News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by changoplatanero on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:05AM (#34094783)
Rather than the students, I’m rooting for the tax payer in this one. California should determine grad student pay at state schools based on what level of funding is required to meet its educational mission, attract good students, and balance against other state priorities.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by uluyol on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:22AM (#34095012)
PhD students really don't get paid much. Tuition is waived if you're a TA, and you get a small stipend + good benefits. If you're an RA, you bring money into the university (through being the engine that pulls in grant money and having your tuition paid).

Most students I know were TA for one or two semesters and RA for the remainder of their 6 years. As far as I can tell, they are all a financial gain, not drain, for the university. That will likely depend on the department though.

I don't know about Masters students.

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by jleyank on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:35AM (#34095206)
No, if you’re an RA your prof brings in the money. Might also be the fund draw for post docs but I can imagine some with their own funding (awards or governmental). Based on my experience I would think PhD candidates are smart technicians for much of their residency.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by twelve40 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:40AM (#34095266)
You both bring the money, ideally. I co-authored grants with my professor and was expected to publish to make name for our work and fulfill the proposal's publishing requirements. Sure, the professor is infinitely better than me at this stuff, but there was a whole team, including grad students, who labored to get those grants, at least when I was there.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by jleyank on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:45AM (#34095337)
I did all that also, but $randomgradstudent didn’t get the grant. Like $majorprof didn’t do the lab work, work up the numbers, …. They merely edited, which was important, and had to mojo to get published.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by mcguire on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:29PM (#34097427)
That's part of your training.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by RHSeeger on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:43AM (#34095316)
That feels like saying it's a restaurant owner that brings in money, not the staff. If the professor couldn't do all the work on their own, then it's the team (which includes the RAs) that's bringing in the money. Sure, the professor is the "name" behind the work, but there's a lot people involved.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by jleyank on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:49AM (#34095402)
While the servers might keep the customers, it’s the chef and perhaps the owners that make the restaurant happen. And this is a terrible analogy for grad school as that staff is paid for shit in the states. Are we going to give ta’s $2/hour and expect their students to tip them?
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by lapcat on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:56AM (#34095492)
> Are we going to give ta’s $2/hour and expect their students to tip them?

That would be interesting, because TAs do the grading. ;-)

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by RHSeeger on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:55PM (#34096237)
Looks like you're arguing just to argue now. The analogy was making the point that more than just "the person in charge" is responsible for bringing in the money. Nothing more. The point of an analogy isn't to have every detail line up.

If I said that the introduction of the automobile to common public use was similar to the introduction of domesticated animals for riding, because it opened up a larger/wider area that people could interact with... saying that a car has wheels but a horse doesn't wouldn't invalidate that comparison.

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by rightbyte on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:18PM (#34100793)
The restaurant owners usually don't claim they make the foodand serve it.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by mcguire on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:29PM (#34097412)
The benefits don't sound all that good.

"“The current child care subsidy will be enough to cover … less than 2 months of child care per year”"

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by uluyol on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:14PM (#34098784)
This depends on your university, and also you should compare against a benchmark that's not cushy tech companies. I had spouse + child health care with no premium and only copays, no coinsurance. Didn't need the child care benefits so I don't know about that specifically.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by ummonk on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:13AM (#34094892)
More importantly, I'm with the undergrads. Their tuitions shouldn't go up to pay for a bunch of whiny PhDs who could have worked in industry instead.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by lapcat on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:16AM (#34094928)
PhD students provide a lot of the teaching labor at universities as lecturers and teaching assistants. What do you think would happen if they were gone? This is precisely why striking is effective, because the universities need them.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by changoplatanero on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:36AM (#34095214)
Universities have many needs besides TAs. the key to figuring out what a fair price for satisfying those needs is to have a market where supply can match demand. The same process can be used to set a fair price for grad student TA labor.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by jonnycomputer on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:06PM (#34095631)
And they raised demand by constricting supply. Nice.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by mcguire on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:31PM (#34097454)
"The same process can be used to set a fair price for grad student TA labor."

That is exactly what the union is negotiating.

