News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by jleyank on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:35AM (#34095206)
No, if you’re an RA your prof brings in the money. Might also be the fund draw for post docs but I can imagine some with their own funding (awards or governmental). Based on my experience I would think PhD candidates are smart technicians for much of their residency.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by twelve40 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:40AM (#34095266)
You both bring the money, ideally. I co-authored grants with my professor and was expected to publish to make name for our work and fulfill the proposal's publishing requirements. Sure, the professor is infinitely better than me at this stuff, but there was a whole team, including grad students, who labored to get those grants, at least when I was there.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by jleyank on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:45AM (#34095337)
I did all that also, but $randomgradstudent didn’t get the grant. Like $majorprof didn’t do the lab work, work up the numbers, …. They merely edited, which was important, and had to mojo to get published.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by mcguire on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:29PM (#34097427)
That's part of your training.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by RHSeeger on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:43AM (#34095316)
That feels like saying it's a restaurant owner that brings in money, not the staff. If the professor couldn't do all the work on their own, then it's the team (which includes the RAs) that's bringing in the money. Sure, the professor is the "name" behind the work, but there's a lot people involved.
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by jleyank on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:49AM (#34095402)
While the servers might keep the customers, it’s the chef and perhaps the owners that make the restaurant happen. And this is a terrible analogy for grad school as that staff is paid for shit in the states. Are we going to give ta’s $2/hour and expect their students to tip them?
Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by lapcat on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:56AM (#34095492)
> Are we going to give ta’s $2/hour and expect their students to tip them?

That would be interesting, because TAs do the grading. ;-)

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by RHSeeger on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:55PM (#34096237)
Looks like you're arguing just to argue now. The analogy was making the point that more than just "the person in charge" is responsible for bringing in the money. Nothing more. The point of an analogy isn't to have every detail line up.

If I said that the introduction of the automobile to common public use was similar to the introduction of domesticated animals for riding, because it opened up a larger/wider area that people could interact with... saying that a car has wheels but a horse doesn't wouldn't invalidate that comparison.

Re:Grad student unions strike controversial deal with Univer... by rightbyte on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:18PM (#34100793)
The restaurant owners usually don't claim they make the foodand serve it.