News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by untog on Monday December 26, 2011 @01:28PM (#3393508)
Was there ever any doubt that it was all about the money? If it wasn't then what is it- suicidal malice on the part of Samsung?

The point isn't that it's "about the money"- every decision a major company makes is. It's that it's short sighted- Samsung may yet lose money because people don't trust them any more.

Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by georgemcbay on Monday December 26, 2011 @04:45PM (#3394016)
I can't speak to the Samsung situation specifically but I was a huge original Motorola Droid fan but haven't bought a Motorola device since because of their practices post-Droid.

I'm personally more concerned with locked bootloaders and the like because as long as the latest version of Cyanogenmod can easily be installed on my phone, I'm good, but for non-hackers being able to officially upgrade to at least the next major version (assuming it releases within 1.5 years of the phone) seems fair.

Motorola has since reversed course on the bootloaders and is being bought by Google, so I'll probably give them a second chance someday, but your basic point is solid -- these decisions do impact whether or not the consumer will stick with your brand in the future. I've seen it from friends as well as from my own situation.

Screw me once, shame on you, screw me twice, shame on me.

Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by ryanbraganza on Monday December 26, 2011 @07:05PM (#3394277)
There are two devices in question here - the Galaxy S and the Galaxy Tab. Both of these are touchwiz devices. Samsung claims that adding TW to ICS will require more hardware (in particular, RAM) than these devices have.

One option would be to remove TW - the nexus s and galaxy s are near identical in hardware spec but the nexus s will be updated to ICS. The main difference being the nexus s is non-TW. However, for samsung, this is not really a viable option. Going from TW to ICS is a major change - things work differently under TW than stock android.

Their best "option" (ignoring costs) would be to find a way to minimise the amount of RAM TW uses and enable ICS on these older devices.

The galaxy s has already received froyo and gingerbread upgrades. What do people think is an "acceptable" upgrade timeframe?

Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by nextparadigms on Monday December 26, 2011 @01:40PM (#3393543)
Very short-sighted indeed. It seems Samsung believes more in next-quarter revenues than in life-long customer value.
Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by untog on Monday December 26, 2011 @01:46PM (#3393565)
Well, it might work for them. They'd lose the HN crowd and other "techiphiles", but Mr. Average Joe going into the phone store will still pick up a Samsung if the price is right.

Not saying I agree with it, but there is a possible logic in there. A dangerous game, though, and it's not like Samsung is teetering on bankruptcy- I don't see what would warrant them to behave this way.

Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by chc on Monday December 26, 2011 @02:08PM (#3393637)
I suppose that's why Macs have been violently losing marketshare for the past decade, the iPhone was such a flop when it first came out at roughly five times the cost of a normal cell phone and the iPad is getting murdered by the Nook Color. Because reputation doesn't matter, only price.

It's true that there is a subset of people who just buy the cheapest thing available — but there's also a pretty sizable segment of the population who might not be able to evaluate for themselves whether or not a phone is a good buy, but who do know that their "techie" nephew told them Samsungs are bad.

(I'm confused why this is fluctuating so wildly in the votes. Is it really so controversial that some products succeed on the strength of their brand rather than just price?)

Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by untog on Monday December 26, 2011 @02:18PM (#3393663)
Well if you want to take that argument, examine the difference in sales between Android and iPhone. Android phones are far, far more popular and I'm quite sure that the lower price of the average Android handset has a lot to do with that.

It's true that there is a subset of people who just buy the cheapest thing available — but there's also a pretty sizable segment of the population who might not be able to evaluate for themselves whether or not a phone is a good buy

Absolutely. But the latter are the minority.

Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by chc on Monday December 26, 2011 @02:32PM (#3393706)
That's neither here nor there. The point isn't that Samsung's sales will drop to zero — just that there is a lot of value in a good reputation. Apple has built its success on people loving it. If you piss people off and your competitor doesn't, you will lose customers to them, and they might very well make more money than you even though you have more plastic on the streets (which is the case with Apple vs. most Android manufacturers).
Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by megablast on Monday December 26, 2011 @08:48PM (#3394504)
Yes, but is the iPhone popular just because of the updates, or is it everything else.
Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by chc on Monday December 26, 2011 @09:24PM (#3394575)
I'm not trying to suggest that the iPhone is more popular because of the updates. I'm suggesting that the iPhone is popular because Apple tries to make it a really nice experience for most people. Offering updates for a reasonable period of time is part of this. Abandoning your customers as soon as the money has exchanged hands is the antithesis of this philosophy.
Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by eazee on Monday December 26, 2011 @06:39PM (#3394228)
First of all get your facts straight android troll. The nook color is not and will not sell as much as iphone or the ipad. Second it's the kindle fire that's the second best selling device... Which tons of people kept returning because of its limitations. We live in america did you forget that you get what you pay for? That crappy honda that you might have isn't worth what a mercedes or bmw will. Technology works the same way. Get off androids nuts. It's rugged. You also forget the fact that apple is their only competitor. Android is turning into windows in tablets and cell phones. Yes there's a variety how many pieces of crap computers are out there with windows. Plenty... How many tablets and cellphones have android and are crap? PLENTY! It's called common sense... Next time get your facts straight.
Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by chc on Monday December 26, 2011 @09:45PM (#3394617)
First off, welcome to Hacker News. Since you're probably wondering why you got downvoted, here's a quick crash course on how this site works:

