Re:Fusion “Breakthrough” Won’t Lead to Practical Fusion Energy
by datadata on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @10:20PM
(#33994728)
They reached "scientific breakeven", you are referring to "engineering breakeven" or "economic breakeven". The vocabulary here is nicely defined: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusion_energy_gain_factor
Re:Fusion “Breakthrough” Won’t Lead to Practical Fusion Energy
by defrost on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @10:04PM
(#33994624)
Not that I like to nitpick but it's important to note that
> and got 3 MJ in return
we didn't even "get" anything .. being able to catch and use released energy is whole other non trivial box of kittens.
Re:Fusion “Breakthrough” Won’t Lead to Practical Fusion Energy
by NotYourLawyer on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @10:03PM
(#33994616)
And let’s also not forget that the 3 MJ is just heat. It still needs to spin a turbine if we want to turn some of it (maybe half? maybe less?) into electricity.
Re:Fusion “Breakthrough” Won’t Lead to Practical Fusion Energy
by ethbr0 on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @10:15PM
(#33994699)
About 35%
Re:Fusion “Breakthrough” Won’t Lead to Practical Fusion Energy
by ablatt89 on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @10:18PM
(#33994712)
I think it's the only way they can garner interest and gain more funding. Fusion energy has always "50 years away." I agree it's a bit misleading but what else can LLNL do to attract more funding? I'm really not quite sure.
Re:Fusion “Breakthrough” Won’t Lead to Practical Fusion Energy
by SantalBlush on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @10:14PM
(#33994682)
This is how scientific progress works; you can't just buy it pre-assembled from Amazon.
The reality is that charging up the lasers takes about 400 MJ, then due to very large inefficiencies you only get 2 MJ directed to the target, and they got out 3 MJ from the fusion reaction.
So we did not get more energy than we put in. We started by using 400 MJ, and got 3 MJ in return. We're not net positive energy generation.
Nothing will change in our daily lives yet. And a lot of people that have been misled by the reports are going to be very disappointed. This is a problem, because we're overhyping results and we're setting ourselves up for disappointment. And this can lead to resentment and funding getting cut.
The results are unequivocally good. But they're being portrayed as something they're not. We are yet unable to generate more energy than we put in.