News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by mickeyp on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:25AM (#34013336)
Because despite its predatory pricing and quirks, it's actually a pretty good database?

There's an enormous amount of larger businesses for whom the database _is_ the business. (Well, databases plural, they'll inevitably have many.)

I've worked for places where the vendor of the software that sits on top of the DB is either defunct, gone AWOL or too pricey to consider upgrading what ever version of software we were using.

I worked one place where we had to large hadron collide data from Sybase and Oracle together. Live. No batching. The whole thing had to plug into some decades old Delphi crud apps + some financial software somewhere else.

Oracle + dblink made that possible. It even, as I recall, did proper two-phase across the dblink. I merely queried -- yes, I know PG kinda has the same feature nowadays -- across the database boundaries and wrote some pg/Sql to make things work. 10 minutes and $10k (or w/e the Sybase connector cost) later and we had a POC, and later that month, a working system.

Pretty? No. But it worked well, and two disparate software products written in different eras that were never meant to talk to one another now did. And it saves us millions in licencing + bespoke software and expensive consultants.

There are few limits to what you can do with Oracle, and that is its strength. When you have weirdo requirements, you can probably do it with Oracle + some skilled DBAs and be assured it'll still run in 20 years.

As for PG: I love PG, and use it for everything greenfield. But its replication is still a planet-sized joke. There are more competing methods and processes than there are JS frameworks. With Oracle, you've got DBAs who know this stuff inside out, and it works, and it has a million-billion ways of matching the needs of your business. With PG? I don't even know who to call if things are up the creek.

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by pclmulqdq on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:37AM (#34013445)
It's not really a good database. By most actual database-related metrics, it's worse than most of its competitors on durability, performance, cost, etc.

It's just one that has people to call when it breaks.

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by nordsieck on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:41AM (#34013483)
> it's worse than most of its competitors on durability, performance, cost, etc.

When you say competitors, do you mean:

1. paid competitors like DB2/MSSQL

2. free competitors like Postgres/MariaDB

3. both

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by pclmulqdq on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:52AM (#34014445)
I generally mean the free competitors, but also the "NewSQL" DBs, cloud company offerings, and data warehousing companies. The traditional "enterprise" databases like MSSQL and Oracle all look kind of silly (from a technical perspective) in comparison.
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by trollied on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:19AM (#34013757)
I don't think that's true. RAC/data guard are solid, and I don't think have any competition.
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by hans_castorp on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:17AM (#34014182)
> I don't think that's true. RAC/data guard are solid, and I don't think have any competition.

RAC does not indeed.

But the equivalent of an active data guard can be setup in minutes (even less with the right tools) with Postgres. I am sure this is possible with other databases as well.

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by Spooky23 on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:33AM (#34014316)
It can be setup, but will it work?
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by pclmulqdq on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:57AM (#34014484)
RAC's PostgreSQL-based competitors are CockroachDB, Amazon Aurora, and Google's AlloyDB. I'm sure there will be an open-source PG plugin that does the same thing soon. These are all scale-out, globally consistent databases. Also, they have fewer bugs than Oracle.
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by narrator on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:47AM (#34013957)
You can get commercial support for PostgreSQL that's pretty good.
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by frou_dh on Friday December 16, 2022 @09:00AM (#34014503)
From this classic HN comment it sounds like working on the Oracle codebase is an exercise in clusterfuckery:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18442941

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by seanw444 on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:10PM (#34017131)
Sounds like they spend 80% of their CPU cycles checking flags...
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by pantulis on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:59AM (#34013606)
Great insights there. I would add that enterprise CIOs paying Oracle through the nose are not idiots, and would have analysed the tradeoffs. Of course there is no company that does not have a migration plan for its workloads but, like mainframe migrations, this stuff is not easy and it could very possibly not make sense.
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by mickeyp on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:07AM (#34013667)
Indeed. It's easy to laugh at CIOs and CTOs, but many of them try their best with the options they have available.

I'm reminded of this anecdote I had with a colleague a while back. He was railing against MS Exchange's rise back in the 90s, and how Novell Netware was better and that he was forced to switch their org to MS Exchange, back then, solely because "His CIO read it was the future in a magazine."

And so it was. Today, Netware's dead.

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by naasking on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:40AM (#34013913)
> solely because "His CIO read it was the future in a magazine." And so it was. Today, Netware's dead.

Could have been a self-fulfilling prophecy, and not something that would have happened without CIOs reading that magazine.

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by owl57 on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:10AM (#34014131)
Could be. That would mean it was good judgement to read the magazine that the other CIOs were also reading.
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by naasking on Friday December 16, 2022 @09:00AM (#34014500)
I'm not sure sprinting towards a self-fulfilling prophecy should count as good judgment. It seems like there's a fallacy in there.
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by aserafini on Friday December 16, 2022 @10:23AM (#34015562)
It makes sense if the self-fulfilling prophecy is outside your control.
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by pantulis on Friday December 16, 2022 @11:51AM (#34016825)
Yeah, it's called "marketing" :D
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by nradov on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:50AM (#34014426)
The magazine wasn't wrong. NetWare was a real mess architecturally. The core file and printer sharing features worked great. But as an application server for email, database, or anything else it was a dead end. No memory protection, no real multitasking, bizarre proprietary API, terrible developer tools. One of the major relational database vendors did actually port their product to NetWare but it was a flop in the market.

