Again: I can give you examples of Gladwell articles that aren't based on hackery, which seems to more or less refute this argument.
(The books don't hold up, but some of his New Yorker stuff does.)
(The books don't hold up, but some of his New Yorker stuff does.)
Good writing ability (for certain definitions of "good") plus hackery are necessary if you want to make the economics of your writing work as well as he has, writing airport nonfiction books. Writing non-hacky nonfiction is takes a lot more time and (perhaps) more talent.