News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Archaeologists Ask Netflix to Reclassify Graham Hancock’s... by cryptonector on Sunday December 04, 2022 @10:28PM (#33861101)
Hancock has been arguing for a long time that a variety of stone age monuments around the world stem from a common cultural background, from a priest caste that spread around the world to build those monuments, and that they must have come from a civilization we have not yet discovered that was destroyed by the end of the last glacial period.

It's been a while since I've watched any of his documentaries, so I'm not sure if my above characterization is accurate anymore (or ever was -- maybe I misremember). But while there isn't much (if any) evidence yet for his proposition, it's really not that farfetched. Sea levels went up a lot, and many possible sites of a small but relatively advanced civilization can have been buried relatively quickly and in ways that are hard to find now (e.g., in the black sea). Whatever the case, such a civilization(s) was not that advanced, and it must have been fairly small, else they'd have spread to areas that would not have been destroyed by the end of the glacial period. The biggest problem I have with his proposition is that it's really difficult to imagine a "priest" caste maintaining the necessary knowledge, ideology, secrecy (comsec and opsec), willpower, and cohesion across hundreds of (perhaps over 1,000) generations and tens of thousands of miles.

Re:Archaeologists Ask Netflix to Reclassify Graham Hancock’s... by Shorel on Monday December 05, 2022 @03:51AM (#33863077)
It's not farfetched. But at the same time, it puts a lot of pressure in the immutability of oral traditions.

Back then, distances were simply bigger, both in actual distance and in time.

For a single culture to have been the origin, their message and mythos needed to be reproduced with precision through countless generations.

I am not saying this is impossible, and in fact it is plausible, just that this is a factor to take into account.

Re:Archaeologists Ask Netflix to Reclassify Graham Hancock’s... by zozbot234 on Monday December 05, 2022 @04:20AM (#33863270)
> Back then, distances were simply bigger, both in actual distance and in time.

I think it's been amply demonstrated that long-distance sea voyages were always feasible - which is how Oceania was populated in the first place. So the tales of ancient mariners bringing advanced knowledge to all sorts of peoples may well have some merit.

Re:Archaeologists Ask Netflix to Reclassify Graham Hancock’s... by cryptonector on Monday December 05, 2022 @11:48AM (#33868024)
It's plausible, but keeping all that knowledge and opsec going across 1,000 generations (or more) is... very challenging -- so challenging that I doubt it actually happened.