News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by billiam on Monday December 12, 2022 @04:07PM (#33960288)
No, not as always. The laser confinement mechanism works, it has been shown, lasers that are more than 20 times as efficient as these NID lasers are now available, so the improvement needed to scale and "commercialize it," whatever that really means looks more like 10x than 200x. In the world of fusion, that counts as really good progress. For one thing, perhaps a lot of the research money will move to lasers now.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by toomuchtodo on Monday December 12, 2022 @04:15PM (#33960396)
I mean, you nail it on the head. It's not "congrats on limitless free energy" but more "looks we might still get value in the future if we keep pouring money into this." Positive indicators at milestones are good. Onward.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by zamalek on Monday December 12, 2022 @06:52PM (#33962233)
> looks we might still get value in the future if we keep pouring money into this.

Maybe this could also open up more avenues for money.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by naasking on Monday December 12, 2022 @04:21PM (#33960488)
> so the improvement needed to scale and "commercialize it," whatever that really means looks more like 10x than 200x. In the world of fusion, that counts as really good progress.

Yes it's good progress, but an order of magnitude is not nothing. Squeezing another order of magnitude efficiency out of the lasers will be very difficult. It took 30 years or so to go from 1% efficiency to 20%, and law of diminishing returns applies.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by janalsncm on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @01:06AM (#33965394)
Why does the law of diminishing returns apply? A lot of things aren’t diminishing returns.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by naasking on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @08:09AM (#33968338)
Literally everything has diminishing returns because nothing is infinite.

Edit: to clarify, lasers will have some maximum efficiency that is less than 100% and approaching that maximum is subject to diminishing returns.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by janalsncm on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @03:26PM (#33975233)
That is trivially true at the extremes of energy input. If you input an infinite amount of energy you will not get an infinite amount out.

But that’s not what we’re talking about. This is a physical process which is known to be exothermic for the energy ranges we care about.

As another example, raising the temperature of a flammable material 1 degree from room temperature will probably not light. Ditto with 2 degrees. But eventually, if you raise the temperature high enough, you’ll get more energy out than you put in. That’s the type of process we’re talking about now.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by nchi3 on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @10:49AM (#33970427)
Diminishing returns usually applies if you assume there are no major breakthroughs. Can we assume that there won't be any major breakthroughs in this field?
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by naasking on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @12:06PM (#33971783)
Diminishing returns describes a trend. A breakthrough describes a single data point that bucks the trend. I'm not sure these are mutually exclusive, as after any breakthrough the diminishing returns trend is reestablished.

I wouldn't bet on no breakthroughs happening in laser efficiency, but more efficient lasers doesn't look like it will be enough to get to net energy given other inefficiencies in the system.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by pclmulqdq on Monday December 12, 2022 @05:17PM (#33961217)
It's still probably about 100x, given efficiency losses all around, even on the highest-efficiency lasers.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by tsimionescu on Monday December 12, 2022 @04:40PM (#33960824)
ICF works for its purpose - research into thermo-nuclear weapons (fusion bombs).

It has nothing to do with energy generation though, and never has.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by zbobet2012 on Monday December 12, 2022 @05:10PM (#33961150)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inertial_confinement_fusion#As...

That's utterly incorrect:

"Fast ignition and similar approaches changed the situation. In this approach gains of 100 are predicted in the first experimental device, HiPER. Given a gain of about 100 and a laser efficiency of about 1%, HiPER produces about the same amount of fusion energy as electrical energy was needed to create it (and thus will require more gain to produce electricity after considering losses). It also appears that an order of magnitude improvement in laser efficiency may be possible through the use of newer designs that replace flash lamps with laser diodes that are tuned to produce most of their energy in a frequency range that is strongly absorbed. Initial experimental devices offer efficiencies of about 10%, and it is suggested that 20% is possible."

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by tsimionescu on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @12:09AM (#33965072)
This is irrelevant - each shot also requires a highly precision engineered piece of metal called a hohlraum to be destroyed.

With current technology, running an ICF plant would cost literally hundreds of millions of dollars per hour in hohlraums, since a single one costs millions, and you need to shoot several times per minute to produce energy.

That's why ICF is not even close to being a plausible electricity generation technology, so it is only being researched by nuclear weapons research labs like LLNL.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by zbobet2012 on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @08:24PM (#33978802)
hohlraums are not expensive because of base materials, but because today we generally produce them as one offs and the process is incredibly man hour intensive. The DOE "roundtable" on the announcement today addressed this.

For an actual look at the challenge of ICF i'd say look here: https://www-pub.iaea.org/MTCD/Publications/PDF/TE_1704_web.p...

and also consider that it might be used in combination with MCF for example: https://medium.com/fusion-energy-league/the-fundamental-para...

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by tsimionescu on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @12:27AM (#33980301)
They are one-offs, but even if they were to be mass-produced, they require extraordinary precision. I very much doubt claims that one can be built in the range of a few dollars that each shot is worth in terms of generated electricity.

The reports you quote actually mention the target costs very clearly. The IAEA one talks about needing 500,000 targets per day, and sets a target of 0.30$ per target. At the time it was written, it says that a target costs 1000$, which is probably before NIF found put just how much more stringent the requirements for the shape of the target were (since the numbers I saw last time NIF achieved ignition were closer to hundreds of thousands of dollars per target, though maybe I am misrembering).

It's also worth noting that that report was expecting NIF to achieve the current milestone within 3-6 years, and it actually took 13. So I feel their numbers can well be considered optimistic.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by pfdietz on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @10:43AM (#33970314)
I thought Fast Ignition had been abandoned because it was found it didn't work.

HiPER is also dead, I think.