Re:Supreme Court leans toward web designer with anti-gay mar...
by Georgelemental on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:31PM
(#33875557)
If a customer walks in requesting a cake with a swatzika and other Nazi insignia, should the bakery be allowed to refuse?
Re:Supreme Court leans toward web designer with anti-gay mar...
by Nevermark on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:51PM
(#33875696)
Good question, thanks!
I think divisive political or social messages would fall under the providers right to decline based on personal morals, that don't involve making distinctions dependent on a protected customer class.
But it would be a problem if the cake maker was ok making very divisive cakes favorable to white supremacists, but then refused to make similarly divisive cakes associated with other races or religions. As that inconsistency would indicate the supplier was making distinctions based on protected classes (i.e. religion, race).
Re:Supreme Court leans toward web designer with anti-gay mar...
by Georgelemental on Monday December 05, 2022 @11:00PM
(#33875754)
What do you mean by "divisive"? How do you define that in a court of law?
Re:Supreme Court leans toward web designer with anti-gay mar...
by Nevermark on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @06:33PM
(#33888624)
The supplier can define divisive, or objectionable in general, in any way they want as long as it doesn't result in protected classes of people being treated differently.
A cake maker is fully within their rights to refuse to make blue cake, if they don't like blue, for example.
Re:Supreme Court leans toward web designer with anti-gay mar...
by roflyear on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:38PM
(#33875607)
Political speech has never been protected.
Re:Supreme Court leans toward web designer with anti-gay mar...
by Georgelemental on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:51PM
(#33875690)
Arguably, marriage and the family are political. "The personal is political" as the feminists say
I have a practical interest in finding solutions to difficult moral problems.)
--
Clearly people shouldn't be discriminated against for the protected class they are in.
And yet people shouldn't be required to harness their own free speech for views that they find morally objectionable.
I don't see how any workable solution can dispense with either of those principles.
But I don't see any contradiction either. No discrimination based on customer class. But allowable service limits, on providing unique creative contributions to promoting ideas the supplier finds morally objectionable.
--
The distinction is between mechanical services, creative non-speech related services (always must be provided equally) vs. creative service directly involved in speech choices.
--
A cake maker should provide cakes to anyone. Put figures offered for sale on a cake in any way requested by a customer. Put any writing a customer wants on a cake. And even produce cakes in designs inherently celebrating any ideas, supporting the free speech of the customer.
But a cake maker can decline to come up with their own wording for phrases supporting ideas they don't agree with. And decline to make decisions regarding a custom cake specific to promoting an idea they morally cannot agree with personally.
So a gay couple should be able to get a unique cake made (from a maker of custom cakes), with rainbow colors (they chose), in a shape of a non-binary symbol (that they chose), with two male figures on top (at their direction). And the cake maker can be expected to apply their general creative calligraphy and cake shaping skills to make the cake presentable, without having to make any decisions about the ideas it represents that they may or may not have personal moral objections too.
--
The only other case I can think of is, suppliers should in general be able to decline projects that morally objectionable to them, as long as the moral objection isn't to something inherent in the equal rights of a protected class.
For instance, a request for a cake in the shape of genetalia can be rejected for being too obscene for the service provider. Given that they would decline such a cake for anyone of any class.