News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pico8 Music Synthesizer by codedokode on Friday December 23, 2022 @04:23AM (#34103855)
I am not a user of Pico8, and probably never going to use this app, but wanted just to comment on usability.

Judging by demo videos, I think that the UI is not very efficient. For example, let's count how many gestures an user has to make to add an oscillator and connect it to a speaker:

- click "+"

- carefully read the menu, locate and click "oscillator"

- maybe drag the oscillator to a desired location

- click "+"

- carefully read the menu, locate and click "cable"

- drag the cable to the oscillator

- catch another end of the cable, which is swinging and trying to escape from your mouse cursor

- drag it to a tiny speaker's socket

This takes too much time. I believe the UI can be significantly improved. Or maybe this can be turned into a game where the devices are playing against you, jump and crawl trying to escape from you (but you can bind them with cables), and so on.

Also, "+" button is too close to a trash button, and it is easy to accidentally click it.

Re:Pico8 Music Synthesizer by conradfr on Friday December 23, 2022 @04:35AM (#34103913)
Oh this is a trash ... I thought it was a keyboard icon that would allow me to setup a midi keyboard but was non-functioning.

Yeah adding a cable is a bit frustrating instead of just adding one when you click on a jack input (like in Reason IIRC).

Re:Pico8 Music Synthesizer by johanpeitz on Friday December 23, 2022 @04:47AM (#34104003)
Thanks for the feedback, appreciate it.

I can totally understand where you’re coming from, but the program is not designed to be efficient. I think of it more as a toy, or and interactive machine that you can figure out how it works. The fact that you can make loops and beats with it is almost a bonus.