News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by vforvendettador on Thursday December 08, 2022 @07:22PM (#33915795)
It's tragic if it's true about the drone. It's my worst nightmare whenever I'm flying these days.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by caconym_ on Thursday December 08, 2022 @11:38PM (#33917507)
> It's my worst nightmare whenever I'm flying these days.

We've all got our irrational fears, but whether you're flying in a jumbo jet or a single-prop bug-smasher this one is very irrational indeed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_unmanned_aerial_vehicl...

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by PragmaticPulp on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:26PM (#33917056)
> It's my worst nightmare whenever I'm flying these days.

Maybe if someone is deliberately flying near an airport and moves into the exact right position at the right time without first being spotted

But in practice, mainstream drones are GPS locked to not fly anywhere near airports and it's not really realistic to just accidentally get a drone too close to an airplane anywhere else. Also, the sky is a massive place and drones have limited flight time. I think the drone-airplane collision fears are greatly exaggerated outside of unique low-altitude specialty flying like airshows.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by leetrout on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:01PM (#33916052)
I am not sure which craft you are talking about flying.

Hitting a drone is your worst nightmare while piloting small aircraft?

Or hitting a plane is your worst nightmare when flying a drone?

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by Alupis on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:35PM (#33916280)
> Hitting a drone is your worst nightmare while piloting small aircraft

A small GA aircraft hitting a drone has a very high fatality chance, particularly in the stages of flight most likely to encounter amateur drone operators (ie. takeoff and landing).

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:07PM (#33916497)
A swan can weigh 8 kilos, a goose can weigh 6, and DJi phantom weighs 1.2 kilos.

Multiple planes crashed with fatalities vecause of birds, as far as I am aware none have done so because of a drone.

The fear of drones had led to pilots reporting drone sightings at 10,000 feet in the middle of the Ocean, thousands of miles from shore.

"Several commenters noted that the AMA analyzed those reported ‘incidents’ and found that out of the 764 reported records, only 27 (or 3.5%) were identified as a near mid-air collision, with nearly all of those involving government-authorized military drones"

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by CSSer on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:40PM (#33916728)
It’s also kind of insulting to those of us who go out of our way to safely fly drones recreationally. More and more drones you purchase today have built-in GPS transponders. I’m notified when airplanes are nearby even at altitudes I can’t reach, and I can tell you what kind of air space I’m in easily. I’m registered with the FAA as required, and I’ve taken more safety courses than I need, mostly because I wouldn’t mind getting my part 107.

I tell everyone these things are not for kids, especially the $1K+ drones capable of high altitudes and speeds. If you go online and find a video of someone doing something stupid, you’ll find an army of enthusiasts telling them so in the comments because they want to preserve the hobby.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by krisoft on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:13AM (#33920078)
> GPS transponders

I assume you mean ADS-B in? Is the receiver in the drone itself or in the ground station/transmitter?

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by jaywalk on Friday December 09, 2022 @09:21AM (#33921447)
Drones (generally) don't use ADS-B in or out.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by krisoft on Friday December 09, 2022 @11:17AM (#33922990)
Okay, then what is a “GPS transponder”?
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by jaywalk on Friday December 09, 2022 @01:21PM (#33924643)
I'm guessing the comment was referring to the drone having a GPS receiver and relaying it's position to the base station.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by Alupis on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:38PM (#33916712)
What's the point you're trying to make? Just because we don't yet have a confirmed kill from a DJI Phantom means it's impossible?

We do have confirmed strikes from drones, and the damage has been devastating. We do have confirmed strikes with fatalities from birds. There is not much difference between a bird and a drone when an aircraft strikes it at speed...

These drones are often operated by folks with zero training and zero deference for the law or aviation safety (highlighted by the fact they're operating near an airport). It's just a matter of time... if it hasn't already happened right here in this Dallas incident.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:54PM (#33916840)
> What's the point you're trying to make? Just because we don't yet have a confirmed kill from a DJI Phantom means it's impossible?

