News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by mfuzzey on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:16PM (#34072697)
This should be illegal.

Businesses like payment processors should not be allowed to refuse to provide their services to any legal clients. And legality is up to the courts to decide not payment processors or any other middlemen.

If enough people really want to ban porn (I don't know or care if this particular site was really porn) then go through the proper channels, and make a law explicitly banning it don't try to get private companies to do the work of enforcing arbitary rules.

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by jamestimmins on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:26PM (#34072829)
In many cases, I suspect providers would love if this was illegal, as they likely dislike being forced by the public to become arbiters of decency (thinking especially of Cloudflare banning trolls).

The balance, according to my limited understanding, is that certain types of activity including porn-adjacent sites have much higher card failure rates, so banning some activity is a way to reduce chargeback costs falling on Stripe's shoulders.

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:20PM (#34074276)
> The balance, according to my limited understanding, is that certain types of activity including porn-adjacent sites have much higher card failure rates, so banning some activity is a way to reduce chargeback costs falling on Stripe's shoulders.

In that case, wouldn't the solution be to charge higher processing fees (possibly much higher) for websites in that category? Why ban them entirely?

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by dragonwriter on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:49PM (#34074623)
> In that case, wouldn't the solution be to charge higher processing fees (possibly much higher) for websites in that category?

Which will the lead to deliberate miscategorization, and more costs to verify claimed categorization, and...

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:44PM (#34075174)
Doesn't banning the category create an even stronger incentive for deliberate miscategorization?
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by hattmall on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:49PM (#34075693)
No, because the logical penalty for miscategorization is adjustment to the correct fees. The penalty for getting around a banned category is that they steal your money. In many cases it is very large amounts.
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:19PM (#34075921)
Huh. Well, I'm not sure of the legal details, but that seems like a system that ought to be changed, since the incentives are clearly misaligned.
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by yucky on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:34PM (#34072925)
Doesn't this go back to the whole "if you don't like it build your own" argument that wrongthinkers have had to listen to for years? A business isn't required to support content they don't agree with, or something.

I agree it's bullshit, but it shouldn't only be called out when it affects the right people.

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by xg15 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:26PM (#34074353)
> then go through the proper channels, and make a law explicitly banning it don't try to get private companies to do the work of enforcing arbitary rules.

I think one of the effects of the gridlock in US politics is that more and more actual policy is now implemented by circumventing the "normal" lawmaking process: e.g. through executive orders, court decisions or appeals to private companies or citizens.

Whichever side you're on, this can't be a good thing for a democracy.

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by dragonwriter on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:55PM (#34074685)
Enforcement of social norms through convincing private actors to behave in certain ways in preference to government actions is a major point of the First Amendment, not a circumvention of the normal lawmaking process.
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by zzo38computer on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:13PM (#34074876)
It would be OK, if they did not then try to force everyone to use the services of private actors.
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by stevefan1999 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:01AM (#34077529)
No, its not okay either. You basically made a cartel that follows a government like structure
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by xg15 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:26PM (#34085228)
If you interpret the first amendment like this, then you shouldn't have any problems with Stripe's behaviour from the article either, right?
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by Waterluvian on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:47PM (#34074603)
This idea is fundamentally at odds with the framework of US jurisprudence. It would require changing the Constitution: namely butchering the 1st Amendment.

Forcing companies to do business with everyone creates a ton of wrong incentives as well.

A law banning porn. Woof. Enough has already been written about that one.

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by dragonwriter on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:51PM (#34074650)
> This idea is fundamentally at odds with the framework of US jurisprudence.

Applying common-carrier rules to a particular, already highly-regulated, key industry to commerce is not “fundamentally at odds with the framework of US jurisprudence”.

> It would require changing the Constitution: namely butchering the 1st Amendment.

No, it wouldn’t. Just like it didn’t when we did it to telecoms.

