More importantly, with OSM you can do whatever YOU want with the actual underlying data. A great example are these beautiful maps: http://mike.teczno.com/notes/osm-us-terrain-layer/foreground...
This url you have put is actually much better than Google maps somehow. It's way smoother and faster. Pretty cool!
It seems the site is down, but here's archive.org's cache:
http://web.archive.org/web/20110208212952/http://www.41latit...
http://web.archive.org/web/20101223050944/http://www.41latit...
And it's also mentioned repeatedly that they were perfectly willing to continue with Google Maps until they had a bad sales experience and were estimated a figure that they couldn't pay.
When you say that and you put the charging issue third, it makes everything else look like a rationalization.
ETA: And as I go to OpenStreetMaps and see it struggle to serve me a page showing my house (and showing exactly the same wrong place for my house that Google Maps does, because it's using the exact same data), it doesn't much make a case for anything but "well, at least it's free".
OSM is very, very good in some areas and not so good in others (especially in the US).
I think the key factor here is something Google does very, very well: UI. There is just something about google maps that makes it more appealing to the eye. And that's crucial to create a great service. I saw a post long ago (i couldn't find :/) that compared the graphic style of Maps, Bing and others. Google just nails layout, ease of understanding and other factors. I believe it is this key factor that makes the difference.