News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by bin_bash on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:32AM (#34081960)
I'm not in favor of this kind of law but I've also seen shade-tree mechanics show a complete disregard for the environment: dumping oil into the dirt, releasing freon into the atmosphere, etc.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by actionfromafar on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:40AM (#34082083)
Dumping oil in the dirt is downright nice compared to dumping it in road drainage.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Kye on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:45AM (#34082145)
Where do you think things go once they get in the soil? Contaminated groundwater is as bad as sending it down to a river. It just takes longer to get there.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by opwieurposiu on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:10AM (#34082525)
When you put oil into dirt it is slowly eaten by hydrocarbonoclastic bacteria and fungi. This process usually takes a long time, years for a typical backyard. This natural process can cope with small amounts of oil like a drip here and there but if you dump an entire cars worth you are gonna have a problem.

https://microbewiki.kenyon.edu/index.php/Oil-Eating_Bacteria...

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by brewdad on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:58AM (#34082345)
Probably 40 years ago, my dad used to dump his oil in a spot in the yard. Years later I realized that spot is about 100 feet from his well.

Somehow, we are all still alive. (He did stop doing that eventually).

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by kbelder on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:43PM (#34083848)
Yeah, when I was a kid we had the 'oil bush' behind the garage. The bush my dad spent twenty years trying to kill by dumping old oil on it.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by actionfromafar on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:03AM (#34082428)
How bad it is depends on a few major factors:

is there a well nearby?

how is the soil layering and composition?

microbial activity?

how deep is the water table?

is there a body of water nearby? (where the drain water runs)

is the drain water treated in a plant? (is the treatment biological or chemical)

and so and so forth

The results can range from "no problem at all, the oil will sit undisturbed for hundreds of years and clean it self up" to "end up straight where it kills somethings".

Anyway, it occurred to me that oil change is probably on its way to become a historical footnote. Barring specalised applications, all motor vehicals will be electric probably, adoption seems to have reached a tipping point.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by oceanplexian on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:31AM (#34082817)
It’s kind of dumb to stick oil in the ground anyway. Used oil is still valuable, when you “recycle” it most people don’t realize it’s going to be burned by a recycling facility. But if you have a diesel engine, or a diesel heater, you can actually use it as fuel.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by aksss on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:34AM (#34082865)
> all motor vehicles will be electric

I guess I’m one of the crazies who would bet against this happening in my lifetime at least. The problems with grid capacity for scaling up electric vehicles, their unsuitability for long uninterrupted trips, lack of towing performance, etc., seem well-covered enough that the notion of no new ice vehicles seems like a bright-eyed futurist pipe dream at this point. Could it happen some day? Sure, but the futurist’s problem is all about timing, not direction.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ryukafalz on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:48AM (#34083040)
100% may be unlikely but certainly most. The vast majority of trips aren't long uninterrupted ones beyond the range of even current EVs nor do they require towing performance.

Grid capacity maybe. It would help if people stopped buying massively oversized vehicles for their actual everyday use in general. (But overall I'm fairly optimistic that EVs can be accounted for.)

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by aksss on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:59PM (#34085620)
> majority of trips

Majority of trips don’t exceed the capabilities of a Smart car. My CPU goes mostly unused. We don’t size for even the mean, but the realistically conceivable max (capability or capacity).

> Grid capacity

We struggle to support the demand for air conditioning and actively ask people to reduce their demand on the grid. Increasing demand by orders of magnitude seems inconceivable without a radical increase in generating capacity, which imposes a huge time constraint at the very least.

Again, I’m not arguing the direction, mostly just that the timeframe which to me seems a lot, lot longer than the popular representations.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ryukafalz on Saturday December 24, 2022 @09:48AM (#34117244)
> Majority of trips don’t exceed the capabilities of a Smart car.

