News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by jrockway on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:35PM (#3401894)
I think the most important thing you can do are long cardio sessions. 3-6 hours at low intensity. This is what trains your body to burn fat, because your body learns that it does not need fast energy.

If you do a daily 1-2 hour bike ride at moderate intensity (which many people do), that's nice, but it doesn't increase your fitness past a certain point or burn much fat. You just deplete your glycogen stores (about 1600 calories worth) which your next couple meals replenish. (I know because I have done this for many years and my speed does not increase unless I became way out of shape for some reason. You become fit enough to do your normal ride and that's as far as you go unless you add intervals or time.)

Short interval sessions at VO2max, as you suggest, are definitely good for you (feel those endorphins!), but they don't train your body to burn fat, they train your circulatory system to remove lactate. This is good if you are a bicycle racer or a marathon runner, but largely useless if you are trying to lose weight. (I know because I've done running and cycling intervals for a couple years and have weighed the same the entire time. More speed at the same heart rate, though, but I wish I had a power meter to really measure the effect of interval training.)

Anyway, my advice would be to go for a 3 hour walk on Saturday afternoon. Get a heart rate monitor to ensure that you're in your aerobic zone while doing so. If you want to be a bike racer or marathon runner or triathlete, then do interval training (and buy a book about it, and get a trainer). But for "normal people" that want to do something other than watch TV, it's not the best use of your time.

As for diet, processed foods are not the problem. Yes, they taste bad and are devices for evil corporations to make extra money at your expense. Avoid them for that reason, not because they are making you fat. You get fat because you eat more calories than your body needs, not because you eat sugar. It's just that it's very easy to eat a lot of calories worth of sugar without feeling full, and so you eat way more than your body needs.

I haven't been very successful with weight loss because I haven't followed two of my rules. I didn't start weekly long cardio sessions until last week, and I still haven't quite found the ideal diet for myself. Interval training with running and cycling have kept me in pretty darn good shape, but I still have a lot of excess fat. (I need to add weightlifting to my regimen also, but only because I want the core and arm strength, not because I think I'm going to lose any weight.)

Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:55PM (#3401957)
You could think that.

You'd be wrong.

Short, high-intensity work, and strength training, both have very large EPOC effects (excess post-exercise oxygen consumption).

The issues with processed foods are manifold. They're also easily avoided by eliminating the foods completely. A large part of the problem is that they encourage yet more overeating, while being robbed of crucial nutrients. Whole foods typically promote satiety while being nutrient-rich.

You might do better on your goals to follow up on a few of the references I've posted, as well as your own further research.

I do believe in a long training session, possibly two, per week. And I really enjoy it (hiking, cycling, rowing). But I don't think, my experience hasn't shown, and research doesn't support this being the missing factor for most people.

Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by rdouble on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @07:03PM (#3401976)
EPOC is not that useful as a weight loss aid. Firstly, it's impossible to measure so you really have no idea how many extra calories are being expended.

Secondly, in the articles about EPOC, it's shown that the EPOC effect is nothing compared to the extra calories you burn doing long bouts of cardio. It's like 200 calories over the course of a day vs. 1000 calories in 75 minutes.

Thirdly, cardio itself has an EPOC afterburn effect.

It's trendy on the internet to espouse SS/SL workouts and HIIT cardio as the end all and be all of fitness, but most people, especially those with a lot of weight to lose, can get good results with relatively minor diet changes and an hour or two of brisk walking per day.

Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @07:28PM (#3402040)
EPOC gives you a training effect without the training cost.

A good Tabata workout, including warm-up and some extra farting around, fits well within 30 minutes. Of which approximately 4 are spent trying to expel my lungs from my body through my nose. The rest of it is virtually enjoyable by comparison.

I'll be toasty, as in sweat-dripping-off-my-brow toasty, for the next 3-4 hours. And feel an elevated metabolism through the next day.

For squats and deads its pretty much the same, except that I can feel the elevation (it'd be interested to actually measure core body temps) for about twice as long.

If you're training for 4-6 hours, you're introducing catabolism and other stress factors into the equation. Remember, all training is stress. If body recomp is your goal, and mass gain is a part of that, then tearing your muscles down for 3-5 hours once or twice (or more) weekly isn't helping you.

If you want a sense of how effective long-duration cardio is at stripping lean muscle mass, consider that trans-oceanic rowers (a cohort I've met several members of) lose 30-40# or more in a typical crossing of 90-180 days, largely muscle mass. Granted, that's a sustained 8-10 hr/day of rowing, but the principle is similar.

EPOC is your friend if your goal is lean mass gains and peak cardiovascular fitness, along with fat loss.

Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by rdouble on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @07:30PM (#3402043)
Yeah, I know the standard internet spiel about EPOC. I just think it's broscience and bad advice for the majority of people looking for health and fitness information.
Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @07:52PM (#3402102)
Well, there's also an established literature going back a few decades. Rather more than broscience:

http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=epoc+excess+post+exercis...

Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by rdouble on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @07:59PM (#3402121)
If you read those studies, they confirm what I said in my previous post. There is an EPOC effect, but it is minimal compared to doing more exercise. There is also an EPOC effect for cardio, it's just not as pronounced as weight training. (but it's not much less, either, more like 5% less)

The bigger issue is there is no way for the casual exerciser to measure EPOC, whereas it's straightforward to measure calorie intake and calorie expenditure. Thus, it's not very useful as a weight loss aid, because you have no idea how much of an afterburn effect really occurs. If you can't measure it yourself, it's effectively broscience, even if there is real science behind the idea.

Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by jrockway on Thursday December 29, 2011 @01:46AM (#3402812)
I'm going to agree with this. What you can't measure, you can't improve. Sure, there is some EPOC effect, but how am I going to use that to benefit me? How do I know that 30 minutes of intervals + EPOC is better than 4 hours of low-intensity cardio? (I think the answer is, "a lab can measure this for you". But is it worthwhile to pay for this when your body is in a constant state of change and you aren't a professional athlete? )
Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by dredmorbius on Thursday December 29, 2011 @01:25PM (#3404653)
The benefit, for the trainee looking to improve overall body composition, is that HIIT provides both cardiovascular and EPOC benefits without the concomitant catabolic effects of frequent prolonged aerobic activity.

Fat loss is mostly about diet, full stop. If you're doing cardio to burn fat, you're mostly looking in the wrong place.

If you want to lose fat, gain muscle, and improve cardiovascular fitness, as well as boost overall metabolism, incorporating HIIT (and benefiting from EPOC) increases both training efficiency and overall body composition, as you'll make faster lean mass gains.

Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by jrockway on Thursday December 29, 2011 @01:12AM (#3402746)
Not sure why this is downmodded so far, so I'll give a citation that says exactly what I do:

http://www.amazon.com/Zinns-Cycling-Primer-Maintenance-Build...

Some exercise is going to be better than no exercise, but training for a marathon and "getting exercise" are vastly different activities.