
http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html

That essay is what made me a firm supporter.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by jonhendry on Monday January 02, 2012 @06:21PM (#3417842)
Okay, he wrote a scary story.

What has he done to promote laws to prevent what he fears, and to fight laws that lead to what he fears?

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by spodek on Monday January 02, 2012 @06:44PM (#3417916)
He co-authored a license that anyone can use to share software, prose, and other copyrightable material.

That license, and others derived from it, are at the root of most non-proprietary software and many types of user-created content. Using the internet means you've used software that likely could not have been created without such licenses. Wikipedia is another example of something using a license derived from the one he helped create.

Helping create flourishing communities of people legally sharing each others' work, collectively creating great works, influences legislation. Imagine if no licenses existed for people to legally remix each other's work without explicit permission. Disney, the MPAA, the RIAA, and others would have had greater ability to lengthen copyright terms, increase penalties for infringement, and so on.

Microsoft had a strong play for extending from the desktop to servers when Unix was fragmented. I wonder what might have happened if apache didn't exist to compete with Microsoft -- how much more influence Microsoft might have had over U.S. legislation.

He's done a lot more than just help write the GPL, but that alone contributed a lot.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by jonhendry on Monday January 02, 2012 @06:50PM (#3417931)
Yes, but what has he done that has been directed towards US laws, regulations, and policies, to protect the right to read?
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by bad_user on Monday January 02, 2012 @07:28PM (#3418053)
While I don't agree with the parent, as the BSD license and BSD-licensed software would have happened anyway, the GPL is the perfect example of what hackers can do against awful legislation.

You see, the GPL takes the copyright system and turns it on its head. That's why it is named a copyleft license, an obvious pun.

How does it do that? Well, copyright prevents distribution. The GPL rides this restriction and says that you may not distribute GPL-licensed software unless (1) you distribute it with no extra restrictions + (2) the distributed binary is either accompanied by source-code or the source-code is available on request. The GPL COULD NOT demand this if it weren't for the copyright law and in regards to freedom / protecting users rights, it works out great because nobody can abuse the GPL without legal repercussions.

It's actually beautiful if you think about it and innovative - it enabled open-source / free software to really disrupt the software industry, creating the equivalent of the public commons. And this movement went viral and moved to books, music and movies. And this would have happened without the GPL, but on a much lower scale. The GPL is the spark that started the fire.

BTW - to change the world you don't need to change the laws. The alternative is to make them obsolete and technology has a habit of doing that ;-)

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by billpatrianakos on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @09:59AM (#3419786)
You mentioned BSD and I'm wondering what's wrong with BSD? A lot of FOSS people are all about hating anything that isn't GPL but let's not forget that these licenses serve a purpose. GPL has its place but I personally distribute things I make under BSD all the time. I don't mind and in fact encourage people to take my source, close it up and make a bunch of money off it if they want or take it and give back better code. I like the idea that both of those very things happen under BSD. I understand that closed source can mean various nefarious (rhyming kind of on purpose) things go on but it isn't necessarily so.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by bad_user on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @11:08AM (#3420076)
I haven't said there's anything wrong with BSD. Where did I say that? As you said, it serves a different purpose.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by _sh on Monday January 02, 2012 @07:01PM (#3417967)
Apart from better sanitation and medicine and education and irrigation and public health and roads and a freshwater system and baths and public order and a legal document designed to protect the right to read and modify and a philosophy that has influenced an entire generation of creators...?
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by EdiX on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @01:44AM (#3418879)
The Free Software Foundation, among other things, sponsors some "political" campaigns against DRM and software patents.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by pingswept on Monday January 02, 2012 @06:25PM (#3417851)
From what I understand, RMS has spent a large fraction of his working life in the last 20 years traveling the world to speak to people about free software. He could be dismissed as too extreme, but dismissing him as someone who hasn't fought for his beliefs is way off.

His speaking schedule is often published in the FSF newsletter; he appears to speak to a group about free software around once per week.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by jonhendry on Monday January 02, 2012 @06:42PM (#3417904)
That's just it, he spoke about free software, not these larger issues. And getting people to adopt free software is an orthogonal issue.

Even if GPL software had 99% market share in the US, and everyone in the country were running the same kind of computer as Stallman, the government could still step in and pass all kinds of draconian laws.

