Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted
by dsr_ on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:40AM
(#34038084)
Let's consider some simplified cases.
A. I get a copy of ChatGPT's code (via some legitimate means) and train it exclusively on my written work. I argue that all output from the dsr_%_ChatGPT instance is derivative from my work. I assert that when I prompt it, the results are also my work. Further, when someone else prompts it, the results are infringing on my work.
B. Same as A, but I train it 50% on my written work and 50% on jacquesm's written work. I assert that when I prompt it, the results always infringe on jacquesm, and if jacquesm prompts it, the results always infringe on me.
A. I get a copy of ChatGPT's code (via some legitimate means) and train it exclusively on my written work. I argue that all output from the dsr_%_ChatGPT instance is derivative from my work. I assert that when I prompt it, the results are also my work. Further, when someone else prompts it, the results are infringing on my work.
B. Same as A, but I train it 50% on my written work and 50% on jacquesm's written work. I assert that when I prompt it, the results always infringe on jacquesm, and if jacquesm prompts it, the results always infringe on me.
Does anyone disagree with either of the above?