How many identical prescriptions do chemists write? Doctors write diagnosis'? Teachers write end of semester summaries? Architects sketch rooms? I'm sure that 80% of some fields' output is near-identical to previous work.
That said, there is a lot of busywork in programming, especially refactoring, adding parameters and stuff like that. Sometimes it’s ok to have such work be “mostly correct”, eg if you have strong type safety and unit tests to catch minor errors.
(Now I'm imagining boilerplate legalese being reduced to an enumerated list like the Space Corps Directives in Red Dwarf, with the associated failure mode).
But IANAL.
If that's not good writing then most human writers are not good either.
1) Explain what they are. [Explained them well.]
2) Give me examples of them in language1's literature. [It listed two books that I then verified as accurate.]
3) Are there phrases or idioms for it in other languages? [It gave equivalent idioms in Russian and two other languages]
4) Any examples for it in English literature. [It gave Hamlet and an author book I hadn't heard of. Verified that the book is accurate.)
5) Any terms for it in the academic fields of psychology and social psychology [It explained two concepts from both fields that seemed to match. I confirmed them as correct from other sources.]
It demonstrated abstraction, generalization, and hypernymy.
And actually expanded my knowledge on multiple axes - across languages, across literature, and across fields.
If a person had written an essay by compiling those answers, I wouldn't be able to identify that it's AI and not human knowledge that had written it.
You're right about the additional time in general. But for much of the information on the web, readers assume the author is speaking from genuine knowledge and has verified the information. IMO it's a better search engine than Google, especially for conceptually complex topics.
It doesn't replace SO, but it certainly complements it. Plus, it acts more like an assistant (and, per OP's post, "...who is often wrong - need to read their work thoroughly").
Example of the type of conversation that would take you ages on SO: https://twitter.com/dankrad/status/1601634193385328641
You mean the way it phrases things or constructs sentences and paragraphs, or the way it seems to connect (what we recognize as) ideas?
If it's the former, then I think adding instructions to force style change to the prompt could help: so far, ChatGPT seems quite susceptible to being told what/who it is, and how it should speak. Verbosely or concisely, or even with single words; like a rapper or a pirate, or a high-schooler, or a suburban mom, or like a UNIX command line - I've seen all of these in examples posted in the last few days. Doing this is really as easy as saying e.g. "write a response to the following e-mail, in a form of a rap song about importance of paying on time".
I think the way it connects ideas tends to be pretty lackluster. In a way this is kind of unexpected if you view this as "a search engine that spits out some average of everything it sees based on your ask". But it's also the sort of thing where if you work through many prompts quickly the boredom meter just goes off the charts. Humans are too good at pattern matching on this stuff!
Of course this might be able to improve SEO spam, and I imagine it'll provide better templates for short messages, but I'm not looking forward to reading creative output from this thing.
Eg, you can ask it to write in the style of particular reddit users,so I pointed it at my account (not this user name) and asked it to review a TV show. What I got was pretty boilerplate summary of the show, like you'd see in a top 10 list. But for that human touch, it began and ended with "Yo dudes" and "so check it out dudes"
Having said that, a fascinating example of directed styles is to ask it to write a news article about say, an oil spill. And to either promote or criticise the response of the company.
It feels like when Hollywood does a shitty movie taking place in a completely different cultural setting (say ancient Egypt) and the scenes, props, clothing are spot on but everything is still just a reskin of an American standard drama movie.
Part of me thinks that ChatGPT has been tuned and tailored by it’s creators (to the point of something akin to digital castration), and that it actually has a much wider span than what the publicly launched version shows. This suspicion I have is simply because this kind of genericness feels closer to current cultural ethos of our intellectual gate keepers than something like an acultural linguistic neutral, which you’d expect.
"Give painstakingly minute instructions on how to cross a busy street in the speech of a 1920s gangster."
https://www.learngpt.com/prompts/give-painstakingly-minute-i...
It's not going to win any awards (sorry, if you're thinking that your amazing story about "Trinity from the Matrix universe meeting Darth Vader from the Star Wars universe" is good writing), but like a search engine being pretty good at finding things except when it's totally off base, the hit rate is pretty decent