I've read my grandmothers' diary, she had quite a bit to say about the previous time people underestimated the size of that maximum mass. There are very large numbers of people that will be happy to sustain such a dumb ideology if it is presented to them in such a way that it presses the right buttons. Fear is a very powerful motivator, as are frustration and jealousy and clever people will be more than happy to take advantage of these facts to push their revolting ideologies.
More effective than fear of government punishment is shame. Few care about pissing off the government in this country so that seems like a non-starter.
Oh, we have plenty of evidence that some things can stop Nazism. The question is if you want to dedicate another couple of 10's of thousands of acres to war graves.
But, well, there's still a neo-Nazi march in Berlin pretty much every year. And it's larger than Charlottesville one was.
Although of course, attempts are made to associate broader and broader statements with extremism, such that even having an immigration policy at all is interpreted as racism, so the number of supposed racists is dramatically inflated.
If the right similarly broadened it’s interpretation of statements, 80-90% of the country could be claimed to be communists, for supporting the most minimal state assistance of the poor, which almost everyone does support at some level.
Citation badly needed. Really.
But most Western countries still have actual, real communist parties so you can't paint completely crazy pictures of them, because their members will simply raise their hand and say "no we're not like that at all".
(1) people are innocent until proven guilty
(2) if one group is judge, jury, and executioner that's a problem
(3) authoritarians seek to quell dissent by censoring
(4) removal/ejection/ostracism from group is censorship
(5) contrary to your assertion removal/ejection/ostracism is a form of engagement
(6) in fact within the realm of free speech r/e/o is the most extreme form of engagement
(7) this is because it is the quashing of that ejected person's ability to freely express themselves
> The first has guaranteed results, the second is uncertain.
(8) hard disagree, the first is guaranteed to generate all sorts of backlash (perhaps not the results wished for)
(9) the second is guaranteed to generate debate, exactly what authoritarians and the censorious dislike
(10) ps: (quibble) the “Nazis” were terminated with extreme prejudice in 1945, any variants thereof nowadays are neo-Nazis
===
All the above is transparently obvious to me. It concerns me that in a so-called liberal society many clearly are either unwilling or are unable to see that everything I have outline is true in all cases. The fruits of this ignorance are all around us.
to my mind i made a very reasonable defense of "free speech even for speech i find objectionable and disagree with but ultimately must tolerate in the interests of the inviolable principle of freedom of expression for all not just for my bubble" – that's the position i'm arguing for and nothing more.
"at all costs" != "free speech even for speech i find objectionable […]"
"at all costs" goes far further and is not something i am arguing for
> is unlikely to work.
i'll go one stronger – “free speech at all costs” cannot work. but that's fine because that's not what i'm arguing for. what i'm arguing for ("free speech even for speech i find objectionable […]") must work because that's the foundation a free society is built on. otherwise, all bets are off and the spoils go to those most willing to use covert and/or draconian measures to achieve their ends