News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s Latest Patent Victory: In-Call Multitasking by DiabloD3 on Thursday December 22, 2011 @08:39AM (#3381452)
Android did it first, so wtf prior art?
Re:Apple’s Latest Patent Victory: In-Call Multitasking by ugh on Thursday December 22, 2011 @08:49AM (#3381482)
Do not take this as me defending Apple (I certainly don’t want to). This is only a statement about technical capability and not supposed to endorse or support Apple with this in any way.

The very first iPhone had multitasking during calls (and multitasking in general). The first Android phone came out after the first iPhone so your statement can’t be correct.

Again, this is in no way an endorsement of Apple’s behavior.

Re:Apple’s Latest Patent Victory: In-Call Multitasking by Terretta on Thursday December 22, 2011 @09:09AM (#3381532)
> this is in no way an endorsement of Apple’s behavior

As if Apple invented the Kodak/Nokia/Motorola/Qualcomm portfolio licensing pricing game.

(Though at least these companies invent and sell things, a point Joe Wilcox forgets when he lobs accusations of patent trolling at them.)

Re:Apple’s Latest Patent Victory: In-Call Multitasking by Kylekramer on Thursday December 22, 2011 @09:12AM (#3381539)
Just like the much else about patent world, being first to build a dubious portfolio to shut down competition doesn't mean much. It is still behavior unworthy of endorsement.
Re:Apple’s Latest Patent Victory: In-Call Multitasking by Terretta on Thursday December 22, 2011 @01:29PM (#3382636)
Being first to invent and first to market a device that rethought users' interaction with phones, and therefore unquestionably "changed the game", means quite a lot.

Patent litigation behavior among cell phone makers to settle licensing scores is the real prior art here, and that's what is "unworthy of endorsement".

That the inventors of this behavior turned on the newcomer (even to the point of trying to withdraw patent pool patents) is even less worthy of endorsement.

To me, the question is: why is this the playing field?

Why call Apple out for playing by the rules the others set long before Apple joined the game and upset the incumbents? Why demand Apple to be held to different standards? Why not talk about the industry as a whole instead of naming Apple (see: patents, Foxconn conditions, signal drop when cupped in hand, etc.)?

Given the problem is the playing field and rules set before Apple had a phone to sell, why not try to do something about that, instead of condemning Apple for currently doing better at the incumbents' game than the incumbents? (A situation nobody seems to believe will last anyway.)

Re:Apple’s Latest Patent Victory: In-Call Multitasking by rimantas on Thursday December 22, 2011 @08:49AM (#3381481)
When? iPhone had this type of multitasking since day one. It was multitasking for third-party apps what was missing.
Re:Apple’s Latest Patent Victory: In-Call Multitasking by DiabloD3 on Thursday December 22, 2011 @09:50AM (#3381657)
This answers my question. I do not (and have never) owned a cell phone, so the iphone hype and android hype gets confusing.
Re:Apple’s Latest Patent Victory: In-Call Multitasking by markokocic on Thursday December 22, 2011 @10:20AM (#3381757)
Nokia Symbian phones had this waaay before iPhone.
Re:Apple’s Latest Patent Victory: In-Call Multitasking by purephase on Thursday December 22, 2011 @09:31AM (#3381594)
Actually, my Blackberry did this 8-9 years ago.
Re:Apple’s Latest Patent Victory: In-Call Multitasking by viraptor on Thursday December 22, 2011 @09:35AM (#3381609)
Unfortunately they limit the patent to touchscreen devices. Otherwise, I'd say that my sl45i did that almost 11 years ago.