News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Norvig critically reviews AlphaCode's code quality by jvm___ on Friday December 16, 2022 @04:57PM (#34021056)
In my head I picture these models like if you built a massive scaffold. Just boxes upon boxes, enough to fill a whole school gym, or even cover a football field. Everything is bolted together.

You walk up to one side and Say "write me a poem on JVM". The signals race through the cube and your answer appears on the other side. You want to change something, go back and say another thing - new answer on the other side.

But it's all fixed together like metal scaffolding. The network doesn't change. Sure, it's massive and has a bajillion routes through it, but it's not fixed.

The next step is to make the grid flexible. It can mold and reshape itself based on inputs and output results. I think the challenge is to keep the whole thing together, while allowed it to shape-shift. Too much movement and your network looses parts of itself, or collapses altogether.

Just because we can build a complex, but fixed, scaffolding system, doesn't mean we can build one that adapts and stays together. Broken is a more likely outcome than AGI.

Re:Peter Norvig critically reviews AlphaCode's code quality by yesenadam on Friday December 16, 2022 @05:25PM (#34021417)
> it's massive and has a bajillion routes through it, but it's not fixed.

I think you meant to write "but it's fixed."

Re:Peter Norvig critically reviews AlphaCode's code quality by jvm___ on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:18PM (#34021973)
Thanks
Re:Peter Norvig critically reviews AlphaCode's code quality by urthor on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:52AM (#34025506)
> The next step is to make the grid flexible.

But... we can do exactly that???

Model retraining is very transparent and a very straightforward way to redirect it.

The core problem is that the analogies just don't hold up.

Artificial Intelligence is not a problem that can be resolved via analogies and heuristics.

Because artificial intelligence simply looks nothing like what our human heuristics imagine it to be.

It can only be solved by understanding the actual, genuine detail.

Re:Peter Norvig critically reviews AlphaCode's code quality by jvm___ on Saturday December 17, 2022 @09:40PM (#34034577)
Is there a 3d structure that you think is more analogous?

From my understanding it's all matrix math, which to me is a grid. Maybe not a scaffolding one, and more like a bundle of interconnected wires so that each concept has multiple related concepts, but I think a rigid grid is easier to explain to lay people.