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by Waterluvian on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:06PM (#34074809)
Massive uphill battle to have an online payment company treated as such.
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by alexeldeib on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:12PM (#34074870)
Perhaps the right one.
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by Waterluvian on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:22PM (#34074977)
I certainly don’t support the idea but I certainly support trying if there is sufficient interest… ideally by the people.
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by just-ok on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:44PM (#34075647)
“It’s a private business, it can do whatever it wants.”
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by puffoflogic on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:35PM (#34076346)
This stopped being true on October 27; where have you been?
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by candybar on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:05PM (#34075829)
Then payment processors either need to either 1) be able to determine with 100% certainty whether something is legal or 2) be given broad immunity with respect to customers' illegal activities as long as they weren't strictly aware. The problem is that 1) is not possible and 2) incentivizes these intermediaries from keeping track of what their customers do, which then opens door to all kinds of criminal activities. Money laundering becomes virtually impossible to prosecute in that environment, which then makes other criminal activities substantially more profitable.
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by blagie on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:18PM (#34075913)
If I were to list my top 10 problems in life, money laundering would not make the list. I would like payment processors to operate like common carriers. I prefer not having private law enforcement, and having it done by government agencies.

The extent to which I want the government to have access to my day-to-day purchases is another matter, but even that's better than commercial operations where I have no recourse.

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by candybar on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:37PM (#34076036)
Money laundering isn't a big problem for you right now precisely because the world works the way it does, rather than the way you wish it did. The relationship between money laundering and corruption is well-established and globally, corruption is one of the biggest problems if you care about human welfare.
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by blagie on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:27PM (#34084433)
If I were to make a list of my top-10 problems, corruption would be near the top. None of the cases I've seen involved money laundering.

If I were to make a trade-off, I would implement many more transparency measures for organizations, not for individuals. If I can see what happens in my local school, municipal government, corporation, university, church, and non-profit, that would cut down on all the corruption I've seen, dramatically. I see no downsides to transparency measures which don't impact individuals, and they have a lot more impact than corporations snooping on me.

Indeed, in one case I saw corruption, corporate snooping meant that the corrupt place had more leverage over a whistleblower. That's no good.

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by candybar on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @06:28PM (#34087769)
If you don't understand the connection between money laundering and corruption, you certainly do not have a very strong understanding of the problem of corruption. Also, good luck having "transparency measures" in a world where intermediaries are allowed immunity as long as they don't know stuff.
Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by blagie on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:46AM (#34093135)
Nice. Switch from discussion to insults. Anyone who doesn't agree with you is clearly an idiot who doesn't understand things.

Yes, I do understand the connection between corruption and money laundering. That touches on one form of corruption. There are many others. If I were to eliminate corruption, I'd take measures like:

- Extend laws like FOIA and Open Meetings, dramatically, so we have a much clearer understanding of government. In particular, I'd extend enforcement and penalties. Wilful violations should be criminal.

- Extend such laws to cover non-profits as well. I should be able to ask a church, a university, or any other organization exempt from taxes for documents, or sit in on governance meetings.

- Put in stronger whistleblower protections, and eliminate a lot of the power of NDA / non-disparage / etc agreements

- Increase SEC-mandated transparency measures

... and so on. Those have nothing to do with money laundering, and to me, are strict wins.

Very little of the corruption I've seen involves bags of money. Most corruption involves things like (not directly financial) preferential treatment. If I give you a raise you don't deserve, give your child preferential treatment at my school, or cut a sweet deal for your company, that doesn't show up in a Paypal transaction.

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by candybar on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:38PM (#34096036)
> Very little of the corruption I've seen involves bags of money.

As I said, that's precisely because the world works the way it does, rather than the way you wish it did. The bottleneck for lots of otherwise extremely profitable criminal endeavors is their reliance on traditional financial intermediaries.

> That touches on one form of corruption.

I'm talking about the type of corruption that keeps entire countries from developing economically. I don't know what you're on about. And no, your series of suggestions, which amount to saying make the current regulations stronger, doesn't come close to closing a huge loophole created by giving blanket immunity to financial intermediaries.