Correct, that's why I drive a Smart car.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lelanthran on Thursday December 22, 2022 @10:54AM (#34094631)
> The vast majority of trips aren't long uninterrupted ones beyond the range of even current EVs nor do they require towing performance.

Buyers tend to buy for multiple uses. Their vast majority of trips may be in the range of current EVs, but they still wouldn't purchase a car that can't do 1 trip out of every 30.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ryukafalz on Saturday December 24, 2022 @09:47AM (#34117235)
I would guess it's far lower than 1 out of every 30 for most people. The number of cars I see towing anything on the highway or in town is miniscule, and the share of all trips above 30 miles is just 5%.

https://afdc.energy.gov/data/mobile/10318

I wish this data was segmented further, because 30 miles each way is no problem for an EV! But still, a longer trip doesn't mean you can't make the trip - especially with the number of fast chargers increasing, it just means you have to stop to charge a bit longer than if you'd stopped for gas.

(But as an aside, I really wish car share systems were more common in the US. It feels silly to have everyone driving around in oversized vehicles when they're only occasionally needed.)

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lelanthran on Saturday December 24, 2022 @11:58PM (#34124432)
> I would guess it's far lower than 1 out of every 30 for most people.

So? It doesn't have to apply to most people, it just has to apply to many, and judging from the number of trailers that are sold, and aftermarket towbars that are installed, many people actually do intend to use their car for towing.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by yellowapple on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:48AM (#34083044)
> The problems with grid capacity for scaling up electric vehicles, their unsuitability for long uninterrupted trips, lack of towing performance, etc., seem well-covered enough

Those are very temporary problems. I would be very surprised if EVs don't end up outperforming ICEVs on all those metrics within a decade or two, and that's a pretty conservative estimate.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by holbrad on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:37PM (#34084540)
Certain for large lorries it's an unsolved issue, unless we have a large battery breakthrough.

The weight of the battery to actually move goods very quickly becomes a major issue.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by bin_bash on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:25PM (#34085205)
Engineering Explained did some estimation around this and doesn’t think weight is likely to be a serious issue. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Uv44W7xa4IU

Granted that’s in part because EV trucks are allowed to be 2000 lbs heavier than ICE trucks in the US.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by jdboyd on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:44AM (#34082141)
True, but since changing your own fluids is still permitted there, I don't see how this helps much.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by asciimov on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:49AM (#34082194)
What one shade-tree mechanic releases or dumps pales in comparison to what is causally released by all the cars, trucks, and 18-wheelers on the road daily.

It's similar to blaming single use straws for the plastic problem.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by throw827474737 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:04AM (#34082438)
Doesn't make it any bit better or even justifyable? When did this reasonig become acceptable? It seems we won't care for the last bits of our planet, but that's how gross of humanity thinks :(
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by throw827474737 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:57AM (#34083177)
While true that most personal impact is tiny vs industry/the whole world we still just shouldn't be ok with dumping waste thoughtlessly?

In the end a lot of stuff is still caused by 8 billion insignificancies..

And imo also this straw (strawman) argument has been exaggerated. Yes, it is also a tiny and mostly insignificant bit, but where was it blamed to be the root cause of the plastic problem? It is another tiny simple thing one can just avoid without much personal luxury impact, so where is the problem? Trying to draw that into ridicule like this not much better, imo.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Scoundreller on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:51AM (#34082232)
I just save all my used oil and every several years, call up the same person I found with an oil burner setup for a 6-pack.

Used oil has value!

I do the same with my apple tree trimmings.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Fradow on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:10AM (#34082522)
Changing oil is specifically allowed here, and I'm pretty sure every first world country has rules against dumping oil and other polluting elements.

