Re:Password generator doesn't generate new password in the s...
by codefined on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:33AM
(#34065606)
`/dev/urandom` isn't a real file / stream. It's part of the 'everything is a a file' *nix mantra. Even if two users are reading from /dev/urandom simultaneously, they'll each get unique values. The CSPRNG keeps track of a sequence number and so you'll end up with something like [process 0 requests sequence 0, process 1 requests sequence 1, process 1 requests sequence 2, proceess 0 requests sequence 3...].
Re:Password generator doesn't generate new password in the s...
by amelius on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:49PM
(#34074627)
Um, yeah, you sort of rephrased my question into a statement.
Re:Password generator doesn't generate new password in the s...
by colanderman on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:32AM
(#34065596)
There is (or at least was, in 2014) a spinlock to serialize access: https://damonsnyder.com/2014/04/16/linux-dev-urandom-and-con...
Re:Password generator doesn't generate new password in the s...
by onei on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:38AM
(#34065684)
Is that strictly true? I know urandom doesn't block if it lacked entropy, but if it had entropy I was under the impression urandom's output was derived from that instead.
Re:Password generator doesn't generate new password in the s...
by colanderman on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:43AM
(#34065742)
Edited my post to include a link with code references and discussion by kernel devs. The RNG state is protected by a spinlock.
Re:Password generator doesn't generate new password in the s...
by ilyt on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:09AM
(#34066081)
Well, a lot changed since the article. For one the test tool now eats more CPU than RNG.
From my dumb tests (run DD in one, then many threads), the 4 thread run have 4x the performance of single thread one (I have 4 core CPU), while 16 thread one have predictably same-ish total throughput, so if there are any serialization still there it is not noticeable much.
(ignoring that they could get the same output by chance)