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by cudgy on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:23AM (#34095030)
Universities would have to hire and pay actual professors instead of milking their students?
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by jleyank on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:29AM (#34095123)
Actual professors, no. Adjuncts. They don’t need ta’s for anything other than lab safety for the major-specific courses. It’s the first two years with the gobs and gobs of students.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by ablatt89 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:52AM (#34095439)
It's not just lab work, I TA'd for physics and students would come to TA discussion sessions to get a more detailed lesson on the material covered that week since often the professor is just repeating the contents of a textbook. Also, many TAs would spend many additional hours in tutoring and office hours, giving individualized attention to students, and this workload adds up.

TAs also grade quizzes, final exams, create questions for problems, etc... The professor often does very little work and leaves it to the TA, at least in my experience as a TA for physics courses. It's a lot more than just maintaining a lab.

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by thatfrenchguy on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:18PM (#34097268)
Can’t get adjuncts for the price you pay phd students in California though.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by mcguire on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:43PM (#34097606)
That's a different group in the strike. (https://www.science.org/content/article/postdoc-union-reache... discusses "postdocs and academic researchers", which isn't faculty, but I believe included adjuncts.)
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by tomrod on Friday December 23, 2022 @12:05PM (#34108111)
They outsource grading from professors to TAs. Adjuncts do this too where they can.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by lapcat on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:27AM (#34095095)
Yes, and actual professors are vastly more expensive than grad students, so how is that going to help with undergraduate costs?
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by cudgy on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:34AM (#34095187)
Are they really that much more expensive? Also, wouldn’t that provide more actual jobs for PHd’s instead of competing for a scant number of jobs? Furthermore, I do not believe that the costs of undergraduate education are driven by professor salaries; I suspect there are other drivers like administrative overhead and overbuilt facilities.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by lapcat on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:46AM (#34095359)
> Are they really that much more expensive?

Yes. From the article: "If the deal is approved by union members, graduate students would receive a minimum stipend of $34,000 by October 2024—a raise of $13,000 for some students". So as I said, professors are vastly more expensive.

> Also, wouldn’t that provide more actual jobs for PHd’s instead of competing for a scant number of jobs?

Yes. But it wouldn't do anything to save money on undergraduate education.

> Furthermore, I do not believe that the costs of undergraduate education are driven by professor salaries; I suspect there are other drivers like administrative overhead and overbuilt facilities.

Then what's the objection to higher stipends for PhD students?

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by cudgy on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:06PM (#34095637)
Why pay higher stipends if the students are no longer performing professorial duties? It may be the case that they are still warranted, but fewer duties means more learning and opportunities to earn money part-time in coops or private companies.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by tosc on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:53PM (#34097757)
> I suspect there are other drivers like administrative overhead and overbuilt facilities.

Right, and this is why they are trying to underpay teaching staff.

There is no problem with “whiny” PhDs. The problem is with overpaid self-dealing administrators betraying the purpose of the institution.

[dead]
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by lapcat on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:24PM (#34095850)
"Please don't use uppercase for emphasis." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

> The UNIVERSITY provides a FREE WORLD CLASS EDUCATION.

My student loan balance says otherwise. In fact, about half of all student loan debt is held by graduate students.

> PHD STUDENTS WHO WILL MAKE WELL OVER SIX FIGURES AFTER SAID EDUCATION

Some will. Many won't. Depends on many factors, including academic department. And almost half of PhD students never complete their PhD.

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by mjhay on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:10PM (#34095688)
That's a dumb thing to say, because it sounds like striking worked in this situation. By this same all-caps libertarian logic, any strikes would be ineffective because the workers need "The FACTORY" or whatever.

The "university" is a huge collection of thousands of people, numerous competing groups, etc. The grad students can shut the whole thing down if they strike, because they are integral towards research and undergrad education happening.

There's nothing quite like the unfounded confidence that ignorance brings.

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by ummonk on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:59PM (#34096297)
They won't go, and if they do senior undergrads and masters students will do the teaching instead.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by lapcat on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:10PM (#34096440)
> masters students will do the teaching instead

It's a graduate student union. Both Masters and PhD students are in the same union.

