News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by jacquesm on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:08AM (#34037752)
I wonder what the implications are for AI generated code. The implications for that could be massive, including all code generated by tools such as co-pilot.
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by dsr_ on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:40AM (#34038084)
Let's consider some simplified cases.

A. I get a copy of ChatGPT's code (via some legitimate means) and train it exclusively on my written work. I argue that all output from the dsr_%_ChatGPT instance is derivative from my work. I assert that when I prompt it, the results are also my work. Further, when someone else prompts it, the results are infringing on my work.

B. Same as A, but I train it 50% on my written work and 50% on jacquesm's written work. I assert that when I prompt it, the results always infringe on jacquesm, and if jacquesm prompts it, the results always infringe on me.

Does anyone disagree with either of the above?

Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by jacquesm on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:42AM (#34038115)
That's a very interesting way to try to find the line.
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by rjzzleep on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:13AM (#34037796)
I was wondering the same. If you can feed a bunch of code into an AI and then use the generated code that's basically like a money mixer. Do you get to decompile things then and then feed them with existing code into an AI? Can you reuse the leaked Microsoft code when you mix it with other code into a dataset? Can a third party do it and you claim ignorance when you use it?
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by namaria on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:18AM (#34037853)
Legal matters don't exist in a vacuum. Short answer is: yes you can do all of those things. But some of them might land you in hot water if done in the context of a contract. Copyright is not absolute, it's about what potential claims people might have.