News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Administrators Have Seized the Ivory Tower by BurningFrog on Sunday December 04, 2022 @06:38PM (#33859314)
The only counter force I'm aware of is competition.

Organization A that is 80% devoted to serve it's bureaucracy will be outcompeted by Organization B which is only at 40%, presumably because it's younger.

That only works if they compete on productive end results, and I'm not sure how true that is for US universities.

Re:Administrators Have Seized the Ivory Tower by Ieghaehia9 on Sunday December 04, 2022 @06:57PM (#33859466)
Democracy combined with local units significantly valuing their autonomy also seems to work, e.g. the International Typographical Union example from Union Democracy.
Re:Administrators Have Seized the Ivory Tower by buitreVirtual on Sunday December 04, 2022 @07:02PM (#33859516)
That's usually the problem. There is virtually no competition within a state university system. Even in open markets, incumbents are bloated with bureaucracy and politics but succeed by digging trenches around them to keep new players out.
Re:Administrators Have Seized the Ivory Tower by bumby on Sunday December 04, 2022 @08:42PM (#33860338)
Universities have already lost their stranglehold on access to information. Now they focus on their monopoly of credentialism. If they lose that too they might face real competition and adjust course. There may be both bottom-up and top-down approaches to eroding that current monopoly.
Re:Administrators Have Seized the Ivory Tower by thebradbain on Monday December 05, 2022 @02:41AM (#33862677)
That’s why many institutions are focused on extra-academic investment: better amenities, better campuses, better sports teams, better housing, better “neighborhood investment” etc.

A school’s academics are, in a way, secondary to the school’s brand/influence (with built in networking effects in the alumni base)

Imagine some crazy world that education-level is a protected class for employment and it can’t be considered or explicitly asked about in job applications. The credential monopoly would be no more. Yet you would likely still see top colleges thrive for the same reason top fashion houses do: status signaling, brand loyalty, and a sense of belonging with patrons who subscribe to the same values

Re:Administrators Have Seized the Ivory Tower by analog31 on Sunday December 04, 2022 @07:42PM (#33859866)
But there's competition and competition. The US private health care system is supposedly competitive, but competes on the wrong things. I read a WSJ article purporting that cities with more health care competition had higher costs.

College could be another case where competition drives up costs.

Another option is to eliminate reasons to compete. Just standardize the offerings and the administrative structure required for a university. Students can choose the school that's closest to home, and go there with confidence.

Re:Administrators Have Seized the Ivory Tower by noobermin on Sunday December 04, 2022 @07:46PM (#33859893)
Sorry but this never happens in practice, this is an example of just pure ideology.

Every large (read stable) corporation has created it's own bureaucracy. The "scrappy start-ups" that become successful by becoming profitable in their own right (and are not merely bought up by the large corporations) eventually develop their own. There a serious lack of examples of successful large orgs where bureacracy is in fact minimal.

Mark Fischer in Capitalist Realism made a good note of this, how the capitalist world of the west recreated the bureacratic culture in a host of in what are its institutions (which are obstensibly businesses) that existed in soviet russia, and in many ways surpassed those systems.

Re:Administrators Have Seized the Ivory Tower by BurningFrog on Sunday December 04, 2022 @08:59PM (#33860471)
> Every large (read stable) corporation has created it's own bureaucracy. The "scrappy start-ups" that become successful by becoming profitable in their own right (and are not merely bought up by the large corporations) eventually develop their own.

Yes, that was even heavily implied in my post you're critiquing!

This cycle of very bureaucratic orgs being outcompeted by lightly bureaucratic orgs, which then grow very bureaucratic, and are in turn outcompeted, results in a medium bureaucracy level on average in the long run.

Re:Administrators Have Seized the Ivory Tower by woooooo on Monday December 05, 2022 @12:22AM (#33861796)
But how do you compete with Harvard? In practice, the bureaucracy has captured the brand and the brand is what students are buying.

It's more likely that the entire western system is outcompeted than it is that the current set of elite schools are outcompeted within our system, imo.

Re:Administrators Have Seized the Ivory Tower by rdtwo on Sunday December 04, 2022 @10:50PM (#33861245)
There are very few competitive industries. Most have consolidated in to 2-5 big companies that own most of the market. Often competitors are barred from entry due to regulations or other government force
Re:Administrators Have Seized the Ivory Tower by astrange on Sunday December 04, 2022 @11:06PM (#33861335)
3-5 companies is enough to be competitive. If there were lots of small ones it truly would be impossible to regulate; that’s why there when there’s a public utility, there’s only one of it.