News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by nonethewiser on Friday December 16, 2022 @11:51AM (#34016815)
It's a novelty. This is the wrong tool for anyone who actually needs a truck.
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by tashoecraft on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:04PM (#34017036)
no. You're just wwrong. It's the wrong tool if you need to tow for more than 100 miles in a single day. It's become very political tool to state that if electric vehicles cannot be better than gas/diesel at every single metric it's a failure. All the reviews are glowing about electric vehicles. Every manufacturer is scrambling to produce one. Demand is insane. Performance is better than anything comparable, and event to things incomparable. A Lucid air performance is faster than a Bugatti Chiron in the quarter mile.

Also I believe 90% of truck owners only use their truck bed once per year or less. Is it stupid they want trucks? Probably, but that's the way it is.

Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by kdkdkdl on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:17PM (#34017234)
Where'd you find that usage data on trucks? I'd love to see it, especially if the people running the study broke down the usage of the truck by commercial vs residential ownership and rural vs urban location.

Would you mind linking it? You don't want people thinking that you just made up a number

Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by bombcar on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:26PM (#34017374)
> According to Edwards’ data, 75 percent of truck owners use their truck for towing one time a year or less (meaning, never). Nearly 70 percent of truck owners go off-road one time a year or less. And a full 35 percent of truck owners use their truck for hauling—putting something in the bed, its ostensible raison d’être—once a year or less.

https://www.thedrive.com/news/26907/you-dont-need-a-full-siz...

So they're close on towing but way off on the bed.

It also overlooks that people who only buy ONE vehicle are best off buying a truck or largish SUV so it can do "all they ever need" - to have a small car you kind of really need to have a second vehicle that's larger, or it gets quite annoying.

Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by estebank on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:42PM (#34017634)
The thing I don't get is that a common retort to critiques od the usage patterns is "who can afford to buy two vehicles!?", but if you look at the cost of these trucks, and the number of comfort features they are marketed with, the market could provide a work truck at a lower price point with enough left over for a comfortable more reasonably sized vehicle. And that's what tradespeople in other countries (where purchasing vehicles is usually felt more in the purse): own a base model work van and an everyday car. But people who work in offices that own trucks? Those are purchased not to move the odd couch while also giving a lift to 6 people, it is pure cosplay.
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by MerelyMortal on Friday December 16, 2022 @01:15PM (#34018030)
That covers insurance, parking, maintenance, etc?
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by rizzom5000 on Friday December 16, 2022 @01:08PM (#34017940)
> It also overlooks that people who only buy ONE vehicle are best off buying a truck or largish SUV so it can do "all they ever need" - to have a small car you kind of really need to have a second vehicle that's larger, or it gets quite annoying.

Logically, it appears to be a trade-off between money and convenience. The money argument is trivial as the total cost of ownership is basic math. The convenience argument is less obvious to me as it's very inexpensive to have Lowe's/Home Depot ship to home and hiring someone to haul a couch once a year is also much less than the cost to own a truck versus a car.

There is also the moral argument if you care about such things as climate change and being a role model for others in your community; and whether or not your need to own a truck/SUV outweighs those considerations in your own mind.

The one argument that does make logical sense to me is the one around safety. Outside of that I agree with the other commenter and would suggest that for the majority of truck owners, it's mostly cosplay.

Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by bombcar on Friday December 16, 2022 @02:23PM (#34018888)
The convenience argument is huge - the additional TIME hassle for the Lowes truck/hiring someone is substation if you have the money to not have to think about it.

A modern SUV can get quite decent gas mileage, too.

Obviously there are people who buy an F350 just to drive to work for no good reason, but it's not as clear-cut as "nobody ever needs a truck/SUV and anyone who buys one is ontologically evil".

I don't know the "actual new vehicle" cost breakdown, but I wouldn't be surprised if the average car price is quite high, comparable perhaps to the average truck. Most people who are "price sensitive" don't buy new anyway, and a number of manufacturers aren't selling cars at all anymore, only SUV/trucks.

Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by rizzom5000 on Friday December 16, 2022 @03:33PM (#34019947)
Totally agree that the rare times I need to rent a truck, it's a major hassle. I wonder if there is an opportunity for an Uber/Lyft type of truck share service.
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by bombcar on Friday December 16, 2022 @04:13PM (#34020468)
I've started to use delivery from places like HD, it's often not that expensive. The problem with the little rental truck is you have to drive it back and get your car.

For largish but still not huge truck items Uber "SUV" might work, but most people just call their friends with a truck.

A smallish vehicle with a trailer hitch is pretty good, but you have to know you're going to get something big so you bring the trailer.

Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by rurp on Friday December 16, 2022 @03:06PM (#34019569)
EV is an exciting space but this is overstating things by more than a tad. There are still plenty of limitations and tradeoffs compared to ICE vehicles, and pretending otherwise isn't going to help aboption. I considered buying an EV for my latest car but ultimately opted not to for reasons that have been widely discussed (range, UX, price, availability).
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by mrexroad on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:30PM (#34017434)
Curious why you say that? I’m seriously considering an EV pickup in next few years. I currently am using a minivan with seats removed for most of my construction and hauling needs (fwiw, I beefed up brakes, monitor tranny temp w/ heavy loads, etc). I don’t usually travel more than a 30mi radius in a day so an EV would be ideal; throw in features like 120/240v or compressed air hookups and I even start rethinking workflows. For now my minivan gets it done as long as I’m careful.