If this is the goal, it's really backward as it is only loosely related.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by hef19898 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:54AM (#34083133)
In Germany, the place you bought the new oil from has to take the old one back. In case of Amazon, the recycling partner is (used to be?) is a nation wide chain of auto shops.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by jandrese on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:02PM (#34084104)
That's also true in much of the US. Every auto parts store has to take old oil for recycle, regardless of where you originally bought it. They don't even ask.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by hef19898 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:54AM (#34090609)
I like the "don't even ask" part, some places over here can be rather difficult in that regard.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by samtho on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:26AM (#34082744)
> dumping oil into the dirt

This is still illegal most places regardless of where you do your service. All auto parts stores (in California at least) let you drop off as much oil as you want for free and they dispose of it. Some Autozones will give you an empty container to transport the oil back to them (if you ask).

> releasing freon into the atmosphere

A/C systems are closed, so unless you have a leak, it shouldn’t ever make contact with the outside. Even DIY tools to “recharge” it have special one-way connector valves that connect directly to the one-way connection valve on the A/C system. We’ve come a long away in this tech.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by bin_bash on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:46AM (#34083016)
I'm telling you what I've seen people actually do. These aren't the minority either, these are most of the poor shade-tree meth heads I grew up with in the PNW.

> This is still illegal

But not enforced because you're not going to catch someone pouring oil over a fence on their own property into a bunch of weeds at night.

> transport the oil

The shit gets everywhere. No thanks. They know they can go to autozone or leave it in a clear plastic container, but that's extra work. I'm not sure people realize just how little free time blue collar folk have.

> it shouldn’t ever make contact with the outside

Pulling the A/C unit out to lighten the car for the dragstrip. Why bother renting an A/C reclaiming machine when I can just open the valve and let it vent?

Again, I'm not saying people shouldn't be allowed to work on cars, but trying to ignore the real environmental dangers here is burying your head in the sand.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by thrashh on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:40PM (#34083812)
Why not just charge something like a core fee like with batteries though?

I don’t see how someone sees one thing wrong with an activity and go “yeah let’s ban the whole thing”

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by bin_bash on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:45PM (#34083879)
> Why not just charge something like a core fee like with batteries though?

That doesn't work with motor oil for a number of reasons. It can burn off, new engines don't come with any oil, etc.

> I don’t see how someone sees one thing wrong with an activity and go “yeah let’s ban the whole thing”

Scroll up and see what my initial post was and you'll see this is the direct opposite of my position from the beginning.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by actually_a_dog on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:58AM (#34083196)
I agree, "shade tree mechanics" often do disregard environmental considerations. But, they tend to pretty much disregard all laws and regulations, when they're inconvenient for them. Hence the shortcuts to "save time."

The question is: what ought to be done about this? I don't think a blanket ban on other than "minor car repairs" is it, but I also don't think the type of person you're talking about here is going to be too fazed by fines and inspectors.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by bin_bash on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:05PM (#34083295)
I'm just saying the environmental cost is real. I feel people are dismissing it because "it's not legal to dump fluids" when the reality is that it's pretty common—and pretty hazardous at a local level.

I think if you banned all automotive work at home (including oil changes) that would reduce the amount of environmental damage like this. It's far easier to catch someone changing oil than dumping it. However there are obvious socioeconomic reasons why I don't think this is something that should be done.

I'm not proposing a solution, I'm just pointing out we shouldn't ignore the environment here. Or expect poor people to care about the environment because they very much do not. I know the people that do this and if I challenged them on it they would say "the government pours oil on their own gravel roads to keep the dust down anyways" or "if the government cared about the environment they wouldn't have killed Stanley Meyer" or some other claim to point out perceived hypocrisy.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mmcgaha on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:32PM (#34083679)
So your argument is that we should enact laws that ban all automotive work at home because some people do not follow the existing laws around dumping motor oil. Do you really not see the flaw in this argument?
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by bin_bash on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:40PM (#34083806)
Every single comment I've posted on this topic (including the one you just replied to) I've been careful to point out that I expressly do not think such laws should exist.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mmcgaha on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:04PM (#34084122)
Fair enough. Sometimes I am blindly emotional when I feel like my right to do stuff to my own things on my own property is questioned.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by t_sawyer on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:43PM (#34083842)
How far does this go? If you have a riding lawnmower you have to change the oil in that too. Are we forcing people to spend money to haul their mower to a shop to get the oil changed? ATVs?

