News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to write like Malcolm Gladwell by tptacek on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:27PM (#33926077)
No, it's not.

The subtext here is the text of this (very excellent) blog post:

https://jsomers.net/blog/it-turns-out

We all get it. Gladwell trades in "it turns out than" constructions as much as anybody else. But so do lots of mediocre writers. Gladwell is fun to read. People don't read him simply to scratch their chin and say "yeah, that's right, that's how the world works, I should uPdAtE mY pRiOrS", the way they do with other it-turns-out-ists. They read him because he knows how to bait a hook and cast a line, and if you make the mistake of nibbling at a Gladwell paragraph you're apt to get snagged. That's a skill, and it's as superficial and vapid as a Gladwell argument to pretend otherwise.

Re:How to write like Malcolm Gladwell by dragonwriter on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:58PM (#33926902)
You seem to be confusing the claim hackery is integral to and inseperable from Gladwell's effectiveness rather than orthogonal to it for a claim that hackery is sufficient for his effectiveness.

Those are... not the same.

Re:How to write like Malcolm Gladwell by tptacek on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:08PM (#33927027)
That's also not true! Gladwell has written some pieces for The New Yorker that actually hold up pretty well. Go read his ketchup piece.

It's just not the case that Gladwell is only effective when he's teflon-coating vapid, big-sounding ideas to shoot into his readers brains.

Re:How to write like Malcolm Gladwell by yamtaddle on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:29PM (#33927251)
I think the hackery's necessary in that it's necessary in order for him to have completed his books with as little effort as he did. Writing as well without the hackery would require coming up with better theses (which would mean jettisoning weak ones when you realize they're weak, and starting over, rather than plowing ahead regardless—this could be a long process) and a lot more time finding and evaluating evidence.

Good writing ability (for certain definitions of "good") plus hackery are necessary if you want to make the economics of your writing work as well as he has, writing airport nonfiction books. Writing non-hacky nonfiction is takes a lot more time and (perhaps) more talent.

Re:How to write like Malcolm Gladwell by tptacek on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:57PM (#33927552)
Again: I can give you examples of Gladwell articles that aren't based on hackery, which seems to more or less refute this argument.

(The books don't hold up, but some of his New Yorker stuff does.)