News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Accounting firm Mazars drops all crypto clients, includin... by LatteLazy on Saturday December 17, 2022 @09:32AM (#34028049)
It's a pity. Proper audits would be a boon for honest crypto exchanges and it would be an opportunity for accountants to show they can actually add value after all the scandals of the last 30 years...
Re:Accounting firm Mazars drops all crypto clients, includin... by coffeebeqn on Saturday December 17, 2022 @10:02AM (#34028277)
The crypto companies don’t allow real audits. They just do “attestations” where the company can arrange things beforehand to look the way they want and doesn’t allow the accountant to dig behind the presented numbers
Re:Accounting firm Mazars drops all crypto clients, includin... by LatteLazy on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:11PM (#34030456)
As soon as one does, others will have to follow. And right now, accounting companies don't do real audits either (hence Enron and WorldCom and dozens of other examples).

This is an opportunity for both of them to up their games.

Re:Accounting firm Mazars drops all crypto clients, includin... by quickthrowman on Saturday December 17, 2022 @10:15AM (#34028396)
> honest crypto exchanges

I am reminded of Diogenes walking the streets of Corinth during the day with a lantern, looking for an honest man.

The only one I would expect to be somewhat honest is coinbase, on account of the mandatory SEC filings and actual audits (vs attestations) but Enron, MCI, Tyco, and many other companies had the same oversight, so I’m still skeptical about coinbase being honest.

Re:Accounting firm Mazars drops all crypto clients, includin... by ceejayoz on Saturday December 17, 2022 @10:20AM (#34028440)
> Proper audits would be a boon for honest crypto exchanges...

Correct!

Ask yourself if "audits are impossible" is the likely answer to their rarity.

Re:Accounting firm Mazars drops all crypto clients, includin... by jmull on Saturday December 17, 2022 @10:31AM (#34028527)
Exactly. There's no such thing as a proper audit for crypto.

Perhaps it could be invented, but no one has.

I doubt the will to do it exists, since that would seem to be against the interests of all the big crypto players.

Re:Accounting firm Mazars drops all crypto clients, includin... by ceejayoz on Saturday December 17, 2022 @10:33AM (#34028552)
> There's no such thing as a proper audit for crypto.

No, this is absolutely the wrong take.

Crypto isn't special. It can be audited, and nothing has to be invented. Coinbase has audit reports.

Re:Accounting firm Mazars drops all crypto clients, includin... by mschuster91 on Saturday December 17, 2022 @10:54AM (#34028817)
What? In fact, crypto is the easiest thing to audit - require the person that claims to own a wallet to sign a challenge you provide with the public key, and check if the signature matches with your challenge and the public key of the wallet and the wallet's balance from the public blockchain matches the claim of the auditee. And you can completely automate this without having to involve a third party like a bank.
Re:Accounting firm Mazars drops all crypto clients, includin... by ceejayoz on Saturday December 17, 2022 @11:51AM (#34029523)
The likely challenge for the shadier exchanges it the “ok, but what have you used these coins you demonstrably possess as collateral for?”

Having $10B in crypto is easy to audit. Finding out $20B is owed is where it gets exciting, FTX-style.

Re:Accounting firm Mazars drops all crypto clients, includin... by xg15 on Saturday December 17, 2022 @12:29PM (#34029955)
Not to mention, the risks tied to the coins itself. FTX was also fully backed, on paper. The problem was just that their reserves were in their own fantasy money, which lost all of its value the moment FTX got into trouble. (And how the real dollars that people had deposited somehow turned into fantasy money is the magic trick that brought SBF free lodging in the Bahamian jail)

So an audit wouldn't just have to prove the assets are there on some chain, it would also have to verify the chain itself is actually suitable as a reserve.

Re:Accounting firm Mazars drops all crypto clients, includin... by blitzar on Saturday December 17, 2022 @11:39PM (#34035098)
> require the person that claims to own a wallet to sign a challenge you provide with the public key

That takes care of the assets ... now the liabilities

Re:Accounting firm Mazars drops all crypto clients, includin... by xg15 on Saturday December 17, 2022 @12:24PM (#34029900)
Well, no one is stopping them...