Re:How Samuel Palmisano of I.B.M. Stayed a Step Ahead
by ww520 on Sunday January 01, 2012 @06:28PM
(#3414161)
Or you can think of it as a small investment to reap the huge reward later.
Extortion is someone putting a gun on your head to demand for the money. Investment is you CHOOSE to put money in for later reward.
Re:How Samuel Palmisano of I.B.M. Stayed a Step Ahead
by JoshTriplett on Sunday January 01, 2012 @08:32PM
(#3414421)
Even ignoring that, it still makes sense to avoid selling to Dell, HP, or similar. Those companies compete directly with IBM in other areas, so why sell a major division of the company to them and make them stronger? Plus, Dell and HP already sell desktops and laptops which makes them less likely to fully adopt the ThinkPad brand like Lenovo has.
For that matter, IBM actually derives ongoing revenue from the sale of ThinkPads, due to owning part of Lenovo; I don't know the terms of the sale, but they might also get some ongoing licensing revenue on brands and designs. (Also, they still use IBM's tech support, right down to the phone number: 1-800-IBM-SERV.) That kind of ongoing revenue would make Dell or HP even less likely to want to push ThinkPad laptops over their own systems.
This doesn't surprise me, but I'm still blown away by this concept. It's highly unlikely that Lenovo happened to offer the same amount as whoever else was the true highest bidder, so this was essentially a huge extortion payment from IBM to China. The deal involved roughly $1 billion of assests, so it's not unreasonable to think that IBM paid of order $100 million to get into the Chinese government's good graces.