If we’re just making flippant generalizations, I’ll throw out that most people driving brodozers don’t actually “need” a truck and just enjoy the novelty.

Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by Enginerrrd on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:01PM (#34016982)
I'm not sure I totally agree.

I have a truck, and you're right, for most of my truck use-cases this won't work, primarily due to range issues and lack of ability to quickly top up.

However, for some of my uses where I'm driving a lot of relatively close forestry roads and just hauling survey/engineering gear and the like, it's basically got enough range although it might get tight every once in a while. But it's got the 4wd ability, it can tow a modest trailer, etc. The lack of ability to top off at some rural gas station though is still kind of a deal breaker.

For short duration / light-weight hauling/towing in town, I think this would do fine.

Combine the truck with a gasoline range-extender and it would probably work for me though.

Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by randomdata on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:16PM (#34017214)
I think it would be the perfect farm truck. The bed to move things, like fuel, seed, chemicals, and tools, from field to field, the cabin to move people from field to field, and electricity to power things, like welders or motors, in the field. You don't need much range and you've got tractors (field or highway) around for when you need serious towing capacity. The price is a little much for a farm truck, granted.
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by RhysU on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:20PM (#34017283)
Don't the agricultural diesel subsidies Bork the economics on this specific use case?
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by randomdata on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:23PM (#34017322)
The only diesel "subsidy" I am familiar with is colored fuel, which exempts the road tax for off-road vehicles. A pickup truck would not be eligible to use such fuel as it is deemed an on-road vehicle. Maybe there is some other subsidy in your jurisdiction?
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by bombcar on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:28PM (#34017405)
They're probably imagining a truck that never leaves the farm but even then in most jurisdictions you can't run red-dye in it (though nobody will ever catch you).

And if you never leave the property than you can get one of those electric cart things I guess.

Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by RhysU on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:47PM (#34022277)
That was indeed what I meant. Lightning vs old red-dye rust bucket farm truck never on the road (wink). The latter seems like it has to be wildly more economical over a full lifetime.
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by bombcar on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:41PM (#34022775)
The rust bucket is gonna win every single time no matter what, because it already exists and is cheap as hell, so even if it has more costs and emissions when running, it still will be a win over a brand new truck.
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by randomdata on Saturday December 17, 2022 @12:29AM (#34025067)
Such a truck doesn't get much use. Even if you broke the law I'd think you'd be hard pressed, at least based on the road tax rate in my jurisdiction, to save more than tens of dollars each year. Hardly makes a difference and certainly not worth the risk for trying.

But you're right that because such vehicles are barely used they start life on the farm as old beaters. That's what I was meaning when I said that the Lighting is too expensive to be a farm truck. Aside from cost, though, they otherwise look quite ideal for the task.

Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by bombcar on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:03PM (#34032219)
I wouldn’t be surprised to see them doing the task years from now - 20% battery left wouldn’t be an issue and by then probably easier to buy a new one.
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by stcroixx on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:58PM (#34017797)
Eh, I have a farm and while I was initially excited, the lack of tow range is a dealbreaker. If you have livestock, you need to be able to pull a gooseneck trailer. Since this can't do that for any useful distance, you'd have to have another heavy duty truck around just for this. You're going places like auctions, other farms, slaughterhouse, etc. that are usually out of tractor range.
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by randomdata on Friday December 16, 2022 @01:18PM (#34018076)
I was imagining it being a 'service' truck, particularly for grain farms (the kind of farm I have). They don't do much other than cart light things around and don't have to travel that far between fields, and often get towed there behind a tractor anyway. The problem is that nobody keeps a brand new truck as their dedicated service truck. If a good used market ever opens up, though...
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by mc32 on Friday December 16, 2022 @11:56AM (#34016912)
I mean, sure, you don't wanna pull a boat, if you're not close to shore. But probably works for construction sites where you might be towing, but not for long distances. Possibly, for smaller site it may mean not having to being your Ingersoll-Rand.
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by yourapostasy on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:08PM (#34017096)
That's an awful lot of money for such a niche tool. I can see it happening regularly and the numbers penciling out if a company regularly worked on say, large commercial projects on large lots. Similar to how the very large trucking companies getting a yard truck for their big trailer yards, for example.

Personally, I'd have to be convinced that these amounts of capex could be amortized over a commensurately longer time period to balance out more traditional solutions.

Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by bombcar on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:32PM (#34017464)
E150 - $56k

Gas - $3.29 gallon

F150 city fuel economy - 20 mpg.

So if you drive your F150 320k miles in-town, the gas pays for the E150.

This ignores electricity costs, but that makes it worse. So it's not quite worth it yet to buy an E150 to supplement an F150.

Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by mc32 on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:41PM (#34017611)
150,000mi is approx break-even, taking the price difference into account.
Re:Ford again hikes the starting price of the F150 Lighting ... by bombcar on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:53PM (#34017727)
That's assuming you never need the range/capacity of the bigger truck (which may be the case if you have multiple trucks).