News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How do you protect your children from internet ad... by sowbug on Friday December 16, 2022 @11:21PM (#34024617)
If my kid asked me about heroin, he'd be asking for advice, not permission. Kids do much more than their parents know about; they always have, they always will. Imagine if your kid came to you asking for advice, and you responded as if you were asked for permission.

| "Dad, what do you think about heroin?"

| "If you go near that stuff, you'll be grounded for a month."

| "Thanks, Dad." (proceeds to try heroin)

In the time I typed this, probably 1,000 kids around the world had the very same conversation with a parent about various difficult subjects including drug use. That's 1,000 missed opportunities for parents to have real conversations with their children.

I have a few thoughts about the rest of your comment.

First, you're defining "addiction" very broadly. It's hard to reconcile why your girlfriend is a "victim," but "literally every parent" on the playground was doing the same thing. At a certain point, behaviors become norms. If phones didn't exist, what would those parents on the playground be doing instead? Probably not heroin, but probably not work that society highly values, either. And nothing so extreme that it's my business to judge them.

Second, it's very difficult to address your "the question is really about addiction" point without conceding a false premise. My comment wasn't about how I deal with it; it was about how to prepare my children to deal with it. Which absolutely is about addiction, or rather about avoiding addiction. (To be clear, I'm talking about addiction in the classic sense that causes a person to make destructive life choices to feed their addiction, and absolutely not about the "addiction" that declares that there is a problem with a parent's manner of sitting on a bench on a sunny day in a park.)

If OP were asking how to stop mobile-phone usage, I'd have ignored the post entirely, because in my opinion that's a misguided goal. OP asked "do you take any precautions to help your children avoid falling prey to [internet addiction]?" That's a very different question. And my answer was to teach my children not to become prey.

Re:Ask HN: How do you protect your children from internet ad... by europeanguy on Saturday December 17, 2022 @02:55AM (#34025800)
> That's a very different question. And my answer was to teach my children not to become prey.

Yeah but from your answers it looks like you failed at that. All your example interactions seem to come from kids that can't take their eyes off the screen.

Re:Ask HN: How do you protect your children from internet ad... by sowbug on Saturday December 17, 2022 @09:45AM (#34028142)
You really want this discussion to be about tactics to avoid screens! Can't help you with that. Good luck finding them elsewhere.
Re:Ask HN: How do you protect your children from internet ad... by europeanguy on Saturday December 17, 2022 @02:12PM (#34031078)
The title of this thread is "how do you protect your children from Internet addiction", so you're the one who really wants this discussion to be about something that no one else is taking about.