> senior undergrads

1) They're not qualified.

2) Why would they even want to? It's time consuming and low paying. In fact, it would be even lower paying without a union, so senior undergrads would need to form one. Also keep in mind that PhD students are generally intending to go into teaching in the future, whereas undergrads generally aren't.

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by ummonk on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:08PM (#34097150)
Masters students often don't receive a stipend.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by mcguire on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:40PM (#34097566)
If they're working in a teaching or research position, they do get paid.

If they don't work for the university, these union negotiations don't affect them.

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by ummonk on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:45PM (#34102413)
And there are plenty that aren't, who should be hired to union bust and keep costs low.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by lapcat on Friday December 23, 2022 @08:22AM (#34105487)
Have you considered that college students tend to be supportive of unions and wouldn't want to bust one?
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by jleyank on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:26AM (#34095080)
Replying to lapcat’s comment (which wasn’t possible), I suspect the schools would just look to adjuncts or senior u-grad students to be the necessary ta’s. It’s not like a 1st or 2nd year PhD student is particularly good or interested in ta’ing - they might be taking courses and are certainly fulfilling program entry requirements. Any research out of these people is gravy.

Interesting concept. Paying students to attend. I survived on this support in ancient times as somebody has to handle all those pre med/vet/dental students. But it was lean and I still can’t enjoy Mac and cheese. It certainly wasn’t a job or career.

Edit: reply again to deeper in the thread: we used the early students for things like 1-2 year lab as they were way better at lab than the students. Nobody handled a recitation unless they were 3rd year or more, had neutral+ evaluations and their boss lacked RA funding. Those with funded profs didn’t waste time ta’ing as they did work and wrote paper drafts. Those with new or unfunded profs did the ta gig and they also did full time work and writing drafts. 10+ extra hours a week ta.

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by avisser on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:33AM (#34095175)
You can get adjuncts and undergrads to be replacement TAs, but from my 2nd-hand experience via my wife (PhD in psychology) it would be research where things fall apart. The tenured professors rely heavily on PhD students to run grant-funded research and write papers for the lab.

The general public thinks first and foremost about education, but for lots of academics, teaching is a necessary evil and research is where the prestige (and money) is.

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by ummonk on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:57PM (#34096271)
Exactly. Fundamentally, these grad students want to further enhance a system where undergrads pay tuition for an education, and that tuition gets paid to research-focused academics instead.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by lapcat on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:33AM (#34095171)
> I suspect the schools would just look to adjuncts

Adjuncts are more expensive than PhD students. That's not going to help at all with undergraduate costs.

> or senior u-grad students to be the necessary ta’s. It’s not like a 1st or 2nd year PhD student is particularly good or interested in ta’ing - they might be taking courses and are certainly fulfilling program entry requirements.

If 1st or 2nd year PhD students are not particularly good, then wouldn't senior undergraduate students be even worse? Anyway, in my experience 1st or 2nd year PhD students didn't usually TA. It was the longer tenured students who were the TAs.

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by time_to_smile on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:19AM (#34094971)
Tuition increases are by far going towards administrative faculty rather than academic faculty. Most academic faculty, especially those doing research, are getting their own funding and not burdening the tax payer in the slightest.

Research is also incredibly important, especially at state schools, so that undergraduate students have more opportunity to participate in and learn from active research.

In my experience having worked at both prestigious private and low ranking state schools, state school doing research are much more willing to have undergrads involved in research. I've seen plenty of young students coming from low income, rural homes go on to become more successful than they ever imagined because they had access to research facilities and teams.

edit: it's worth noting as another commenter has that most of the teaching in universities is done by highly underpaid grad students.

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by passwordoops on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:22AM (#34095015)
Just made me wish this place supported the "100" emoji
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by tosc on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:19AM (#34094968)
Who should do the teaching instead?
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by ummonk on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:00PM (#34096306)
Senior undergrads and masters degree students, as well as PhDs who are willing to work for the current market rate.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by okaram on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:55PM (#34097788)
If your students are striking, chances are you won't attract good students, and are not balancing priorities well.