News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Using ChatGPT as a Co-Founder by O__________O on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:20AM (#33864125)
To be fair, Wikipedia also “speaks with confidence” and makes no attempt to make it easy to understand exactly how confident one should be in the facts presented. At one point they had said the would, but never did to my knowledge. Google has TrustRank, but to my knowledge it’s on a source-level basis, not fact-level basis.
Re:Using ChatGPT as a Co-Founder by FerociousTimes on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:32AM (#33864226)
The bot got it unequivocally wrong here.

When it said that the vast majority of what's now modern-day France spoke modern French as their native language, that's categorically false and shouldn't be treated with leniency or open to interpretations.

Re:Using ChatGPT as a Co-Founder by O__________O on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:11AM (#33864537)
My point is cherry picking flaws won’t help improve anything for ChatGPT, Wikipedia, etc — but systematic approaches to discovering and modeling information space and related fact, queries, etc would. Wikipedia not free of issues and to my knowledge does not allow end user to see Wikipedia’s confidence in a given fact, if they have one at all.
Re:Using ChatGPT as a Co-Founder by FerociousTimes on Monday December 05, 2022 @09:04AM (#33865767)
These sort of statements are by nature speculative not factual, and thus speakers are advised to express and communicate doubt, and hedge against uncertainty inherent in their views, and probably even vicious rebuttals, by using appropriate language constructs or terminology, but when a know-it-all bot that was trained by its handlers to pass always as an authority figure makes a mistake due to hubris or overconfidence, don't expect us to sit idle, and not call them out, and refute their claims accordingly.
Re:Using ChatGPT as a Co-Founder by O__________O on Monday December 05, 2022 @09:26AM (#33866035)
Understand, though where exactly does ChatGPT claim to be a source of factual information?

Wikipedia on the other hand does clearly state its intent to maintain reliability of its content:

- https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_and_fact-checking

- https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Reliability_of_Wikipedia

Beyond that, in my opinion, while human dialogue might hedge confidence, disclose conflicts of interest, etc — to me, assumed the exchange is via text-based chat — there are much more efficient and effective ways to express that information than adding non-actionable text like that.

Re:Using ChatGPT as a Co-Founder by cmeacham98 on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:29AM (#33866869)
> Understand, though where exactly does ChatGPT claim to be a source of factual information?

It doesn't right now, but if you scroll up, you'll see the idea at the beginning of this thread is to turn it into a source of information.

The difference between ChatGPT and Wikipedia for this purpose is that:

1. Wikipedia is wrong wayyyyyyyy less often than ChatGPT

2. Wikipedia has sources linked at the bottom of the page you can go check, while ChatGPT does not

Re:Using ChatGPT as a Co-Founder by Semaphor on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:32AM (#33864225)
> At one point they had said the would, but never did to my knowledge.

I think autocorrect or something mangled your sentence beyond recognition.

Re:Using ChatGPT as a Co-Founder by O__________O on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:06AM (#33864479)
What specifically is unclear?

Wikipedia said they would enable users at to be able to quickly tell what the confidence was in the facts being presented and to my knowledge never did. My understanding is that even now that linked sources are not even systematically checked to confirm they even relate to the related passage of text.

Re:Using ChatGPT as a Co-Founder by Semaphor on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:16AM (#33864598)
the -> they

That was probably readable by context for most, yet not for me ;)

Re:Using ChatGPT as a Co-Founder by O__________O on Monday December 05, 2022 @09:15AM (#33865889)
My bad, thanks for the clarification, even in rereading sentence, didn’t notice the error.