If you want to create antimatter then, at the very best, energy in = energy out. The energy required to accelerate a small mass of human seeds + associated robot farmers (say 100kg total) to a reasonable speed and to slow it down around the star at the other end is enormous, and a sizable fraction of the annual energy consumption of the entire human planet. It might not be impossible to realise, but it will require as much of a political effort as a scientific/engineering one.
Of course, antimatter from space colides with our planet every second, so why not just harvest it? Imagine the entire planet covered with a web that captures every particle of antimatter arriving from space. Well, it would take hundreds of millions of years to harvest enough energy though antimatter to send that 100kg mass to a nearby star.
Chemical rockets aren't going to get us there. Antimatter is currently the densest energy source known to man, and it's not enough. Barring the invention of warp drives, we're stuck here. Make the most of it.
Most of my thoughts on anti-matter (though of course I am totally unqualified in every regard) is that the biggest problem with rockets these days is fuel efficiency. We are wasting most of the energy of putting something into space because most of the weight we put into space is actually the weight of the fuel and engine. A minority of the weight of the rocket on the ground is the actual payload intended for space.
There are, to my mind, three competing emerging technologies that could solve the mass-weight ratio problem. They all involve kissing chemical rockets goodbye.
1) Nuclear
2) Anti-matter
3) Energy-beaming technology.
I feel that number 1 gets too much attention.
Obviously, if we ever want to get to other stars, we will have to get to other planets first. But I think once we get a solar-system wide economy our options will be much wider.
I also feel that making predictions about what the human race is capable of in, say, 10,000 years of technological development is silly. Even if you look 200 years back at what people predicted about what we would be capable of now you see wild inaccuracies.
I think that anti-matter could work for an interstellar rocket though. Consider what would happen if we built a factory that could convert 90% of the solar energy hitting the planet mercury into antimatter fuel. I bet that you could create an interstellar rocket from that.
Maybe we'll never be able to do it. But I wouldn't count your chickens just yet.
As far as I know, there's no known physics which "forbids" directly converting matter to antimatter with substantially less energy than going via energy (no conservations violated, etc), but to the best of my knowledge there aren't even any far-out fringe ideas on how to do it. That is, nobody even has any ideas on how to do it more efficiently than with rather large particle accelerators and with mind-bogglingly bad efficiencies.
I think you'd have to put in at least as much energy as you get back out through annihilation of the antiparticle, which would be half the energy released (the other half coming from the destruction of the normal matter).
And actually, we already have a working energy source that works by annihilation of matter: nuclear energy. Any future antimatter-based power plant would have to compete for full-cycle efficiency against future nuclear (possibly even fusion) designs.
Yes, but if you put ten kilograms of matter in, and get back 10 kilograms of antimatter, the energy equations are balanced; 10 kilograms times c^2 on both sides. Some sort of hypothetical device which somehow reaches into matter and flips it to antimatter via some relatively cheap technique, such as perhaps rotating it in a rolled-up dimension in such a way that the result is antimatter (to give one example of plausible sounding English words that have no actual referent in the real world), does not violate conservation. It just doesn't seem to be possible, either.
And if you're going to get technical, nuclear power plants have no special claim on converting mass to energy. All power plants do that. Combustion products are ever so slightly less massive than their original components, corresponding to the energy released in the chemical reaction.
Releasing energy stored in nuclear bonds between particles is NOT annihilation. Nothing gets annihilated in nuclear reactions.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_reaction#Energy_conserv...
EDIT since I can't reply. Particle/antiparticle "annihilation" is the conversion of their mass to energy. This is the same outcome as with the converted mass in a nuclear reaction.
If your argument is that I misused the word "annihilation" because it's a technical term in physics referring strictly to the mass->energy conversion in a matter/antimatter reaction, then I will concede that semantic point to you.
If there were a cost-efficient, energy-efficient, weight-efficient way of generating even very small annihilating pairs, it would be a major propulsion technology. It would also be a major weapons technology, and the fact that we don't know about research being done on such a cool-sounding thing it means that it probably isn't being done, or is being done with surprising secrecy (kind of unlikely).
Going out on a limb, I think that means we probably have solid theoretical grounding for believing it's infeasible.
(obligatory disclaimer: I am (obviously) not a physicist)
For weapons (I was thinking grenades and bombs) you would need to have smaller sizes, and it would have to be efficient to make the particle generators themselves. Spacecraft (at present) can be one-off designs. We could conceivably make a very expensive, reasonably lightweight, reasonably energy-efficient, reasonably large antimatter drive once while being unable to use that technology to make a reproducible superweapon.