* Not legal advice or proposed by a practicing attorney of any U.S. state.
IMO — I’d prefer not to be called engineer but we live in a capitalist world — if someone is willing to pay enough they can call me whatever they want.
You cannot however represent yourself as a licensed professional (engineering or otherwise) without actually having that license. That's what's illegal.
(1) The professional title "engineer" may be held by anyone who
1. has successfully completed a course of study in a technical or natural science subject with a standard period of study of at least six semesters, corresponding to at least 180 ECTS credits, at a German state or state-recognised higher education institution, whereby this course of study must be predominantly in the fields of mathematics, information technology, natural sciences and technology, ... [1]
My own interpretation is that not all of these four aspects need to be included equally in a course of study. If the question is of practical importance to you, you should contact the Chamber of Engineers of the respective (federal) state for an authoritative answer.[1] Original:
(1) Die Berufsbezeichnung »Ingenieurin« oder »Ingenieur« darf führen, wer
1. ein Studium in einer technischen oder naturwissenschaftlichen Fachrichtung mit einer Regelstudienzeit von mindestens sechs Semestern, was mindestens 180 ECTS-Punkten entspricht, an einer deutschen staatlichen oder staatlich anerkannten Hochschule mit Erfolg abgeschlossen hat, wobei dieses Studium überwiegend von den Bereichen Mathematik, Informatik, Naturwissenschaften und Technik geprägt sein muss, ...
Source: https://www.landesrecht-bw.de/jportal/portal/t/3ba/page/bsba... (in German)My translation:
The job title _software developer_ is not a protected job title in Germany and Austria.
According to German law, the job title _software engineer_ may only be used by those who have successfully completed a technical degree. In Austria, the title of engineer can also be acquired through training at an HTL [Höhere Technische Lehranstalt, aprox.: Higher Technical College].
Original: Die Berufsbezeichnung _Softwareentwickler_ ist in Deutschland und Österreich keine geschützte Berufsbezeichnung.
Die Berufsbezeichnung _Softwareingenieur_ darf nach deutschem Recht nur führen, wer ein technisches Studium mit Erfolg abgeschlossen hat. In Österreich kann der Ingenieurstitel auch durch die Ausbildung an einer HTL erworben werden.
Source: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Softwareentwickler#Berufsbezei... (in German)As if Google Deutschland would not hire you as a Software Engineer (or SRE, ..) if you are missing a B.Sc. (or did it in a non-technical field) but everything else is perfect.
Job adverisments in German almost exclusively use the term "Software-Entwickler" ("software developer"), indicating that an IT degree is not necessarily required for the job.
If my job title is Software Engineer, then this is of course what it written on my business card that my employer prints for me.
> Job adverisments in German almost exclusively use the term "Software-Entwickler"
This is just not true.
> If my job title is Software Engineer, then this is of course what it written on my business card that my employer prints for me.
If you are not entitled to do use the title, then it is illegal nevertheless. After all, the law applies regardless of whether it is followed.
>> Job adverisments in German almost exclusively use the term "Software-Entwickler"
> This is just not true.
A search for "Softwareingenieur" or "Software-Ingenieur" on gulp.de, the leading IT freelancer platform in Germany currently gives zero results. If you search for "Software engineer" you get results mixed with "Softwareentwickler". So I went through these results which gave me aprox. 10 cases where they were looking explicitely for an "engineer" ("aprox." because I excluted those where "engineer" was one option among others or were they were mentioning the field "engineering" -- but even those were only a few). In contrast to that, when I searched for "Entwickler" or "developer", I got 275 results.[1] So the proportion of "engineer" is aprox. 3.6 % to that of "developer"/"Entwickler". I think it is okay to call that "almost exclusively".
[1] Some of it are a bit general, so you may not want to count everything. A quick random sample seems to indicate that the number is low nevertheless; so I went with 275, because the end result is unlikely to be significantly different.
Every term that has a legal (or precise subject-specific) definition also has a common-use definition. Engineer is no different, and the law knows and understands this.
This is why the term licensed engineer is a thing.
We are builders, with some amount of analytical ability and creativity. We aren't much different from pipefitters, blacksmiths, or furniture builders, and we aren't any smarter than those people.
I appreciate the bridges and roads, but I will not be told what title I can have just because YOUR industry has been captured.
For example, in Canada, the title "engineer" is reserved for licensed/professional engineers, so it would be misleading to use the title "electrical engineer" if they're not actually licensed.
We are "Framework and API plumbers" by and large, taking existing packages and just hooking them into each other.
We belong with the lawyers, who are working in an entirely human constructed framework but have somehow fucked it up so bad that it has loopholes and undefined/unexpected behavior.
And there's no possible way not to have some leaky abstractions with this in front of us.
But it is less funny if we go with code-plumber, the goal here is to justify trying to steal the protected job title.
Nobody's skirting the law. In most US states, there is a so called "industrial exemption," which allows you to do engineering without a license if you work for certain kinds of employers. I work for such a company, though I don't have an engineering title. But when we do offer a product for sale to the public, it goes to a third party for approval, and the people at that company who conduct the design review all have engineering licenses. The thing that will get you in trouble is offering engineering services directly to the public.
Now in my state, there are only licenses for a small handful of engineering disciplines: Electrical, mechanical, power, etc. I don't know if it means that the rest of us can't call ourselves engineers at all, or if we're just unregulated. I've never tested those waters.
From what I've observed, people with engineering job titles rarely do any hard quantitative engineering. Most of the work consists of organizing and arranging things, fitting things together, troubleshooting, etc.
Imagine a world in which we let the bootcamp grads build our bridges and medical devices (Therac anyone?).
I don’t mean to be a gatekeeper. Keeping someone from practicing medicine if they won’t get a degree is not gatekeeping by anyone’s definition.
„Trust me, I am a software engineer“ just doesn’t have the same ring as „trust me, I’m a doctor“
The risk of criminal liability in many countries is most likely low, as long as you keep the anglicized term and not call yourself Ingenieur (engineer) in Germany or for example 工学者 (こうがくしゃ, kougakusha) in Japan, both of which imply that you have a degree in engineering.
To make things more confusing, the information technology qualification I possess in Japan called 基本情報技術者試験, loosely translated as fundamental information technician, is often translated using engineer instead of technician.
Some countries do over software or information engineering degrees, with a professional body regulating them, but I find that to be the exception.
The battle is already lost.
The original meaning is "someone who builds machines, particularly siege engines, or who constructs defenses against those machines". Is that really what you're complaining about?
Perhaps you're referring to the meaning "a guy who shovels coal into a train engine"?
It's gatekeeping that we all pretty much agree is a good thing, but it's still gatekeeping.
I think what I'd rather like to see is an industry standard professional engineering board for computer science. I think the field could actually do with some minimal barrier to entry even if that sounds like gatekeeping.
Not having a professional software engineering license wouldn't prohibit you from taking jobs or practicing software development, but it would help to guarantee a certain level of fundamental grounding in computer science that certain employers might desire in their prospective employees.
I've been a programmer, system administrator and a machinist. I've never called myself an engineer, and wouldn't want the criminal liability for doing so.
[1] https://www.in.gov/pla/professions/engineering-home/engineer...