Getting regular people to adopt the GPL ethos is fine, but if the ethos doesn't permeate government as well, Stallman might as well be touring around promoting the Spice Girls for all governments will be prevented from doing intrusive things.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by super_mario on Monday January 02, 2012 @07:26PM (#3418051)
Are you seriously expecting Stallman or any one person to "fight" the government and prevent it from passing some draconian law. You seem to thoroughly misunderstand how a modern democracy operates. It's up to the people to prevent a government like that by not electing politicians that have draconian views on the subject. And the only way people can ever do that is if they are aware of all the issues. And Richard is doing a lot to make us all aware of the issues. In my mind he is doing all he can do, and at the right level of involvement, where he has the most know how to influence the minds of "regular" people.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by jonhendry on Monday January 02, 2012 @08:19PM (#3418192)
Compare the FSF to the EFF.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by stfp on Monday January 02, 2012 @10:08PM (#3418443)
They do different things? That are both needed and important?
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by tjr on Monday January 02, 2012 @07:03PM (#3417971)
Richard speaks about more than just free software per se; recent speeches include Copyright vs Community, A Free Digital Society, and The Danger of Software Patents.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by noibl on Monday January 02, 2012 @08:32PM (#3418225)
The point is to make such laws unworkable through practical measures, not to generate political anger in the uncertain hope that that will balance the efforts of proprietorial lobbyists and state security extremists indefinitely.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by rjbond3rd on Monday January 02, 2012 @07:26PM (#3418050)
> That's just it, he spoke about free software, not these larger issues...

What's larger than freedom?

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by jonhendry on Monday January 02, 2012 @08:22PM (#3418202)
There are many freedoms. I suspect Stallman would be happy if he achieved all his free software goals, even if he lost freedoms that most other people consider more important.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by tankenmate on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @02:45AM (#3418960)
I think you completely misunderstand RMS then, I think you would find that he would argue that all freedoms are necessary and worth fighting for. In many speeches I have heard him give he has said that he could fight for other freedoms but the freedom he could do the best job of fighting for are software freedoms. I would suggest you read more of RMS's work and listen to more of his talks.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by jiggy2011 on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @09:29AM (#3419699)
Yes, exactly.

Let's assume Stallman had qualified as a Medical Doctor rather than a Computer Programmer.

Perhaps he would be making the same argument about pharmaceutical patents?

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by anatoly on Monday January 02, 2012 @06:57PM (#3417953)
It isn't that he wrote a scary story.

It's that his story looked much less plausible in 1997 than it does now. I remember reading the story at that time. I thought it had something going for it, but was very far-fetched and unrealistic. 14 years later, it seems way more plausible.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by cabalamat on Monday January 02, 2012 @06:52PM (#3417937)
He was and is a major inspiration for the international pirate party movement, which if the power of the MAFIAA is to be destroyed, is the most likely actor to do it by political means.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by adrianbye on Monday January 02, 2012 @05:48PM (#3417727)
same for me, except around 2003. RMS is a difficult guy but he tends to be right.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by Zigurd on Monday January 02, 2012 @07:00PM (#3417963)
RMS is difficult because he is consistent, because he is right about difficult topics, and because people have a natural tendency to be comforted by authoritarians. But the issues RMS writes and speaks about are fundamental to human rights, and to the continued ability to create and innovate and create value without getting prior permission.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by cookiecaper on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @06:47AM (#3419337)
I think RMS is difficult because he is not cooperative with people who don't share his views in their totality and because like many socially-awkward engineers, he has a penchant for making some really offensive and petty statements over what should simply be an ideological disagreement.

I agree with Stallman in many ways but I also have some important and major disagreements. I am sure that he would call me an enemy to free software, even though I regularly contribute to it, and that he would therefore consider my actions absolutely immoral and inexcusable. But I don't think it's immoral and inexcusable to charge money for things in a meaningful way (i.e., a way that actually generates money), at least not in the current context. I've read Stallman's arguments and don't find them particularly convincing.

I also don't believe that GNU is entitled to a prefix every time a complete system that uses the Linux kernel and GNU toolchain is mentioned.

So where does that leave me? As far as I can tell, Stallman would refuse to work with me, disavow any relationship with me, and consider me an immoral provocateur that harms free software no matter how much good I do for it in actuality (due to my disavowal of freedom 2 as an essential element in moral software).

That kind of hardcore, unyielding, exclusive ideology makes it really hard to get anywhere with people. You can't show someone the error of their ways if you refuse to associate or cooperate with them.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by neilk on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @07:46AM (#3419451)
No, there are lots of authors who do that and still have a following.

1. As an advocate, RMS scores own goals far too often.

RMS seems to go out of his way to present himself as an eccentric who has no comprehension of social norms.

I've also seen an entire roomful of people who were ready to eviscerate a new Microsoft technology (this was back when trusted computing was being introduced) suddenly flip around to sympathy with the Microsoft guy when Stallman weighed in.

2. Being RMS' friend is almost as bad as being his enemy.

He will condemn someone who has a slightly different position, or has made compromises, with equal vituperation as someone who is directly opposed.

