News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by rich_sasha on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:59AM (#34039601)
Re wind being so cheap: it is currently because we have fossil backup. If fossil fuels and nuclear get phased out, we might wake up to a reality where, when the wind blows, energy is basically free, and when it doesn't, it is extortionately expensive.

That might change the economics, for nuclear fission as well as fusion.

Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by aeternum on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:08PM (#34039694)
The way solar prices are trending, energy will also be free when it's sunny out, maybe even partially sunny.

Then the way EVs are trending, each home should have giant batteries in their garage and a good percentage will likely be incentivized to charge their EV when the sun/wind is strong and potentially release it back to the grid when its not.

Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by nwiswell on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:09PM (#34039721)
Not everyone lives in the suburbs with a two-car garage.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by aeternum on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:33PM (#34040002)
Cities are already energy efficient compared to the suburbs. Most cities have plenty of suburbs around them, and lots (arguably too many) large parking garages that can be used for the same purpose.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by revnode on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:31PM (#34039966)
Not everyone is necessary. You just need a critical number to balance the grid.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by jghn on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:12PM (#34039755)
Indeed. Where I live most people are limited to street parking. It wasn't so bad keeping an EV charged using public chargers, but as more people are getting EVs the public chargers are becoming harder to access.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by persedes on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:23PM (#34039869)
checkout ubricity, have not used them but the concept is pretty neat: use street lights for ev charging.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by theptip on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:40PM (#34041991)
Or public chargers will see higher utilization and therefore be more prevalent. Supply/demand - neither is static.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by akira2501 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:06PM (#34043381)
And supply and demand still have to deal with physical constraints and the current layout of the grid. You can only install so many chargers in a given area before you find blocking issues.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by ImHereToVote on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:22PM (#34039862)
Why would disgusting poor people need to use electricity?
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by thinking4real on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:14PM (#34039779)
Sounds like a dystopian reality where we revert back to only really functioning when the sun is in the sky.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:11PM (#34041566)
Luckily, between CO2 emissions and climate catastrophe, toxic energy waste of various kinds, air quality issues, and geopolitical instability largely caused by resource wars, our current reality isn't dystopian at all.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by moloch-hai on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:19PM (#34042648)
You will completely forget that you ever predicted such a thing.

After there is enough renewable generating capacity to charge it from, storage will be built out, and NG turbines will be used decreasingly often. Many will be converted to burn ammonia instead, which will be fixed at solar farms in the tropics and shipped wherever it is wanted.

If there is dystopia it will be via failure to build out fast enough.

Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by The_Double on Sunday December 18, 2022 @05:55PM (#34045002)
Society already slows down a lot when the sun is down. Is that dystopian too?
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by captainmuon on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:14PM (#34039782)
Would that be a showstopper? Then we would just produce less stuff when energy is expensive, and more when it is cheap. We'd build houses to keep a pleasant temperature for longer. We'd combine local energy generation with a strong grid to transport energy over longer distances.

Stuff will become more expensive, economic activity might be somewhat dampened, but that might be offset by the cheapness of wind and solar, and by the fact that building the new infrastructure will create a lot of growth. And in the end, it will literally save the planet. I'd choose a bit slower economic activity over accelerating climate change any time.

Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by pifm_guy on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:16PM (#34039807)
You're assuming energy companies switch to hourly priced billing.

But nationwide nearly everyone is on a fixed price per kWh deal, and current electricity meters don't usually even support pricing that chances every few minutes, as would need to happen to incentivize people to only use power when the wind blows.

The cost of simply upgrading every electricity meter to a modern one is many years of profits for most energy companies.

Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by fulafel on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:32PM (#34039983)
This seems pretty pessimistic. Weather forecasts exist and things work quite well already today eg for day ahead hourly pricing model, lots of end user energy contracts are like that.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by captainmuon on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:40AM (#34065700)
Maybe I'm more optimistic because I live in Europe :-P. I'm pretty sure most energy intensive industry is already on flexible pricing. And privately, if you build a new home or change anything about your meter, you're already mandated to install a smart meter. But households' energy use has been slowly going down anyway, due to energy saving appliances and lights, education, and better insulation (the latter doesn't help much with electricity, but with total power consumption).

