News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How an early oil industry study became key in climate law... by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:18PM (#33805058)
19th Century Scientists also claimed that heavier than air flight would be impossible.

19th century scientists though that space was filled with ether.

The 19th century scientists predicted global warming trope is basically survival bias.

Re:How an early oil industry study became key in climate law... by MayeulC on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:50PM (#33805622)
Indeed, and I am not sure if there was a consensus on that topic back then.

However, it is remarkable that some predicted it, as not everyone was paying attention.

One issue with "scientists" (and engineers, as well as other humans, including me and you, and everyone on HN) is that they can't help but give their "expert" opinion on every topic, even if they are not an actual expert (related to Dunning-Kruger, although I was recently pointed out[1] that what people call DK is not what the paper was about).

And, from my experience, we tend to attach more credibility to claims by famous people than from skilled people. Or at least broadcast them more. Einstein said that after he became famous, people started asking his opinion on any topic, from politics to football.

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29141367

Re:How an early oil industry study became key in climate law... by bcrosby95 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @03:28PM (#33807160)
> is that they can't help but give their "expert" opinion on every topic, even if they are not an actual expert

Aka being human.

This all says more about the people invoking it than the supposed effect.

That is, they expect otherwise smart people to not behave like people. But they do, and they talk about subjects they have no clue about, just like everyone else.

Re:How an early oil industry study became key in climate law... by MayeulC on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:34AM (#33866937)
Well, I'm guilty of it myself, but I try to pay attention. It's a trap that can be avoided to some extent if both the audience/interviewer and interviewee are aware of it.
Re:How an early oil industry study became key in climate law... by compiskey on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @02:03PM (#33805848)
They didn’t predict global warming. They measured directly industrial emission accumulation and predicted an impact on human health.

Global warming is a colloquialism. The researchers did the science that gives rise to it.

Luminiferous Aether is just another name for electromagnetic field effects. Which do literally exist but our written logic works out better if we talk around it as an idea not a thing.

You’re just arguing semantics to look smurt. Qualitative ideas like survivorship bias are relative in when they apply.

Re:How an early oil industry study became key in climate law... by btilly on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @03:11PM (#33806945)
For anyone who wants to dig further on this, http://ponce.sdsu.edu/global_warming_science.html explains the actual reasoning of the paper that came closest, which was an 1896 paper that laid out all of the actual facts behind global warming, minus the prediction that a rapid increase in usage of fossil fuels actually WOULD cause global warming. The author of that paper did come to the correct conclusion not long after, but I'm not aware of any record of his doing so before the year 1900.

The paper itself is available at http://ponce.sdsu.edu/arrhenius_paper_1896.pdf.

The first newspaper article that I'm aware of predicting global warming was in 1912. See https://theconversation.com/for-110-years-climate-change-has... for more on that story.

Re:How an early oil industry study became key in climate law... by jstanley on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @02:16PM (#33806034)
The ether was a proposed explanation for electromagnetism.
Re:How an early oil industry study became key in climate law... by compiskey on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @02:37PM (#33806375)
Right; it came about as experiments suggested something actually did exist.

It’s not the same kind of gibberish “mechanical flight is impossible” ended up being.

Re:How an early oil industry study became key in climate law... by btilly on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @03:45PM (#33807407)
In the defense of 19th century scientists, the best approximate solutions to the Navier-Stokes equations really did predict that mechanical aircraft should not be able to fly, curve balls should not curve in the air, and so on.

It was not until 1904 that Ludwig Prandtl published Über Flüssigkeitsbewegung bei sehr kleiner Reibung (On the Motion of Fluids in Very Little Friction) which first discovered the importance of boundary layers. The breakdown of approximations in those boundary layers allows for all sorts of behaviors that came as a surprise. In time science caught up up with practical engineering advances to finally understand how airplanes can fly, pitchers can throw curve balls, and so on. And even so, those old approximations are still used because they are mostly right!

So they were wrong, but it wasn't gibberish either.

For a similar example of a mostly correct scientific theory producing wrong results, until near the end of the 20th century the linear wave model predicted that rogue waves were impossible. Today we can look back at shipwreck records and laugh at their stupidity. But in fact you can spend a week looking at every wave that passes a point and probably won't find even a single wave that doesn't fit the theory.

Scientific overconfidence in well-tested theories is a systemic error that we are likely to always be prone to. Most of the time it is well justified. But we do nobody a favor by dismissing past examples of this as "gibberish".

Re:How an early oil industry study became key in climate law... by kjkjadksj on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @02:08PM (#33805922)
We believe ancient greek math but not their religion today
Re:How an early oil industry study became key in climate law... by est31 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @04:07PM (#33807699)
Survival is how science works. Some theories are proven wrong, others are proven right. The theories that are proven wrong are often still quite accurate except for some edge cases. We shouldn't use our advantage of having one entire century plus two decades of research history to ridicule scientists from 100 years ago. They didn't have python, excel or pocket calculators. Yet they were able to derive really fancy rules and laws. I think that's really impressive, even if they were wrong on some things. We are likely wrong on some things too, doesn't mean we should discard all of our science.