Anything is possible, there is a guy that was killed by his beard, shot by a dog and every year several people die from being tangled on bedsheets. Lets keep things in proportion.

I, for one, am unclear why we immediately jumped to regulating drones, but when Tespa autopilot kills people, nobody seems to care?

The real point is that people in this thread are too quick to blame drones, when geese outnumbet them 1000 to one. I live near an airport and a huge flock of geese is constantly here. When I see people with real drones, they tend to know whay they are doing.

The only people I see fooling around are people who buy a tiny drone for $50 on Amazon and the worst those drones can do is get aruck in your hair while filming nudes.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by Alupis on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:59PM (#33916866)
Well, I don't disagree on any of these points.

But these points don't mean it's any less fatal to hit a drone in a small plane than a goose.

Hitting things in aircraft isn't a recipe for a good time... ever.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by mlyle on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:01PM (#33916880)
> We do have confirmed strikes with fatalities from birds.

Yup.

> There is not much difference between a bird and a drone when an aircraft strikes it at speed...

Open to debate.

Even if true: There's a whole lot more birds near airports than illegally operating drones. So even if there's some tiny, absolute risk, the relative risk appears low.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by Alupis on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:12PM (#33916956)
There is no debate.

The claim was, hitting a drone has a high chance of being fatal - the same high chance hitting a bird has... particularly in vulnerable stages of flight. Nothing you, or anyone else has offered counters this claim, because it's just reality. Hitting things in aircraft is never a good thing, and is always a significant cause for concern.

We've been lucky so far more idiots haven't flown drones closer to airshows or airports. There are plenty, and there have been collisions with devastating damage but luckily no fatalities (perhaps yet). There are plenty of pictures on the internet if you want to compare damages to bird strikes.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by mlyle on Thursday December 08, 2022 @11:09PM (#33917322)
> the same high chance hitting a bird has.

It's unclear whether it's the same chance hitting a bird has. You assert it is.

As to a high chance of fatality from bird strike: no. There's >10k bird strikes per year in the US and most years there isn't a single bird strike related fatal accident. Estimates of death are on the order of 1 death related to bird strike per billion flight hours.

Even if drones are the same risk per collision, drones are much rarer near runways than birds.

There's no such thing in the world as zero risk, but if drones are a small fraction of a risk that's less than 1 death per billion flight hours, I'd say that we have bigger fish to fry.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by rootusrootus on Thursday December 08, 2022 @11:03PM (#33917280)
> There is no debate.

Sure there is. On average there are about 13000 bird strikes a year. What fraction of those result in a fatality? The FAA says a bit under 400 pilots die every year, however since 1990 there have been just 292 fatalities globally that can be attributed to wildlife strikes (and not all are birds).

That is a pretty clear repudiation of any claim that hitting a drone has a "high chance of being fatal."

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by jandrese on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:07PM (#33916504)
This seems surprising. Most drones weigh no more than a medium sized bird and are made out of flimsy materials that shatter readily. Sure there might be a bit of fire from the destruction of the battery pack, but nothing that should be a major problem for a GA aircraft. Unless by drone you are talking about a Global Hawk? I would count that as a high fatality risk.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by heliodor on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:57AM (#33921253)
> very high fatality chance

Really? Very high? My uneducated guess is that there's a very high chance of damage to the airplane, but not of crash landing, and certainly not of death.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by thrill on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:02PM (#33916460)
No, it likely wouldn't have a large effect on the GA aircraft.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by bobkazamakis on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:05PM (#33916490)
? Either you don't know what GA aircraft entails, or you've got a real misconception of the size of a drone compared to a bird.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by thrill on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:20PM (#33916577)
Well, I've hit birds with wingspans around a dozen feet (didn't go measure). They make a mess, and have killed people I knew, but that was mostly because of their size and the penetration of the windscreen. Hitting a smaller object could certainly cause some damage but it wouldn't likely be immediate and catastrophic unless it was in a critical spot.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by Alupis on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:35PM (#33916692)
> unless it was in a critical spot

Which is where most strikes occur. Low speed (relative for an aircraft) and low altitude.

