Re:Supreme Court leans toward web designer with anti-gay mar...
by Georgelemental on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:31PM
(#33875557)
If a customer walks in requesting a cake with a swatzika and other Nazi insignia, should the bakery be allowed to refuse?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Supreme Court leans toward web designer with anti-gay mar...
by Nevermark on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:51PM
(#33875696)
Good question, thanks!
I think divisive political or social messages would fall under the providers right to decline based on personal morals, that don't involve making distinctions dependent on a protected customer class.
But it would be a problem if the cake maker was ok making very divisive cakes favorable to white supremacists, but then refused to make similarly divisive cakes associated with other races or religions. As that inconsistency would indicate the supplier was making distinctions based on protected classes (i.e. religion, race).
Re:Supreme Court leans toward web designer with anti-gay mar...
by Georgelemental on Monday December 05, 2022 @11:00PM
(#33875754)
What do you mean by "divisive"? How do you define that in a court of law?
Re:Supreme Court leans toward web designer with anti-gay mar...
by Nevermark on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @06:33PM
(#33888624)
The supplier can define divisive, or objectionable in general, in any way they want as long as it doesn't result in protected classes of people being treated differently.
A cake maker is fully within their rights to refuse to make blue cake, if they don't like blue, for example.
Re:Supreme Court leans toward web designer with anti-gay mar...
by roflyear on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:38PM
(#33875607)
Political speech has never been protected.
Re:Supreme Court leans toward web designer with anti-gay mar...
by Georgelemental on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:51PM
(#33875690)
Arguably, marriage and the family are political. "The personal is political" as the feminists say