News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sanderson shares intimate details about contracting with ... by beezlebroxxxxxx on Friday December 23, 2022 @11:14AM (#34107383)
Sanderson's books appeal to a certain reader who is extremely invested in world building and "hard" magic systems. I would say his plots and characters usually play second fiddle to those things, and he infamously has his writing tics. I think the majority of his books would be vastly improved with a better editor, frankly (especially the last Stormlight one, jesus). But I'm generally in the minority in that respect. He has extremely devoted fans. I would set your expectations for the books at about Avengers movie quality, which for some people sounds amazing and that's exactly what they are looking for. Personally, I enjoyed the core Malazan books far more as fantasy with very intense world building sensibilities and a more mature edge. But I don't go to Sanderson looking for fantasy with literary sensibilities.
Re:Sanderson shares intimate details about contracting with ... by nottorp on Friday December 23, 2022 @06:35PM (#34111955)
Yep, world building and system building is what he does.

The only book of his that wasn't like that... and which i liked most... Elantris... was never really continued.

Re:Sanderson shares intimate details about contracting with ... by terafo on Friday December 23, 2022 @08:41PM (#34112930)
It will eventually be continued, just like Warbreaker. And it's not like it is forgotten, there are at least two characters from Sel in Lost Metal(his latest mistborn book).
Re:Sanderson shares intimate details about contracting with ... by shostack on Monday December 26, 2022 @03:43AM (#34135889)
And don't forget the Warbreaker crossovers in The Stormlight Archives.
Re:Sanderson shares intimate details about contracting with ... by aardvark179 on Friday December 23, 2022 @07:17PM (#34112314)
Yeah. For big fantasy series I much preferred the Malazan books. Sanderson is fine, but if somebody really likes those books I know I can mostly ignore their other recommendations because our tastes just differ too much.

That’s not to say hard magic systems can’t be done well, I think Robert Jackson Bennett does a superb job in the Foundaryside books.

Re:Sanderson shares intimate details about contracting with ... by frosted-flakes on Saturday December 24, 2022 @01:42AM (#34114617)
One of his books that actually did have great characters and plot was Skyward, the first book in a series of 4 (#4 is not yet released). It focuses heavily on personal relationships with a small cast of characters, and the plot is tightly centred on the main character. But it was like Sanderson threw all that out the window with book #2 (Starsight) and #3 (Cytonic) in favour of world-building and a weird plot that expanded in scope extremely rapidly, and I heavily disliked those books because of it. #1 was a 9/10 for me, but I rate #2 as 3.5/10 and #3 as 5/10. But that's me; my siblings who also read the books all seemed to love them.