As the sibling post said, the transition will be difficult. But there is absolutely no way the government will allow widespread brownouts or industrial collapse (in the worst case we'll use just enough fossil as necessary). We are talking about reduced profit margins for a couple of years, and having to wait a bit more longer to buy shiny new gadgets. The real challenge is to orchestrate everything so that it is socially fair and the weakest, or those most dependent on cars, etc. don't get hit too hard.

Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by SuperQue on Monday December 19, 2022 @06:30AM (#34050930)
In Finland, time of day electric use meters have existed for something like 20 years. Someone I know who lived north of the arctic circle had a home heating system that would heat up an energy storage box (I forget if it was an oil tank or simply stone) at night and then cycle the heat out to the house during the daytime.

The big thing I see with a ton of arguments about changing the way we produce and consume energy assume that things will change overnight and the whole system will come crashing down because it's not ready.

Perfect is the enemy of good. Things aren't going to happen overnight, there will be a transition period.

Electric vehicle transition is a good example of this. * OMG, the grid will crash with all the charging. * OMG, You won't be able to charge it <because reasons>. * OMG, it doesn't solve <random gas car use case here>.

The transition to electric vehicles is coming, but slowly. It basically started at 0 in 2010 and a decade later it's still only at 2-5% in the US and something like 5-10% in the EU, China, etc. The ball is just getting rolling.

The grid hasn't crashed, charging is getting deployed where there's demand, and not every <random gas car use case here> needs to be solved now, or even in the mid term future.

Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by Gwypaas on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:05PM (#34039658)
Both fission and fusion are awful at peaking. For peaker energy you want low capital investment and higher marginal costs.

Fusion and fission are extremely capital expensive with quite hefty marginal costs through the steam side. They're simply awful at solving the last 20%. Even worse when they're undercut badly enough to never run for the first 80%.

Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by DennisP on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:09PM (#34039718)
Whether fusion is good at peaking will depend on which fusion technologies end up working. Helion for one would be fantastic at peaking. It's likely to be quite cheap, wouldn't use a turbine, and could run fusion pulses at whatever rate we need.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by adgjlsfhk1 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:18PM (#34039830)
it's still a pretty bad peaker. it's cheaper than a tomumak but it still needs a ton of capacitors and incredibly precise machining.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by DennisP on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:58PM (#34040288)
They claim an electricity price of $0.01/kWh even before mass production kicks in. If they achieve that, the economics will work out fine.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by pfdietz on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:00PM (#34040327)
I'll believe that when I see it, but that price would be more than good enough to beat renewables.

I find it amusing that Helion's approach also strongly depends on the cost of storage, just in a very different part of storage parameter space.

Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by pfdietz on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:56PM (#34040263)
Helion's approach is I'd guess still dominated by capital cost, not fuel cost, so it's relatively bad at peaking. Granted, if they split the reactors into DD reactors making 3He, and field reactors burning the 3He (with reduced DD), it might make more sense to turn the latter up and down, if they have a relatively larger part of their cost from their fuel.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by bell-cot on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:12PM (#34042515)
With the capital costs of every form of ~continuous-output fusion reactor, the only fusion technology that would be good for peaking would be H-bombs.

That has been looked into, in the context of propelling very large spacecraft. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propuls... )

Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by ilyt on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:11PM (#34043451)
Why would fusion be bad for peaking ? It got none of the fission problems regarding that.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by moloch-hai on Monday December 19, 2022 @02:13AM (#34049382)
It has exactly the same problems, same as any high capex steam-driven turbine.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by throw_me_5555 on Monday December 19, 2022 @07:06AM (#34051146)
Can it start generating electricity without waiting for steam to reach required temperature? For now we can only assume the worst case scenario and group it with fission in "up to 12h startup time". The report in https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=45956 compares existing power sources
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by janef0421 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @05:09PM (#34044143)
They can't peak independently, but their reliability and low marginal cost means that they can are well suited to providing peaking capacity in conjunction with storage. Excess power from the reactor can be used to place energy in the storage source, which is then discharged during peak load. Due to the reliability of the nuclear generator, the amount of storage required can be relatively small.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by panick21_ on Sunday December 18, 2022 @06:18PM (#34045370)
You right, just build high-temperature nuclear and use if for everything, then no peaking is required. And you can also use if for both industrial and residential heat. Solving all your problems at once. If you have electrified transport (electric trains and electric cars) you can have a 100% green economy.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by AntoniusBlock on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:05PM (#34039672)
Depends on whether we improve battery technology, then we could store the excess for less windy days. Also I did a quick search and there are places on Earth that are consistently very windy, so we could maybe even set up massive wind farms there. Commonwealth Bay, Antartica is apparently the windiest place on Earth, where the average annual windspeed is 50mph, according to the Guinness World Record book.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by throwaway0x7E6 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:18PM (#34039828)
it isn't even economical to transfer electricity from north africa to europe
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:13PM (#34041601)
It's completely economical, and it's being worked on.

It's difficult for political reasons, not economic or practical ones.

Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by fpoling on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:18PM (#34043550)
UK is planing a cable from Morocco
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by moloch-hai on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:22PM (#34042711)
Battery technology doesn't need improvement, and most storage won't be in chemical batteries. Batteries will remain the expensive alternative.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by api on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:09PM (#34039719)
This already kind of happens in places with a lot of solar around noon. Not the extortionate part but the almost free when the system is saturated part.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by WaxProlix on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:02PM (#34042306)
Batteries are a thing, and continue to improve & diversify. The same arguments about pace apply here, too.
Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by audunw on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:02PM (#34043326)
> If fossil fuels and nuclear get phased out

Don't you realise the consequences of phasing out fossil fuels? So much of that is used for, well fuels.. and even when it isn't, like fertilisers, it's still something that's produced in bulk in large quantities and stored. We'll have to produce a HUGE amounts of hydrogen, ammonia, etc. .. and in the absolute worst case scenario we can store some of that hydrogen and use in in existing natural gas power plants (yes, running a turbine on 100% hydrogen has been demonstrated already).

We're already seeing the prices swing more due to renewables, and we're already seeing that it's creating a lot of solutions for shifting energy consumption. Right now I can connect my EV directly to my electricity provider and they'll stop or start charging based on prices. There's an entire parking garage in the Netherlands full of EV rental cars that can deliver power back to grid when prices are higher.

People seem to think nuclear will let us avoid solving the energy storage problems. No. You might be able to run some big ships on nuclear, but not much else. If we solve the problems we need to solve to stop climate change (in a sustainable way.. don't get me started on CCS), then we'll be doing energy storage at just around the same scale needed to balance renewables. BEVs is a pretty good illustration of that, where, if you have one you suddenly have enough energy storage to run your house a day or three. If we're making enough batteries for all cars to be EVs, we're making battery at a scale where a doubling could give most households dedicated battery storage. I'm not sure exactly that will be the solution, maybe it'll be more specialised grid-level batteries like Ambri.. point is, we're moving towards a world where we HAVE to become experts at transforming and storing energy. Cause we're not getting "free" storable/transportable energy from the ground for eternity.

Re:Why fusion will never happen (2012) by Archelaos on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:15PM (#34043509)
> when the wind blows, energy is basically free, and when it doesn't, it is extortionately expensive.

This is why one must look at the whole spectrum not only on wind and solar. There is hydro, biomass[1] and geothermal as well. The latter is currently not so relevant directly for electricity in most regions, but has a hugh potential to replace other energy sources, including electricity, for heating buildings via heat pumps.

[1] In the USA biomass plays a comparatively minor role in electricity production: 1.3% of all, 6.5% of renewables (half of solar). In a more advanced country like Germany the numbers are: 8.8% of all, 19% of renewables (a little less than solar). -- Sources: https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=427 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renewable_energy_in_Germany