News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Fire Them All; God Will Know His Own: Harvard's 7,024 Administrators. Parent comment

Re:Fire Them All; God Will Know His Own: Harvard's 7,024 Adm... by kyrra on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:35PM (#33833725)
Can the universities prove that whatever process they have now (or is trying to do) is better than a pure meritocracy? Obviously we would need to agree on what "better" means here (ie: what outcomes they are measuring).

The question to you is, how do you measure "needs to be more than that". If this isn't something that you can't quantify, it's just going to let administrators pick students to satisfy whatever the current cultural hot button issue is.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Fire Them All; God Will Know His Own: Harvard's 7,024 Adm... by throwaway23236 on Friday December 02, 2022 @03:25PM (#33836397)
That is a good question. I think the university should decide on the "why" and base candidates off of that. And you are are right, much like picking a hire, a best friend, your spouse, there is a lot that isn't quantifiable.

4.0 student who you interview and they come off as a Jerk, they are smart as hell or a 3.93 student who is passionate about learning, wants to be there, and is a humble person. Which do you want affecting your school's culture?

[ Parent | on HN ]