News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @05:11PM (#3401626)
That's at the high end of reasonable, but lean gains on the order of 3# per week aren't unheard of. Mark Rippetoe documents one in his "Novice Effect" in which the gains were 2.84#/week over 11 weeks: http://startingstrength.com/articles/novice_effect_rippetoe....

I'd suspect that OP was hitting 50-50 for lean vs. fat mass, but that's still 12 pounds in a month, or about 3# per week. For a highly talented, untrained novice just starting to lift heavy on a milk-heavy diet, within reason/credulity. Though it'd be nice to see witnesses or supporting docs.

Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by kenjackson on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @05:23PM (#3401673)
From the article you linked, "A best case scenario is Zach’s – he comes in skinny and weak, trains to his full potential, recovers to his full potential, and therefore expresses his optimum capacity for growth and strength. If Zach’s is the best-case scenario, the fact that you don’t really believe it happened the way I’ve described (you really don’t, do you?) means that it happens infrequently enough that less-than-best-case scenarios are the norm."

I don't doubt Mark. But Mark had to couch Zach's story so many times in, "I know... hard to believe"isms that it's super clear that it's something even rare for him to see. Double that rate of lean musle mass gains? I find that seriously hard to believe. I suspect Mark would too.

Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by ellyagg on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @05:35PM (#3401718)
Look, of course it would be nice for documentation. I didn't set out to prove anything. This was just my experience. I would like for people to believe, but I'm not selling anything, and I have nothing to lose.

Was it 50-50 lean to fat? Well, I can say that my waist size didn't increase, and no one by visual inspection could point to any subcutaneous fat deposits. A normal person looking at me before and after would say that I had strictly increased in muscularity.

Re:The Fat Trap: Our Bodies Are Fighting Against Us by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:06PM (#3401817)
Easy there ... I'm mostly agreeing with you.