News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by ckocagil on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:16AM (#34037836)
That brings the question: in order for a work to be copyrighted, does a human need to put "some" effort into generating that work (prompt engineering, tweaking knobs, etc.) or does it suffice to click a "generate" button?
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by ClumsyPilot on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:19AM (#34037858)
Clicking the shutter on the camera grants you copyright. As things stand, clicking a button is enough
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by jacquesm on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:21AM (#34037888)
To some degree this probably applies:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monkey_selfie_copyright_disput...

And that might lead to an argument that if the human doesn't hold the copyright the AI does, but then you are back to square one because you need to be a legal entity to hold copyright.

Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by ape4 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:20AM (#34037882)
Of there is more to that than taking a photo. You have to be at the location. Aim at the subject. Possibly select other settings.
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by molotovh on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:46PM (#34041160)
There is more to taking a photo, yes, but not to claiming a copyright, at least not in the US.

"Generally, the author and initial copyright owner of a photograph is the person who 'shoots' or 'takes' the photo."

https://www.copyright.gov/engage/photographers/

Let's say a photographer sets up his camera, aims it, composes it, focuses it, etc. But he decides the light isn't quite right yet, so he goes for lunch. While he is away, his assistant clicks the shutter on a whim, capturing more or less the exact image what the photographer intended to capture. The resulting photograph's copyright belongs to the assistant, not the photographer.

This is in theory, of course. In practice, this would be difficult to prove, since the picture is likely to be on a roll of many other pictures for which the photographer does own the copyright. The assistant would need some definitive evidence that they clicked the shutter on that exact frame if they wanted credit for their work.

Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by bilbo0s on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:26AM (#34037941)
Not to be too pedantic but wouldn't that fall under the questioner's definition of fiddling with knobs?

I mean, if you have to point the camera, and set the fstop or set photo vs pano, or even just set the flash or what have you, aren't you kind of key to generating that image? (Even though you generated it with the press of the button.) I mean, if the human didn't point the camera and set the settings, it would be a different picture even if someone did push the button on a camera that was just sitting on a table say.

Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by Ekaros on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:24AM (#34037912)
Also EU makes this different. Just taking a generic image. As in one that many other people would take might not reach level of originality and thus not entail copyright.
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by ipaddr on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:33AM (#34037999)
That seems like an easy place to introduce gatekeepers to allow some to keep copyright and disallow others based on political reasons
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by js8 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:49AM (#34038190)
The concept of property is in itself political, because some have it and some do not.
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by ClumsyPilot on Sunday December 18, 2022 @10:18AM (#34038460)
Intellectual proterty is political. If you have a patent, I cannotncreate the se thing even if I came up with the idea independantly and neber heard of you.

You are using the power of the state to restrict my freedoms.

Copyright is slightly different, but still

Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by jacquesm on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:19AM (#34037874)
Speculation: this will hinge on whether or not that input can be considered a copyrighted work by itself. A prompt may well be too short, and if someone else could come up with the identical prompt in a natural setting and generate the exact same output then I would lean towards 'no', if it takes who gives the prompt into account then the answer might be 'yes'.
Re:U.S. copyright office rules A.I. art can’t be copyrighted by barbariangrunge on Sunday December 18, 2022 @09:19AM (#34037860)
Or even more generally, does blindfolded painting while drunk, half by accident, for 3 seconds count? How do deliberate and skillful does it have to be?