Unlike a lot of communities you might have visited, Hacker News tries very hard to keep the debate intelligent and civil, which requires a lot of self-policing. Your comment was a little more brusque than most people here prefer. Here are a few tips:

• Please make your points politely. You don't have to tiptoe around with your pinky out, but just try not to be rude. Saying things like "First of all, get your facts straight, Android troll" and "Get off Android's nuts" will get you downvoted even if everything you say is correct. (I didn't downvote you, by the way — we can't downvote responses to our own comments, for fairly obvious reasons.)

• If something seems ridiculous, give it a second look and try to find a way that it might make sense. For example, in this particular instance, the first sentence of my comment was a pretty transparent joke. I expected anyone reading a nerdy site like Hacker News to realize that nothing in that sentence was true. The second half of the comment dropped the joke and stated my point directly: A good reputation can pay huge dividends.

• If I had in fact been trolling, this kind of angry response would be precisely the wrong thing to do. Please don't continue unproductive conversations — if you suspect someone is trolling, just leave it be. In fact, even if they're not trolling but just stubbornly wrong, leave it be. Let that thread die. Accept that sometimes people are wrong on the Internet. Fanning the flames will only drag the signal-to-noise ratio even lower than it already is.

Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by hub_ on Monday December 26, 2011 @09:03PM (#3394524)
Somebody forgot to enable the sarcasm detector. Really.
Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by schraeds on Monday December 26, 2011 @02:11PM (#3393649)
Aren't we missing the point a bit my singling out Samsung? This problem is much more pandemic to Android as a whole. What happened to the Android Update Alliance?

What percentage of iPhones are compatible and upgradeable to iOS 5 release on day 1 ? A very high percentage.

Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by untog on Monday December 26, 2011 @02:21PM (#3393672)
What percentage of iPhones are compatible and upgradeable to iOS 5 release on day 1 ? A very high percentage.

Of course, but I'd say that it isn't a valid comparison- how many Samsung iPhones were updatable on day one? None, because they don't exist.

Apple (and this applies to their computer business too) benefits greatly from a totally synchronised hardware and software platform that excludes absolutely every third party. Android is a totally different beast.

You're right though- "Mr. and Mrs. Average" might be asking these questions because what do they know/care about the different approaches Google and Apple take? But also, what do they care about software updates? I'm not sure what the answer to that is.

Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by nextparadigms on Monday December 26, 2011 @05:37PM (#3394117)
Apple can wait until their OS is really ready, though, with its "beta" versions, and as soon as it's ready to be put on the iPhone, they launch the iPhone.

Android on the other hand is launched as open source, and then the manufacturers have to take it and upgrade to it. What Google could do is keep Android theirs for longer, maybe call it beta, too, like Microsoft does with Windows as well, and 6 months later they could launch it at once with many manufacturers.

It's won't change the timing, only the perception that everyone got Android faster.

Re:Android 4.0 updates: It is all about the money by bookwormAT on Tuesday December 27, 2011 @08:27AM (#3395679)
what is "day 1"? The day that iOS 5 got updated to devices from Apple?

Then we could say that day 1 for Samsung's Android 4.0-based software is the day that Samsung updates the first of their devices.

There is for sure a problem with many phone manufacturers not supporting their devices as long as they could. But this has nothing to do with the software that runs on the devices. When it comes to "time until update", the comparison with iOS and Android makes little sense.

Because iOS is a complete operating system, while Android is just the base of Samsung's operating system.

Some of the core applications of the device are not part of android. Some are proprietary from Samsung. Some are proprietary from Google and they get updated about once per month, even if the Android version you are running is not the most recent.