But in my time on various zoning boards and appeals boards more often than not I am the dissenter when someone says “neighbor on their own land doing something legal will lower my prop value.”
When I remind them “with investment comes risk” I am often looked at, by my own peers even, like I just said something crazy.
Owning your home is owning a home and I think we need to focus on that idea more.
I know there's also a cost-benefit analysis involved surrounding all the various fees and taxes.
The biggest "what-if" risk is probably liquidity.
No it isn't. Ben Felix has a great video talking about this:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Golcxjpi8
We can argue which is better in a specific situation, but there's definitely an argument for renting other than "people buy too big".
I also own a house. I hate the maintenance part :p
I don't hate maintenance as I grew up working around the house with my dad. But I absolutely will not do lawn care work, ehehhe!
Which he regrets:
Side note - As I understand it, you cannot deduct either of those if you take the common standard deduction. In high cost of living places I am told that these deductions do outweigh the standard deduction.
Lack of homeownership is not what's making the US poor lose money. Lack of income is what's causing lack of homeownership. Lack of income is caused by society and government sabotaging these groups.
Landlords can also deduct their interest expenses and so they benefit from leverage too (meaning they don't want to build up equity).
In a reasonably efficient market, this means that the equivalent cost of homeownership would be higher than rent, to offset these things (the rate at which you're paying down the principal, and the deductability of interest rate expenses). This is obviously a very simplified argument, and there's a lot of other factors going into this.
Back in 2013 I was renting an apartment for $1600/month, but my dad made me do the math and I ended up buying a condo about 10 minutes walk away, larger and far higher quality everything and the mortgage was only around $800/month. Even with the monthly assessment fee (for the management company to handle the property and facilities) it was lower than what I was renting for. Just had to get over the down-payment hump.
The “forced savings” argument is nonsense. If you’re renting you are simply building equity and “savings” for someone else. Housing cost is a lot of monthly money going out the door to never see a penny of it again. People do dumb things like buy too much house, but it’s very hard to make a financially logical argument against sensible home ownership. Even in places were housing is super expensive it’s common for those that played their cards right to simply cash out later in life, buy some place in a less expensive part of the country and pocket all the equity.
In the US the whole tax system is also rigged massively in favor of home ownership. If you own you’re paying mortgage interest and real estate taxes and both are tax deductible. If you rent you are almost certainly paying both of these (your landlord includes it in the rent) and get no tax benefits.
The only realistic argument for renting is if you’re only living somewhere for a few years and the fixed costs of buying/selling outweighs the financial benefits of ownership.