News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mastodon Instance with 6 Files by vidarh on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:31PM (#33883830)
The actual technical reason is that it prevents us from implementing it with static files.
Re:Mastodon Instance with 6 Files by stonogo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:36PM (#33883936)
I'm not sure that's true. You can map these URIs, params and all, to static files behind the httpd. Nothing is forcing anyone into running a dynamic application. Even if you don't want to map characters, all the param characters are valid in unix filenames.

Anyway here's someone doing webfinger with a static file, in a way that works for serving for multiple users: https://gist.github.com/aaronpk/5846789

Re:Mastodon Instance with 6 Files by JustinGarrison on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:47PM (#33884124)
That’s really cool! Thanks for sharing, but doesn’t a rewrite rule still require an active web server component and not static file listing?

I’m not sure if you could implement something similar with s3

Re:Mastodon Instance with 6 Files by cxr on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:56PM (#33884263)
> You can map these URIs, params and all, to static files behind the httpd. Nothing is forcing anyone into running a dynamic application.

Sorry, but this is a form of equivocation[1] at best. More honestly, it's a simple contradiction; at the point where you're "map[ping] these URIs, params and all, to static files", then you are already being forced into running a dynamic application.

Although not well-defined, a "static" site is widely understood to be the sort of thing you get with e.g. Neocities or GitHub Pages or one of its myriad clones—where you cannot rely on being able to mess with the server configuration (past the point of, like, specifying the hostname your site should respond to). Any configuration more involved than that moves it out of this realm and towards the dynamic systems that people are largely not running and not interested in running—for various reasons, including pricing, maintenance, and sheer complexity/brittleness. It's a place where you dump a directory of files and the host doesn't do much beyond serving that file with the appropriate media type, i.e. the only thing that people can reliably trust to work if and when they move all their crud to another host someday.

1. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/equivocation

Re:Mastodon Instance with 6 Files by vidarh on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @01:03PM (#33884392)
The problem with this is that the webfinger spec allows additional parameters (e.g. "rel"), so if you do this you violate the spec.

(EDIT: Actually given it does a full regex match it might work; though it'll return supersets of the intended results if rel= constraints are preset, and possibly break if the rel= argument is put after the "resource=" in the URL so would need refinement; of course it depends on using a server which allows arbitrary regex based rewrites, which rules out a lot of object storage etc.)

It may happen to work for some clients some of the time, until it suddenly doesn't.