> Most corruption involves things like (not directly financial) preferential treatment. If I give you a raise you don't deserve, give your child preferential treatment at my school, or cut a sweet deal for your company, that doesn't show up in a Paypal transaction.

Most corruption is like this when you live in a country where corruption isn't much of a problem.

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by blagie on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:57PM (#34099354)
With all due respect, you have no idea who I am, what my background is, where I lived, or what I know. If you wanted to argue facts, that'd be one thing. I could pull up citations. Personal attacks, I just don't feel like engaging with.

I'm done here.

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by candybar on Thursday December 22, 2022 @05:40PM (#34099885)
It's not that hard to infer that you know very little about the topic at hand, but you think you know, because reasons. Your comments remind me of the other time I had to engage with complete nonsense (to be fair, you're not nearly as bad as the other person) - just because you can put together some words that appear to make sense if you don't think deeply enough or have no context, doesn't mean the resulting output makes any sense.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22680687

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by blagie on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:34PM (#34100914)
Oh no! Someone's wrong on the internet!

No, you can't infer how much someone knows about a topic, at least from the discussion here. You can infer they know something different than you do. That happens when you get a modern-day Republican and Democrat in the same room, and each believes the other to be an idiot. The same happens if people are from different countries, cultures, or hold different values.

Groups develop groupthink, with a common set of information, logic, and conclusions. It's natural to assume anyone who doesn't share those is an idiot. My own experience is that they're often not idiots, and if I go in with an open mind, I often learn something (and quite often, we both do), although that's been harder with recent political polarization. Nowadays, discussions usually shift to people calling me an idiot if I don't line up 100% with their worldview. It's been rarer and rarer to have intelligent discussions.

Perhaps my conclusions were wrong. They often are; on average, we're right about half the time in discussions, and that's fine. Perhaps yours are too. Perhaps we're right in different contexts (we might live in different countries, for example).

However, where you took this discussion, neither of us has any chance of discovering what the other's opinions were informed by. If you doubt something I'm saying, you can ask for evidence, rather than assuming and insulting. Perhaps each of us might have learned something.

In either case, that's as far as I'm willing to take this discussion. I nerd on topics like these for fun. Getting insulted is tiring and draining rather than fun. You're welcome to believe I'm an idiot.

I propose we terminate this discussion. People are welcome to be wrong on the internet.

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by candybar on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:57PM (#34101074)
This has nothing to do with worldviews. It's just that a statement like this:

> If I were to make a list of my top-10 problems, corruption would be near the top. None of the cases I've seen involved money laundering.

rather clearly reveals your lack of understanding of the topic at hand. The fact that you think this has anything to do with political polarization is another clue that you have no idea what you're talking about. Your repeated attempts to anchor all of this to your personal experience are also quite revealing with respect to both your bias and lack of grounding in the subject.

And this isn't about your conclusions being wrong - it's just that you (and people like you) seem to form absurdly strong opinions when you don't even have the slightest clue regarding why things are the way they are.

Btw, since you are now pretending that you were this intellectually eager person just trying to have an honest discussion and I somehow poisoned the exchange, let me remind you that this was your first contribution:

> If I were to list my top 10 problems in life, money laundering would not make the list.

Which, of course, is combative, dismissive and arrogant. Why on earth is your personal list of "top 10 problems in life" relevant to any discussion? Who the hell do you think you are? It's the type of response that immediately signals lack of interest in learning anything, which you have since confirmed.

> I'm done here.

> I propose we terminate this discussion

You can do whatever you want - is your next reply also going to mention how you're really done this time?

Re:Censoring Naked Yoga by puffoflogic on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:33PM (#34076332)
> Businesses like payment processors should not be allowed to refuse to provide their services to any legal clients.

And social media? Careful, this position is making you fascism-adjacent. Now is the time to decide if that's really where you want to be.