A bird hitting the prop, sucked into an engine, tail strike, windscreen, etc... all can be devastating for any aircraft, be it GA or commercial.

A drone strike isn't somehow going to be better for the aircraft...

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by thrill on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:22PM (#33917026)
Well, sure you don't want to hit anything unless you want to hit it, but doing so is unlikely to be the mushroom cloud event that seems to be believed occurs when hitting a drone.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by SamBam on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:44PM (#33916764)
> birds with wingspans around a dozen feet

Albatross or pelican?

I think 12.1 feet is the world record.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by thrill on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:21PM (#33917009)
Spanish condors - they look bigger when they suddenly appear in your way.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by salamandars on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:13PM (#33916539)
Can you source this? I can't find any information on fatalities due to aircraft-drone collisions, topic of this article notwithstanding.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by caconym_ on Thursday December 08, 2022 @11:33PM (#33917480)
> I can't find any information on fatalities due to aircraft-drone collisions, topic of this article notwithstanding.

That's because there have not been any: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_unmanned_aerial_vehicl...

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by Alupis on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:41PM (#33916734)
You don't need a source. An object striking an aircraft in flight is devastating, and can be very fatal. Just because the object was made in China vs. hatched out of an egg doesn't really matter... the results will be the same.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by salamandars on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:07PM (#33916923)
Well, according to wikipedia, only between 11-15% of bird strikes result in damage to the aircraft. Apparently large birds like geese are the main danger.

I imagine a similar distribution with drone strikes, as most drones do not weigh as much as a goose, at least of those in the hands of a typical idiot (who would fly in the path of a plane).

That's why 'very high fatality chance' doesn't seem right to me, but I can't find any statistics on it.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by NovemberWhiskey on Friday December 09, 2022 @09:38AM (#33921614)
There's never been a verified fatality or even injury caused by a midair collision between a drone and a manned aircraft, as far as I know.

You're way to more likely to be killed by a midair in the pattern at an uncontrolled field than anything drone related.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by aaron695 on Thursday December 08, 2022 @07:54PM (#33916019)
It doesn't look like a drone.

Although possible, war planes should not be as affected by strikes.

Why do you think it's a drone?

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by Alupis on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:26PM (#33916209)
> war planes should not be as affected by strikes.

There is nothing special about a war plane that makes it less affected by strikes of any kind, be from birds or drones alike.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by someweirdperson on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:38PM (#33916300)
A bullet-proof windshield protects the most vulnerable part (the pilot) a lot better than any civilian plane can.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by Alupis on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:41PM (#33916322)
Most (practically all) aircraft do not have bullet-proof windshields (including military), for starters, and secondly a several pound meat ball travelling at closing speeds anywhere between 60kts (GA) to 200+ kts (jets/airliners/mil) is going to do a number on the aircraft regardless if it incapacitated the pilot.

Doubly-so if it's a several pound metal ball...

You don't want to hit anything in an aircraft, ever.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by sio8ohPi on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:09PM (#33916515)
Bulletproof windshields were very common during this period, although 43-11719 doesn't appear to have been fitted with one, likely because the F variant never advanced beyond the prototype stage.

https://warbirdsnews.com/warbird-restorations/caf-bell-p-63f...

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by Alupis on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:51PM (#33916824)
I may have missed it, but I don't see anywhere in that linked article that mentions bullet proof windscreens... and Wikipedia for the aircraft also makes no mention. Plus, we're not just talking about this particular aircraft in this incident, but generally all aircraft.

But, I would not be surprised it was tried, particularly with WWII era machines. There's very little actual benefit to having one on any aircraft, even CAS aircraft. A modernly restored version meant for airshows and racing probably would have replaced it for something more modern and lighter weight.