I'm completely against this. You're expecting poor people to pay for things they can do themselves if they're willing just because a few people dump oil in their weeds at night. Your freon argument doesn't sway me either. Wrecks cause freon dumps all the time. Your neighbor pulling freon out of one car isn't causing that much environment damage.

Also: if you're concerned about it, report them.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by tcmart14 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:28PM (#34085254)
I wonder if the solution here is entirely different. Maybe instead of asking what-ifs per-se we ask, "well, why would someone not do it the proper way." The answer there is, whether justified or not, the current process is too much of a "hassle" (I don't see it as such but for someone dumping motor oil down storm drains for them it apparently is). We can't make them do the current process that is more of a "hassle." So how do we make a more "hassle-free" process? Maybe like garbage, one Wednesday a month, the recycling/garbage company picks up jugs of fluids? We have an existing process, so maybe we just rope one more thing into. The county/city already does garbage pickup and disposal, why not fluids?
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by actually_a_dog on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:46PM (#34083900)
I realize you're not proposing a solution. That's precisely why I was asking about one. I'd like to see the environment protected while at the same time people retain the right to do repairs on their own vehicles on their own property.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by holbrad on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:32PM (#34084490)
I think we just need to be real that, there are environmental externalities to many many things. Even when we take a good faith look at various issues it's entirely reasonable for other factors to trump environmental concerns. (Moral, economic, social, cultural)
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lelanthran on Thursday December 22, 2022 @10:49AM (#34094551)
> I think if you banned all automotive work at home (including oil changes) that would reduce the amount of environmental damage like this.

Sure, and if you banned all alcohol consumption, then that will reduce the amount of kids damaged by alcohol.[1]

Still doesn't mean that banning is an idea worthy of consideration.

[1] The negative effects of alcohol on a population is far worse than many other things that are banned, and yet alcohol is not. Many things would get immediately unbanned if the bar was "needs to be more damaging than alcohol"

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by nverno on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:06PM (#34089664)
Having the option to leave your oil in a clear container more than accounts for the environmental dangers. That is not 'extra work'. When you're doing an oil change you need a container to catch it in anyway- but the claim here is it's too much work to put it in a clear container?! Used oil is trash, so I guess you'd argue it's 'extra work' for people to take out their own trash as well.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by samtho on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:45PM (#34100538)
> Pulling the A/C unit out to lighten the car for the dragstrip. Why bother renting an A/C reclaiming machine when I can just open the valve and let it vent?

This is very rare in the grand scheme of things and the most common case is simply to recharge a line that had a slow leak. Both the valve that allows you inject coolant on the A/C system and the valve on the pressurized can are one-way by default. Yes, a little get leaked every time you do this because there is a void between where the valve attaches to the pressurized can, but this is all about trade offs.

If your A/C is leaking, you can usually fix it as it’s usually just a brittle gasket or a flare connection became loose over time. Most people I’ve helped have vacuumed out their refrigerant before disassembling so they can simply pump it back in. Why pay for new coolant if you can borrow the vacuum tool for free and just use what you got already? Yes, I’m sure some people just open the valve and let it rip, but most undertaking this repair at least watch a few YouTube videos.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by uberduper on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:09PM (#34083354)
You can pick up an AC manifold on amazon for about $20 and cans of refrigerant (not top off kits) are available at any auto parts store. There's plenty of reasons to need to open the AC system in a car.