I also know someone who got into trouble with his own repressive government due to RMS being unable to keep his mouth shut on issues he didn't understand. (Please don't ask for details.)

It's sad because, like the OP, I think RMS is fundamentally right about these issues.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by _delirium on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @01:15PM (#3420630)
I think those are true, but I think it's basically RMS's personality, so you get the bad with the good. I don't think he's really going out of his way to present himself as such; as far as I can tell he really doesn't have any real comprehension of social norms. I hear similar tales from MIT alumni about even casual encounters with him in hallways or elevators being pretty weird.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by jaekwon on Monday January 02, 2012 @10:06PM (#3418434)
Consider me in, since 2012-01-02.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by forcefsck on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @07:43AM (#3419444)
Better late than never.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by pyrhho on Monday January 02, 2012 @05:26PM (#3417678)
Since you recognised this issue so long ago, I'm sure you have some recommendations regarding how we can solve it?
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by spodek on Monday January 02, 2012 @06:26PM (#3417858)
I'm not sure which issue you mean by "this issue," because the freedoms involved in free software touch many issues.

I also can't recommend for others not knowing their needs and interests, but I can tell you some things I do. Maybe some things will translate to what you do.

I use free software as much as possible, running gnu/linux on my computers since 1996. I stopped dual booting about ten years after that.

I give some time to support freedombox -- http://joshuaspodek.com/tag/freedombox -- when I can.

I keep apprised of activities of Stallman, Eben Moglen, and a few others.

I attend conferences when I can, like Debconf.

I hardly code, but I've released a bit GPL'ed.

I support and contribute to Wikipedia.

I talk about free software to people who want to know more.

My art pieces -- http://joshuaspodek.com/tag/unionsquareinmotion and http://joshuaspodek.com/new_bryant_park_in_motion_videos -- run free software.

There's a short list. I'm not trying to save the world all by myself, just to avoid infringing on other people's freedom. All of the above together adds up to a modest amount of time and other resources. I have other priorities for most of my time, but, as I mentioned, I think by making myself aware of the issues, I've reduced how much I'd infringe on others' freedoms.

If you're looking for suggestions, I think asking the questions you asked in an open-minded way will start you off. I expect the more you do, the more you'll learn you can do.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by joe_the_user on Monday January 02, 2012 @05:57PM (#3417757)
Whatever the poster's ideas might be, I have to point out that it is a fallacy to imply that the person recognizing the problem necessarily can come up with the solution or has an obligation to come up with the solution - even if the person has recognized the problem for a long time.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by lukifer on Monday January 02, 2012 @05:35PM (#3417697)
I'll tell one thing which won't solve it: religious zealotry and advocations for everyone in the world to commit to FSF purity.

Open software advocates should treat closed and controlled systems in the same fashion that techies implore content creators to treat piracy: an unstoppable force of nature that must be accepted and competed with, rather than feared and demonized.

Also underlying both issues: the need for improved business models to sustain free software and open content. People like to get paid, and t-shirts + donations doesn't always cut it.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by Stormbringer on Monday January 02, 2012 @06:21PM (#3417843)
Disclaimer: I'm no RMS fanboy by a long stretch of the imagination.

What you're saying is that they should throw their arms up in the air and say "welp, that's how the real world works in reality, so might as well give up and accept it".

But I think you're being unfair. The normal open advocates don't fear and demonize closed source. They may secretly pity it, they may secretly hate it, I don't know.

The RMS vision of open source, when you get right down to it, is that of two sandpits. In one sandpit, everyone shares their toys. In the other sandpit... who cares what they do?

If someone comes from the closed source world and wants to play in the open source sandpit, they have to play by the rules (sharing and openness).

I think RMS gets frustrated sometimes, because he doesn't want the other people playing in the open playpit giving their stuff away to the people in the selfish (no sharing) playpit. I think his thinking is that it would mean that there is less incentive for them "over there" to examine and repent of their selfish ways.

Sometimes the people in the no-sharing playpit have rich relatives that buy them nice toys for Christmas. But RMS views that as okay, if the open playpit turns out to have a need for one of those, he is confident that the open source people have the ability to make something even better, if they can be bothered to do so.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by lukifer on Monday January 02, 2012 @08:16PM (#3418183)
I am, admittedly, attacking a straw man, though in the case of RMS and a few others, it's not far off from reality.

> In one sandpit, everyone shares their toys. In the other sandpit... who cares what they do?

That's the attitude I mean. The fact is, a lot of people care: engineers, customers, and investors are making really interesting things happen in that sandpit. For FOSS advocates to avoid the development happening there is a hindrance to progress, not in aid of it. Maybe if RMS let himself own an Android or iPhone (perhaps with SIM removed), he would understand why these new platforms are a big deal, and be better equipped to create truly open equivalents, instead of insisting on living in his purist tech world of the 70's (wget-ing web pages? really?).

