News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web browsers drop mysterious company with ties to U.S. mi... by charcircuit on Thursday December 01, 2022 @04:14AM (#33814050)
>there was substantial evidence

circumstantial evidence, but nothing that was definitive

>The CA had no substantial public certificate issuing program

So just because they don't have enough customers they should be removed? This just promotes centralization of trust.

Re:Web browsers drop mysterious company with ties to U.S. mi... by DoctorNick on Thursday December 01, 2022 @04:21AM (#33814086)
It really doesn’t matter if it was circumstantial or not. When presented with such evidence, the TrustCor rep was extremely evasive. This isn’t a court of law; if a Root CA can’t be up-front about explaining evidence that calls their trust into question, then they cannot be trusted and deserve to have their certificates yanked.
Re:Web browsers drop mysterious company with ties to U.S. mi... by dcow on Thursday December 01, 2022 @04:32AM (#33814154)
They were under attack. I actually read the whole thread and they were crystal clear.
Re:Web browsers drop mysterious company with ties to U.S. mi... by ranguna on Thursday December 01, 2022 @05:00AM (#33814343)
Yeah I personally feel for the rep, they were indeed under attack. But there is no going around it, a company that advertised a product as being e2e encrypted when it really was not, having multiple levels of ties with the CA was enough to deem the CA as unfit.

I agree with this conclusion because the CA ecosystem is a fragile one if not governed strictly, since the risks are of the highest concern to the general use of the Internet.

Re:Web browsers drop mysterious company with ties to U.S. mi... by netheril96 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @04:53AM (#33814294)
> circumstantial evidence, but nothing that was definitive

CAs should be assumed guilty until proven otherwise.

Re:Web browsers drop mysterious company with ties to U.S. mi... by simplotek on Thursday December 01, 2022 @05:35AM (#33814559)
> circumstantial evidence, but nothing that was definitive

That's not how things work. The role of a Certificate Authority is to act as a trusted third party. If that third party is unable or unwilling to demonstrate that they are trustworthy then naturally they can't be expected to assume that role.