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by sio8ohPi on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:10PM (#33916939)
Look at the 12th photo in the gallery, which shows the cockpit from the right-hand door. No armored windscreen.

There's no particular reason for wikipedia to mention it because it was a very common feature in this era. It would be like mentioning that it had self-sealing fuel tanks. It was also a feature that could be present or not between different models, and could even be retrofitted to a plane once it was in service.

Regarding the wreck-finder below: he likely does know exactly what it was because he likely started by looking up the crash report (and based on his claimed date, it's probably s/n, 44-2031)

This is exactly what a typical armored windscreen looked like in this era (e.g. https://ww2aircraft.net/forum/threads/armored-windscreen-for...)

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by someweirdperson on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:07PM (#33916501)
> Most (practically all) aircraft do not have bullet-proof windshields (including military)

The P-63 did (example picture [0]), like many others that were designed to attack bombers and/or ground targets.

[0] https://www.flickr.com/photos/23057174@N02/3031666813

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by Alupis on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:54PM (#33916842)
The person in the picture is speculating it's a bullet proof windshield, and he's mistaken (particularly from the P-39 aircraft mentioned in the link). If you look at both a P-63 and P-39 you will not find any windshield or window that is even remotely shaped like what is held in the image.

Regardless, modernly speaking, very few (if any) aircraft have bullet proof windshields. They are impractical for a number of reasons, including weight, size, thickness (distortion of picture), and efficacy. If a pilot is within small-arms distance they generally are already in trouble...

Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by kQq9oHeAz6wLLS on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:49PM (#33916374)
Actually, I'd say the most vulnerable part for a strike in a single engine craft is the engine, which sits ahead of the cabin. At low altitudes there's precious little time to correct for any sort of engine failure.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by sio8ohPi on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:07PM (#33916500)
The P-63 has the engine behind the pilot.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by someweirdperson on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:00PM (#33916445)
There's zero time to fix a dead pilot in a plane with only one seat.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by maxbond on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:25PM (#33916197)
It looks like a small black spec a few hundred feet off the ground to me. Drone seems pretty likely. Perhaps it's junk that fell off another aircraft, it could be a satellite falling to Earth for all I know, but drone seems like the first hypothesis to rule out. Or that the footage is inauthentic I suppose.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by maxbond on Saturday December 10, 2022 @01:06PM (#33934958)
(My current understanding is now that the footage being inauthentic or misunderstood is the most likely.)
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by leetrout on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:02PM (#33916060)
Vouched for your comment. It looks like you are shadowbanned. You might want to send an email to HN.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by maxbond on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:44PM (#33916339)
Looking through their comments, it's pretty clear they know they're banned, why they're banned, spoke with dang about it at the time, and embraced being banned (I think because they feel it filters out low effort replies? Their statement was on the matter was terse, but semiparphrasing they said "I'm aiming for a shadowban" because "replies are the worst").
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by leetrout on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:46PM (#33916358)
Oh OK, I didnt look in detail.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by chrisbaker98 on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:40PM (#33916313)
How can you tell that someone is shadowbanned?
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by leetrout on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:41PM (#33916321)
All their comments are dead
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by chrisbaker98 on Friday December 09, 2022 @03:56PM (#33926386)
I don't get it. How do you know that GP is shadowbanned? The post looks just like a normal post to me; I'm not even sure what it means for it to be dead.
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by fsckboy on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:26PM (#33916626)
if part of the way the shadowban works is that the banee isn't alerted, why are you alerting them which works against "the system"?
Re:Dallas midair tragedy: New videos show startling change i... by adwn on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:18AM (#33918572)
Because "the system" might have made a mistake. And even if the shadowban was warranted at some time, the poster might have improved their conduct in the meantime and should be given another chance.

Usually, when I see a reasonable but dead comment, I vouch for it. If the commenter is shadowbanned and their other most recent comments are also reasonable and civil, I (sometimes) alert them to their status.