News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why (and how) we've switched away from Google Maps by mmwako on Monday December 26, 2011 @10:04AM (#3393031)
I read the post and it's mentioned many times that OSM is as good as Google Maps. Others argue "its just about the money". Why would someone want to pay for a service that you have to pay for and its just as good as the alternatives?

I think the key factor here is something Google does very, very well: UI. There is just something about google maps that makes it more appealing to the eye. And that's crucial to create a great service. I saw a post long ago (i couldn't find :/) that compared the graphic style of Maps, Bing and others. Google just nails layout, ease of understanding and other factors. I believe it is this key factor that makes the difference.

Re:Why (and how) we've switched away from Google Maps by freyfogle on Monday December 26, 2011 @10:09AM (#3393039)
Agree, Google does very well with their UI. But so do others. Check out Leaflet for example http://leaflet.cloudmade.com/

More importantly, with OSM you can do whatever YOU want with the actual underlying data. A great example are these beautiful maps: http://mike.teczno.com/notes/osm-us-terrain-layer/foreground...

Re:Why (and how) we've switched away from Google Maps by zobzu on Tuesday December 27, 2011 @01:02AM (#3394973)
http://leaflet.cloudmade.com/

This url you have put is actually much better than Google maps somehow. It's way smoother and faster. Pretty cool!

Re:Why (and how) we've switched away from Google Maps by rsoto on Monday December 26, 2011 @12:06PM (#3393286)
>I saw a post long ago (i couldn't find :/)

It seems the site is down, but here's archive.org's cache:

http://web.archive.org/web/20110208212952/http://www.41latit...

http://web.archive.org/web/20101223050944/http://www.41latit...

Re:Why (and how) we've switched away from Google Maps by Semiapies on Monday December 26, 2011 @03:41PM (#3393885)
"I read the post and it's mentioned many times that OSM is as good as Google Maps."

And it's also mentioned repeatedly that they were perfectly willing to continue with Google Maps until they had a bad sales experience and were estimated a figure that they couldn't pay.

When you say that and you put the charging issue third, it makes everything else look like a rationalization.

ETA: And as I go to OpenStreetMaps and see it struggle to serve me a page showing my house (and showing exactly the same wrong place for my house that Google Maps does, because it's using the exact same data), it doesn't much make a case for anything but "well, at least it's free".

Re:Why (and how) we've switched away from Google Maps by yellowbkpk on Monday December 26, 2011 @07:50PM (#3394370)
What do you mean "struggle"? The page loads slowly? It's showing data but it's wrong? Google Maps and OSM don't use the exact same data. What's wrong with OSM? How can I help you fix it?

OSM is very, very good in some areas and not so good in others (especially in the US).

Re:Why (and how) we've switched away from Google Maps by Semiapies on Tuesday December 27, 2011 @12:49AM (#3394951)
Yes, it loaded glacially when I tried it, and there was a link begging me to donate for a hardware upgrade. It showed precisely the same wrong location, given a search address, that Google Maps shows - which is pretty impressive if they're somehow not using the same data, there. As for fixing it, fix it yourself. I'm not a cartographer, and I'm not actually interested in this project or in being hectored by someone to pitch in on a project I don't give a damn about.
Re:Why (and how) we've switched away from Google Maps by yellowbkpk on Tuesday December 27, 2011 @07:57AM (#3395626)
Can you give an example of the exactly matching wrong data? I'd love to fix it myself but can only fix it if I know where the problem is.
Re:Why (and how) we've switched away from Google Maps by Semiapies on Tuesday December 27, 2011 @05:02PM (#3397621)
I'm sorry, but the search address is my home address, and I'm not going to give that out to you.
Re:Why (and how) we've switched away from Google Maps by RussNelson on Tuesday December 27, 2011 @01:27PM (#3396721)
Well, how about FIXING it in OSM?
Re:Why (and how) we've switched away from Google Maps by Semiapies on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @12:55AM (#3398806)
How about no? It's not my job, it's not a project I care about, it's not even something I use.
Re:Why (and how) we've switched away from Google Maps by wensing on Monday December 26, 2011 @03:19PM (#3393832)
Definitely agree. This is why we (Stormpulse) not only avoided Google Maps but spent 1,000's of hours designing the UI. I would avoid mapstraction for the same reason: we see mapping as a core competency of our business. YMMV of course.