News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by eesmith on Sunday December 11, 2022 @09:19AM (#33943404)
I think you are calculating as "twice the distance from 0 C", which is a relatively arbitrary zero point. Change the zero point and the ratios change.

The coldest measured temperature is -89.2 C, so -162 C is indeed about twice that C value.

However, in Kelvin that's 184 K for Vostok and 111 K for LNG, which is only 40% colder.

Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by _Microft on Sunday December 11, 2022 @10:13AM (#33943834)
Don't downvote that - it's correct: the Celsius scale is an "interval scale" while the Kelvin scale is a "ratio scale". One must not take ratios of Celsius values as ratios are not even defined for that.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Level_of_measurement

Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by blamazon on Sunday December 11, 2022 @11:03AM (#33944310)
So, "about" twice as much then? ;)

This whole thread is very funny this morning, I was posting at 3AM and not thinking much. I am happy to be corrected, the more I learn to know here the more I learn I don't know or can't immediately recall. I damn this fickle lump of head thinkmeat, but praise the enlightened hive mind of internet commenters!

Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by antipotoad on Monday December 12, 2022 @07:05AM (#33953786)
I can’t help but be reminded by your comment of this classic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tScAyNaRdQ
Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by Ferrotin on Monday December 12, 2022 @12:24AM (#33951193)
It is very reasonable to describe coldness as a distance from some reference temperature, such as room temperature.
Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by philliphaydon on Sunday December 11, 2022 @09:25AM (#33943465)
How many people use kelvin to quantify temperature.
Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by eesmith on Sunday December 11, 2022 @10:04AM (#33943767)
That's rather tangential to my point, which is the phrase "twice as cold" as used here is tricky to interpret.

What does "twice as cold" mean? In the US, is -2°F twice as cold as -1°F?

Yet that's only -18.33°F to -18.89°F, so only 0.3% colder if you change temperature scale.

Is 16°F twice as cold as 32°F? Or half as warm?

Is -10C infinitely colder than 0C?

I used Kelvin as an example of how the ratio depends on the scale chosen, not because it's popular.

Note that Rankin (Rankin is to Fahrenheit as Kelvin is to Celsius) would give the same answer as Kelvin - both Rankin and Kelvin are absolute scales of temperature, and would better candidates for defining what "twice as cold" means.

(Though even better would be to say "half has hot".)

However, I was not saying that we should all use Kelvin, only that the phrase is tricky to interpret.

Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by wtcactus on Sunday December 11, 2022 @09:41AM (#33943596)
I think the point is that -2C is not twice as cold as -1C, that would imply that -1C was infinitely more cold than 0C.

An analogy is the same as seen with percentages. It's wrong to say, for instance, that 2% growth, it's double of 1% growth.

Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by mercutio2 on Sunday December 11, 2022 @09:56AM (#33943696)
Everyone who cares about precision or thermodynamics?

I was about to make the same comment: the freezing point of water is a really odd choice to make up a ratio for.

If you have to do it, you’d almost always use Kelvin, or in a pinch the equilibrium temperature of a big greenhouse 1 AU from the sun, i.e. 20C.

Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by philliphaydon on Sunday December 11, 2022 @10:07AM (#33943783)
> Everyone who cares about precision or thermodynamics?

So like 3 people...

My point is talking about Kelvin is meaningless to the vast majority of people on HN, including myself. Everyone (Except the US) knows Celsius, and it's easy to gague how cold something is looking at it in Celsius. In Kelvin its just 'ok that's a number...'

Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by layer8 on Sunday December 11, 2022 @10:52AM (#33944185)
You’re underestimating the HN crowd. I’d expect everyone halfway scientifically literate to have an understanding of the Kelvin scale. It’s also quite an intuitive scale, physically, especially if you’re coming from Celsius.
Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by revertmean on Sunday December 11, 2022 @10:45AM (#33944101)
I think you're wrong. I suspect most people on HN have an above average interest in physics and would therefore have a reasonable understanding of the Kelvin temperature scale.
Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by mrep on Sunday December 11, 2022 @11:00AM (#33944276)
I learned kelvin in high school chemistry and I'm not sure why you wouldn't use kelvin when talking about liquids that far negative in celsius/fahrenheit and that close to absolute zero.
Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by philliphaydon on Sunday December 11, 2022 @11:37AM (#33944660)
Sure, I learned kelvin 20 years ago in chem too but in the last 20 years the only time I see it mentioned is literally on HN. Or GamersNexus.
Re:The five-year engineering feat Germany pulled off in months by Denvercoder9 on Sunday December 11, 2022 @10:51AM (#33944174)
> So like 3 people...

Just about everything human-built around you had someone consider the thermodynamics of it during the design.