Novell eventually tried to catch up by grafting their proprietary networking features onto Unix but that was too little, too late. The CIOs who started migrating off of NetWare early were the smart ones.

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by therealcamino on Friday December 16, 2022 @09:10AM (#34014602)
I agree completely. But man, it was pretty amazing as a file server for DOS machines. You could boot a roomful of diskless PCs over ethernet from a 386 server, and for most uses the speed felt like you had a local hard drive in each one.
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by hackandthink on Friday December 16, 2022 @10:28AM (#34015633)
Novell was no fun.

I ported a C++ server and struggled with the only available C++ Compiler for Novell (Watcom). Debugging meant staring at core dumps. Novell bought SUSE too late.

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by ilyt on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:08AM (#34014120)
Marketing to decision makers is true and tested method to make inferior product popular tho
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by cduzz on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:58AM (#34014042)
For a large set of problem spaces you can replace "oracle" with "cisco" or "microsoft" or "AWS".

These companies demand a premium over "rolling your own" or "integrating a pile of better at solving a specific problem" products. In some cases the premium is well earned, in others it's just rent-seeking monopolist behavior, depending on how mature the product space is.

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by coredog64 on Friday December 16, 2022 @10:55AM (#34015971)
Nitpick: Rent-seeking is an economic term that describes an actor that provides no value for end users. It is not a synonym for someone who rents you something.

It’s confusing because it can apply to landlords who also seek to restrict supply, and people then conflate the former with the term.

Of those companies listed, maybe you can finger Oracle for their shenanigans with Java.

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by cduzz on Friday December 16, 2022 @11:38AM (#34016620)
The far end of this continuum is CA Technologies where they buy products with an entrenched customer base and squeeze them for money while putting the product on "sustaining engineering" (aka hospice care).

On the continuum of "innovative product solving hard problem" to "Rent seeing monopoly" AWS is still in the "build the mouse trap" phase while oracle's half way to CA.

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by RajT88 on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:58PM (#34017799)
> Of those companies listed, maybe you can finger Oracle for their shenanigans with Java.

Oracle licensing on the cloud can be byzantine. In part because their sales people don't seem to all have the same understanding.

https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/data-architecture-blo...

(read the comments!)

Of course, license true-ups in my experience are allowed the latitude of, "Whatever you can get them to agree to". I've heard a few times Oracle sales folks trying to pressure companies into buying licenses for all physical machine cores for the host underneath their VM's in the cloud. Which is, frankly, malarkey and not even supported by their own docs. (Apparently this is how it is licensed on-prem if you own a VMWare cluster or something, but they carve out an exemption specifically for cloud hosting in their docs - but they try anyways)

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by api on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:02AM (#34014069)
It reminds me of people who pay through the nose for cloud. They've done the spreadsheets and DIYing servers and infrastructure and hiring the people required to administrate it often comes out as more expensive. It's much worse for companies that are not tech companies with lots of in-house IT experience. They often lack the institutional expertise to even hire the right people to manage a DIY infrastructure. So it makes perfect sense to outsource to AWS and pay what seem like very high costs. You're not really buying the compute. You're buying the management.
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by ilyt on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:07AM (#34014105)
All your example are pretty much "we already have some old ancient shit that works only with Oracle", not actual features anyone might miss...

> With PG? I don't even know who to call if things are up the creek.

The core developers literally sell support...

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by acomjean on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:23AM (#34014236)
My only experience with Oracle was we were using it at a startup at the turn of the century. I got tasked with asking them for a quote. They came back with one but offered pretty strong technical support. My boss, wise in the way of databases indicated that their support would involve using there apis locking us to them as opposed to the odbc drivers that let you switch databases easily. Those odbc drivers weren’t great on Linux at the time.

The startup ran out of money a couple months later..

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by dagw on Friday December 16, 2022 @09:00AM (#34014501)
The core developers literally sell support...

One 'feature' Oracle has, that is very important to some large companies, is that they offer truly full stack support, from the hardware up to the application layer. If I buy support from some PG developers and they diagnose that the problem is actually with my RAID controller firmware or a bug in my inventory management software, will they still take responsibility for fixing it?

Edit: Another aspect is how long will it take for one of those PG core developers to show up on site? Oracle already has a team of support engineers (either first or third party) in most major cities in the world.

Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by lazyfanatic on Friday December 16, 2022 @10:16AM (#34015456)
Oracle Support has gotten absolutely terrible over the last four years. I support a full Oracle stack, and seeing all that beautiful Sun engineering turned to sludge because of poor support is really sad in many ways.
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by nnurmanov on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:41PM (#34017610)
It is true. I am building brainpick.co.uk as a Stackoverflow for enterprise. Yes, it is paid and the money goes to experts.
Re:IBM creates 24-core Power chip so customers can exploit O... by hans_castorp on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:15AM (#34014172)
> With PG? I don't even know who to call if things are up the creek.

There are plenty of companies offering commercial support contracts. Most of them are also active contributors to Postgres so they do have the ability to create bug fixes and patches.