Re:How an early oil industry study became key in climate law...
by bcrosby95 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @03:28PM
(#33807160)
> is that they can't help but give their "expert" opinion on every topic, even if they are not an actual expert
Aka being human.
This all says more about the people invoking it than the supposed effect.
That is, they expect otherwise smart people to not behave like people. But they do, and they talk about subjects they have no clue about, just like everyone else.
However, it is remarkable that some predicted it, as not everyone was paying attention.
One issue with "scientists" (and engineers, as well as other humans, including me and you, and everyone on HN) is that they can't help but give their "expert" opinion on every topic, even if they are not an actual expert (related to Dunning-Kruger, although I was recently pointed out[1] that what people call DK is not what the paper was about).
And, from my experience, we tend to attach more credibility to claims by famous people than from skilled people. Or at least broadcast them more. Einstein said that after he became famous, people started asking his opinion on any topic, from politics to football.
[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29141367