Re:Twitter is suspending journalists who cover Elon
by olliej on Thursday December 15, 2022 @09:25PM
(#34008876)
Literally the entire argument musk made for re-allowing a bunch of people who had been banned for calling for LGBT people to be allowed or assaulted, or for more generally being nazi-supporting shitheads, was that twitter is a public square, and that he is a free speech absolutist.
So the problem people are having is that he still gets to come out in public talking about free speech, when that is objectively bullshit, or that any of the changes being made have anything to do with "free speech".
Re:Twitter is suspending journalists who cover Elon
by anigbrowl on Thursday December 15, 2022 @09:59PM
(#34009272)
Lot of people (not including you) walking around sounding like this lately: https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/just-go-on-the-internet-and-t...
Re:Twitter is suspending journalists who cover Elon
by jacooper on Thursday December 15, 2022 @10:55PM
(#34009914)
These are not lies though?
Elon said he wants free speech to the extent the law allows, yet now goes on banning spree
Re:Twitter is suspending journalists who cover Elon
by jakelazaroff on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:00AM
(#34010512)
They're saying that Elon was very obviously lying from the start, yet many people credulously believed him.
Re:Twitter is suspending journalists who cover Elon
by cmurf on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:36PM
(#34043768)
If Twitter were owned by any local, state, or the federal government, I'd agree it's a public square.
But it's owned by an corporation. And it can say one thing but do another, or even change it's mind on a whim.
Re:Twitter is suspending journalists who cover Elon
by jakelazaroff on Thursday December 15, 2022 @09:57PM
(#34009242)
> Do we need a cyberspace public square? I think we do.
Why is the web not that public square? Your website is your own personal space. No one can tell you what to do there. No one can stop you from speaking.
Re:Twitter is suspending journalists who cover Elon
by acedTrex on Friday December 16, 2022 @10:13AM
(#34015403)
Bingo, the web is already a public space. You dont need a more specific one
Re:Twitter is suspending journalists who cover Elon
by cmurf on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:31PM
(#34043699)
Twitter is not the web. Twitter's website is Musk's personal space. User's have no rights. If you disagree, point to where those rights come from.
A public square is property owned by a government. In the U.S. anyone can place themselves on public property and speak without being inhibited by the government.
That is not true in all countries, and even in the US is not true on private property.
In any case it's not currently public property, so users don't have a right to be on Twitter.
But is it a place of public accommodation? And if so, how does that bind Twitter? If someone talks enough trash that it's clear they want to start a fight, a bar can kick that person out. No question. But what if they're kicked out unfairly? What is the line the bar can't cross in kicking people out, and is that a suitable line in the sand to use for Twitter? I don't know.
Do we need a cyberspace public square? I think we do. Should it be Twitter? What would that look like? Public-private adventure?