Closed source isn't evil. It's selfish. And we expect a certain level of selfishness from both individuals and companies. I fully support shifting our values in tech and elsewhere to a greater esteem for community and the commons. But calls for all software to be open and free is unrealistic: many people can't or won't create value without a selfish incentive. Time spent advocating against closed platforms is better spent making open platforms better.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by Stormbringer on Monday January 02, 2012 @09:43PM (#3418384)
I think that RMS is quite happy to cut all ties with the closed source world in order to build a brave new one that is an idealised programmers paradise. I look at the GPL and it seems to me the clear intent there is to have this separation, this "software apartheid" if you will.

You and I on the other hand, might look at it and say "okay, but how do these brave new programmers eat? Who pays their rent?" Back in the day, RMS used to just do some hand waving and point out that if (sorry: "once") the economic benefits of open source are realised that companies will do this because they realise it is in their best interests.

I'd be delighted to be wrong, but it seems that only a tiny minority of Open Source developers are actually hired by enlightened companies to work on their Open Source projects full time. Google being an obvious big contributor in that regard. But here's the thing with RMS, he is such an extremist that even Google's contribution isn't enough. He doesn't want a measly couple of buillion dollars worth of commitment, he wants it all, the heart mind body and soul must be dedicated to the cause or you are unworthy.

The sandbox metaphor breaks down when we look at one of the things that RMS objects to about Google, that they use Open Source, and they provide 'free(ish)' software services in return, but because those web/software services sit behind the "big-iron" curtain Google are never obligated to release their changes and improvements. Hence the GPL becomes ineffective in that scenario.

The problem of course is the risk of ghetto-isation of the open source developers. You and I might be reluctant to leap in boots and all because of petty economic concerns and so keep at least one foot in the closed source world. This lets us see lots of exciting things happening there. But don't forget that there is lots of stuff happening in the open source world. Closed source may look more exciting now, but RMS is taking the long position that in the end his legions of trusty hackers working together will create something much better than the corporations all doing their own small secret things.

And something genuinely spectacular happened last year. Last year was (finally) the long predicted, long awaited year of Linux hitting the mainstream. Except of course it wasn't Linux on the desktop, but Linux on mobile (Android).

Unfortunately, as open as it might be, it seems to me that Android is deeply flawed as far as alignment with the GNU philosophy of openness, what with the carriers doing all kinds of horrible things (some behind the scenes, some brazenly out in public). I hear stories of Microsoft making more money off Android than the do off Windows mobile (or whatever it is called this week), simply by threatening legal action, and patents of dubious parentage. Not to mention some of the openness being more open than others (e.g. Google releasing the code to some partners but not others, and not the public)

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by stfp on Monday January 02, 2012 @10:16PM (#3418464)
Stallman is a good extreme, in that he creates and lives by an idealized system (call it "pure" if you want), which enables a lot of less ideal, more real-life versions to exist in between his and the "commercial software" world, without any negative side-effect to the world at large.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by HalibetLector on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @04:03AM (#3419099)
I used to think this too, until I realized something I didn't thoroughly understand until I read the OP. The reason Stallman wants a "pure" system with no closed source code is because if there's even one proprietary bit of executable code, you can't guarantee your system isn't spying (or capable of spying) on you. Or tracking you or restricting how you use your data.

Seen through the argument I just made, when you say closed and controlled systems are an unstoppable force of nature and must be accepted, what you're really saying is digital spying/tracking/restriction is an unstoppable force of nature and must be accepted. It really is an all or nothing proposition at this point.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by cschwarm on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @05:08AM (#3423516)
I'd like to remark that your argument is not valid: To know that your system won't spy on you, all you need is open code (transparency). You don't need it to be free.

Theoretically, you can have a completely unfree system that is completely open at the same time.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by HalibetLector on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @10:35AM (#3424447)
I don't see how that invalidates my argument. I don't mention paid vs unpaid at all, just closed and open.
Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by cschwarm on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @11:46AM (#3424775)
I didn't mention paid vs. unpaid, either. I was speaking about 'free' as in 'free software' vs. proprietary. My point was that you can have a proprietary system that is open.

For reference, this was the argument I was replying to:

> … if there's even one proprietary bit of executable code, you can't guarantee your system isn't spying (or capable of spying) on you.

Re:Richard Stallman Was Right All Along by cabalamat on Monday January 02, 2012 @06:55PM (#3417945)
Via the technological route, or the political route.

The technological route involves software to enable darknets, and hardware/software to enable ad hoc mesh networking.

The political route involves electing representatives that care about these issues, which the Pirate Party have had success doing, e.g. in Germany and Sweden.