Unfortunately AC repair shops generally price gouge. I've seen shops charge > $100 just to evacuate a system for you, which is just hooking it up to their (admittedly very expensive) recovery machine for a couple minutes. Take the car back to have it filled again with about 4x $6 cans of refrigerant and they'll charge $200+ to once again hook it up to their machine for about 20 minutes. Ask them to diagnose your busted AC system and they'll inevitably tell you the evap coil is leaking and it's a $2k+ repair because of the 15 hours of labor involved in removing and reinstalling your entire dash. Go home and follow some youtube directions and find out it was really just a leaking oring on the condenser.

It's no wonder people do these repairs at home. Maybe the fix is for the auto industry to move to a less harmful refrigerant and design their AC systems in ways that don't require them to be disassembled for various unrelated repair work.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by rascul on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:32PM (#34084486)
> Maybe the fix is for the auto industry to move to a less harmful refrigerant

I think 1234yf is supposed to be a lot better. I'm not sure what the adoption rate is, though.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:56PM (#34084788)
You're not paying for the repair. You're paying for the peace of mind that comes with a "legitimate business" that you can sue if their shop burns down with your car in it, has an expensive machine that avoids discharging refrigerant, follows labor law, etc.

It's the same reason people pay more for products that are ethically sources.

That said I think the prices are crazy and would be lower if the financial burden of running a "legit" shop weren't so high.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by samtho on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:52PM (#34100596)
They’re are plenty of reasons to open the system, my point was that it isn’t a simple fluid top-off that oil or engine coolant is. A leaky A/C system is really an exception and people who work on their cars typically understand the work that goes into this and why it shouldn’t ever need topping off in ideal circumstances.

I agree that refrigerants need to be safer, but it’s not my experience that people who are relying on their cars to literally survive are going to just pop the refrigerant valve and let it rip.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by dotancohen on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:02PM (#34083253)
So draft a law that forbids dumping oil into the dirt, releasing freon into the atmosphere, etc. And if those laws already exist, why aren't they enough to dissuade the practices but this anti-repair law is?
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by admax88qqq on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:40PM (#34083809)
Because they're harder to enforce and accidental leaks happen.

Highjacking planes is illegal but we still don't allow guns and bombs on planes, it makes it easier to enforce.

Risk mitigation is a part of public policy.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by nulbyte on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:55PM (#34085572)
Actually, we do allow firearms on planes. In the US, you must declare them and store them properly in checked baggage. The rules strike me as suitably tailored to the actual risks, unlike the repair law in question. And that's assuming the repair law was actually intended to address environmental risks. I am highly skeptical.

https://www.tsa.gov/travel/transporting-firearms-and-ammunit...

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lelanthran on Thursday December 22, 2022 @10:43AM (#34094466)
> I'm not in favor of this kind of law but I've also seen shade-tree mechanics show a complete disregard for the environment: dumping oil into the dirt, releasing freon into the atmosphere, etc.

"I'm not in favour of banning alcohol, but I've also seen how easily minors acquire it".

So? That's an argument for enforcing current law, not implementing a complete ban.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by bin_bash on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:02AM (#34094746)
I think you and many other have completely misunderstood this sentence, which is on me for not being clear. Now that I slept on it I think I see where my fault lies. It sounds like everything after the "but" is me contradicting the first part when I meant to just convey more information, not to contradict it entirely.

When I said "I'm not in favor of this kind of law", I literally meant that. I'm not in favor of a complete ban: full stop. You're arguing as if I have the opposite position.

I'm saying the environmental costs are real. That doesn't mean that I therefore think that there should be a complete ban, simply that there are real costs that we need to be mindful of. Socioeconomic costs outweigh the environment here, IMO.

I think if you read my comments again with this in mind you'll find you're not actually disagreeing with my real position.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by phunehehe0 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:23AM (#34095023)
What I've been taught is, the part of the sentence after the "but" is the part that's being emphasized.

Imagine if you had written:

> I've seen shade-tree mechanics show a complete disregard for the environment, but I'm not in favor of this kind of law.

It seems like you think that's the same sentence as before but to me, and I suspect other readers, they say different things.