News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI Homework by ThalesX on Monday December 05, 2022 @11:19AM (#33867552)
I love talking to GPT, but I've tried using it for some serious stuff (research, biz-dev) and less than serious stuff (Dungeons & Dragons) and the magic is still there but it has obvious blind spots which might be solved in the future but we're talking about the present.

I am wholly amused how everyone got on that dude from Google that accused the AI of being sentient and Google about not caring, and now you have huge names in the tech industry kinda drooling over this with what I believe to be the same passion.

One was ridiculed, the others will continue to be our 'heroes'.

Re:AI Homework by rxhernandez on Monday December 05, 2022 @11:29AM (#33867710)
> One was ridiculed, the others will continue to be our 'heroes'.

I wish I was amused. Instead, I just feel a bit empty from the faith I lost in humanity years ago. I haven't found sufficient instances where:

1. People were held to be accountable for their actions as a group

2. Aren't unnecessarily cruel when it comes to thinking outside the group's consensus (even if said thinking has no real effects on the group)

(To clarify, I feel more confident in winning a lottery I've never played than that being an instance of a sentient AI; I just found that too many people were far too cruel to that person)

Re:AI Homework by dslowell on Monday December 05, 2022 @11:44AM (#33867955)
> I am wholly amused how everyone got on that dude from Google that accused the AI of being sentient and Google about not caring, and now you have huge names in the tech industry kinda drooling over this with what I believe to be the same passion.

Is it strange? Someone can be extremely impressed with how a Boston Dynamic robot moves, while also being entirely unconvinced by claims that the lifelike movement is a sign of sentience.

Re:AI Homework by gumby on Monday December 05, 2022 @12:55PM (#33869061)
> Someone can be extremely impressed with how a Boston Dynamic robot moves, while also being entirely unconvinced by claims that the lifelike movement is a sign of sentience.

Especially as those devices are all coded in a traditional manner, with no ML or NNs at all.

Re:AI Homework by wizzwizz4 on Monday December 05, 2022 @12:56PM (#33869081)
> while also being entirely unconvinced by claims that the lifelike movement is a sign of sentience.

Well, would one suspect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_Locomotion of being sentient?

Re:AI Homework by indigochill on Monday December 05, 2022 @12:03PM (#33868241)
There's a huge gap between "The breadth of training this AI has and the depth of its processing is impressive" and "This script is sentient". The latter is a _far_ broader (and unsubstantiated) claim.
Re:AI Homework by fauntle on Monday December 05, 2022 @12:15PM (#33868444)
The guy who suggested the AI was sentient was clearly wrong, and strange in a bad way. ChatGPT enthusiasts are just having a good time with a text generation AI. How did you even come up with this comparison?
Re:AI Homework by theptip on Monday December 05, 2022 @12:20PM (#33868519)
> drooling over this with what I believe to be the same passion.

Lemoine didn't get fired and mocked for being "passionate" about LaMDA, he got fired for breaching NDA and mocked for claiming that a LLM is sentient.

Ben Thompson isn't claiming ChatGPT is sentient, or that it has personhood, and that is the categorical difference. It's a far, far weaker claim that ChatGPT's text output is (perhaps) good enough to fool a school teacher in a school essay.

Re:AI Homework by sourcecodeplz on Monday December 05, 2022 @04:12PM (#33871996)
Not to mention when Google first started showing specific snippets for queries that could be answered with a sentence. People were up in arms that Google is stealing their content.

Come today and people seem to not mind so much. Is the same thing? Maybe not but it does look similar to me.